Poll: Best Winger in the PL?

[Gilly]

.

Who do you support?

 

[bagsjoni]

Liverpool fc

 

[Pighardia]

Bale.

Stupidly quick and a world class cross. Only pathetic finishing has stopped him getting a ridiculous number of assists.

This exactly.

lol at Lennon getting votes

 

[Nossmayo]

Tough one this, but for me Bale edges it over Valencia.

 

[Dark Kyon]

Bale. A talented young man

 

[Shamikebab]

Who do you support?

Liverpool fc

You've gone quiet Gilly

 

[JDeeLFC]

Downing was there for the lolz

Thank god you said that! I was going to slap you haha.

 

[JDeeLFC]

Valencia without doubt. Bale is a quality player but in terms of being a "winger" its Valencia. Bale could do exactly the same up front and be just as good.

 

[Gilly]

You've gone quiet Gilly

I hadn't seen his response. If Downing is all he gets to watch I'm not surprised he thinks Nani is awesome

 

[JustBen]

I think Valencia is a great winger! Out and out winger

 

[crackerman]

I believe what Tom's trying to do is create a team based on the results of each of these polls. It would have been better had he told us what formation he had in mind or in this poll on "wingers", maybe expanded it to include wide midfielders & wide forwards.

I voted for Bale (I don't want to have to explain why) as I assume we'll have another poll for the best "2nd striker/in the whole/off the front" player that will include the likes of Mata and Silva. If we aren't and it's going to be a 4-4-2 then I'd have wanted to pick Silva or Mata as my "winger".

In hindsight maybe Tom should have done a poll for the best formation to use, then he could work the players around that formation.

 

[cm1179]

come on, Tom84. as much as it's going to pain you to do it, bale has won and in the team he goes

 

[Pighardia]

Both wing positions are pretty comprehensively decided.

 

[Tom84]

come on, Tom84. as much as it's going to pain you to do it, bale has won and in the team he goes

Only 4 votes in it, little early to be calling a comprehensive win for Monkey boy yet

Both wing positions are pretty comprehensively decided.

Like I said before the amount of votes for the remaining positions will dictate the formation

 

[wedgie]

Top two nailed on now, so this makes no difference, but my vote goes to Nani.

Not an easy choice this because there's at least 3 players that can be justified easily, in the end I can't help but go with the flair player over the more consistent but workmanlike Valencia.

However, I accept it's possible that although not intentionally, I am overlooking Nani's flaws because he plays for my team.

 

[McBain]

21 votes for Nani

Was a tough choice between bale and Valencia. Went with Bale.

 

[Tom84]

21 votes for Nani

 

[Ryan-3]

Bale.

And it does say winger, not striker, so his goals aren't as relevant as the assists. (not that i've seen any official stats.)

 

[Pighardia]

A bit worried by 2 votes for Walcott, and 3 for Lennon

 

[McBain]

Im equally confused what with 21 people selecting Nani over Valencia/Bale.