Well according to MMORPG.com -
http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/post/4496861#4496861
Which game will you play
GW2 - 44.8%
SWTOR - 24.1%
Googling for many other such threads clearly shows GW2 being hugely favored over SWTOR.
People seem to heavily underestimate GW2 and Arenanet, I'll never have any idea why.
and he clearly has an agenda against almost all rival MMORPGs.
I just dont play, nor like crap games. SWTOR is looking like a blatant WoWclone, we have seen enough of those already and they hardly ever do well.
There's also millions of followers for GW2, much more anticipated then a Star Wars game.
People just wont understand, nor recognize how hugely successful GW1 and Arenanet actually are compared to MMOs other than WoW.
The fact that it's BioWare and is the next game in The Knights of the Old Republic
GW1 alone is massively bigger than any game that Bioware have ever released. And Dragon Age II was great wasnt it?

.
Bioware also have no experience whatsoever in the MMO industry, this is the first one they are making, and their approach is simply to copy the old and boring gameplay from WoW, and whatever it was that existed before then. Arenanet on the other hand are constantly pushing forward Online RPG innovation, creating ideas and games that are radically different to anything else out there, and focusing on ironing out the flaws of the traditional MMO while implementing gameplay features that their already huge fanbase actually enjoy.
2.) It's Star Wars, I've heard the brand is kind of popular.
The film is very popular yes. None of the Star Wars games so far, in terms of sales figures have been anywhere close to impressive.
That wikipedia list looks quite questionable. Plus it includes all the expansions as part of the game so the total amount of purchases is nowhere near that figure
Actually GW1 surpassed the 7 million+ sales point earlier this year, recent sales simply havnt yet been added to the official figures. GW1 also only has 1 expansion, and 3 seperate stand alone games.
Yet people on this forum act like Guild Wars is like some minor, completely unheard of game compared to anything that Bioware have ever created
Meh, and I missed the most obvious point - GW no fees, SWTOR fees. The market for new fee based MMOs is tiny due to WoW still going strong with over 10 million subs. Barely any other fee based MMO has had any success since WoW because the vast majority of people who pay fees are unwilling to play anything but WoW, and most of the others have had to go FTP.