If it's topping out at 60 and not really dropping below that, I'd say it's capped in some form - there's obviously no shortfall in your system, so it's the only reasonable explanation.
Out of interest, what class & spec are you? And what's your ilvl? When I started again recently my ret pala was still kitted out in mostly T11 stuff, but I could still get up to 18-20k easy enough on the new Twilight HC bosses. Check out the changelog for your spec, could be that something key has been nerfed like my poor Hammer of Wrath - first they take our bubble hearth, then they put Word of Glory on a CD and now they've taken the nerfbat to one of our core skills! Why does Blizzard hate DPS paladins so much?
Out of interest, what class & spec are you? And what's your ilvl? When I started again recently my ret pala was still kitted out in mostly T11 stuff, but I could still get up to 18-20k easy enough on the new Twilight HC bosses. Check out the changelog for your spec, could be that something key has been nerfed like my poor Hammer of Wrath - first they take our bubble hearth, then they put Word of Glory on a CD and now they've taken the nerfbat to one of our core skills! Why does Blizzard hate DPS paladins so much?

.
