There are only three real superhero movies to consider this year, let's forget Ghost Rider was ever made 
So as in the thread title, which of these do you think will be the winning movie for you?
For me it's TDKR for a few simple reasons, the first two are excellent movies, it's got Nolan directing & Tom Hardy is starring as Bane...my only worry is Hathaway. I know people are saying we had the same worries about Ledger, the thing is, Ledger was already an excellent actor before he did TDK, Hathaway is nowhere near his level.
Then we have the rest of TDKR actors, you won't find many other movies, let alone superhero movies out that have acting calibre the likes of Christian Bale, Gary Oldman, Michael Caine, Liam Neeson, Morgan Freeman, Joseph Gordon-Levitt & Aiden Gillen.
When it comes to AA, Hulk & Iron Man were fantastic movies, IM2 & Thor were entertaining but nothing special and let's not think about Captain America. I think it's way too many strong characters to try and fit into one movie. It's also directed by Whedon while great for TV, i'm not convinced he can do much for film. One big plus point for AA though, Black Widow, those lips and that hair
AA's only has a few strong actors...Robert Downey JR, Samuel L Jackson, Mark Ruffalo and Stellan Skarsgard. While many of the other actors are well known, they are fairly middle of the road actors who'll take just about any role going (Evans, Johansson, Renner, Hemsworth). I personally don't rate Paltrow, she's has never engaged me in any movie i've watched.
As for TAS, I really like Garfield as an actor, much better than limp Maguire. However i'm already biased towards the reboot/remake/cash-in as I never liked the original trilogy very much, it didn't capture the essence of the comics for me. Casting wise, aside from Martin Sheen and Rhys Ifans, it's relatively new actors who i'm yet to form opinions on until they have more movies under their belt.
So as in the thread title, which of these do you think will be the winning movie for you?For me it's TDKR for a few simple reasons, the first two are excellent movies, it's got Nolan directing & Tom Hardy is starring as Bane...my only worry is Hathaway. I know people are saying we had the same worries about Ledger, the thing is, Ledger was already an excellent actor before he did TDK, Hathaway is nowhere near his level.
Then we have the rest of TDKR actors, you won't find many other movies, let alone superhero movies out that have acting calibre the likes of Christian Bale, Gary Oldman, Michael Caine, Liam Neeson, Morgan Freeman, Joseph Gordon-Levitt & Aiden Gillen.
When it comes to AA, Hulk & Iron Man were fantastic movies, IM2 & Thor were entertaining but nothing special and let's not think about Captain America. I think it's way too many strong characters to try and fit into one movie. It's also directed by Whedon while great for TV, i'm not convinced he can do much for film. One big plus point for AA though, Black Widow, those lips and that hair
AA's only has a few strong actors...Robert Downey JR, Samuel L Jackson, Mark Ruffalo and Stellan Skarsgard. While many of the other actors are well known, they are fairly middle of the road actors who'll take just about any role going (Evans, Johansson, Renner, Hemsworth). I personally don't rate Paltrow, she's has never engaged me in any movie i've watched.
As for TAS, I really like Garfield as an actor, much better than limp Maguire. However i'm already biased towards the reboot/remake/cash-in as I never liked the original trilogy very much, it didn't capture the essence of the comics for me. Casting wise, aside from Martin Sheen and Rhys Ifans, it's relatively new actors who i'm yet to form opinions on until they have more movies under their belt.
IM1 - Excellent. Hulk - Atrocious. IM2 - Excellent. Thor - Great. Captain America - Good.
