I test drove an Aygo last September when I was still looking at buying a new car. I returned it with a "thanks, but I'll keep my 12 year old rust bucket".
As mentioned:
- The gearbox is dreadful. It's like stirring porridge to find the right gear and then it doesn't feel like it's selected correctly when it's in.
- It's not nippy. It feels like it has no guts at all, mainly because you've got a 1L 67bhp engine strapped to something which weighs 830kg. In fairness this was in comparison to the car I was coming from which had 74bhp but weighed only 830kg. The Starlet was *much* nippier.
- There is no room in the boot. There was enough room in the front for me at 6'4 which is good, but there wasn't really enough room for a passenger in the back afterwards.
As for the handling, that was slightly more interesting. It doesn't handle too badly from it's near square wheelbase, but I wasn't up for putting it round the sharp corners near me at 60 like I did with the Starlet.
Final point would be that when I was driving it back on the motorway it sounded awful at 70mph and it wasn't really up for going much faster. In fairness this was the real killer for me as I was doing 12k motorway miles a year.
In the end I ended up with a £2.2k 8 year old Ibiza TDI. Not bad on fuel, loads of room, fast as hell compared to the Aygo and it was a third of the price.
