Noisy neighbour stabbed to death

Meridian said:
I would imagine that he convinced the jury that he had no plan to use the knife. Given the circumstances, it's possible he took it along for protection, as he was likely aware that there were a lot of people in the flat. If he planned to hurt or kill her from the outset, it would seem a tad silly to do it with so many witnesses. If there was no intent to use the weapon, and the attack was spur-of-the-moment, then it;s not murder.
Click to expand...

As I said, the facts must be extraordinary - carrying a knife is a strong indicator of an intention to cause grievous bodily harm.
 
Nitefly said:
The facts must be fascinating.... stabbed her with a knife and killed her, yet manslaughter!
Click to expand...


He must have raged, id have gave her and one of a friends a drug overdose, turned the music loud and then stood outside shouting and calling the police.

Do you think I'd get done for murder or manslaughter?
 
According to the local rag "The St Helens Star" she was due to be evicted a few days after this incident....

Prosecutors alleged the knifing happened in the early hours of Saturday, July 23, 2011, about 40 minutes after Lyon told another neighbour he was going to kill Miss Dyer if she did not stop playing music which was keeping him awake.

She had been due to be evicted from her flat above his home in Chapel Street, St Helens, three days later following repeated complaints by Lyon about her noisy conduct.
Click to expand...

source - http://www.sthelensstar.co.uk/news/9985154.Man_gets_10_years_for_fatal_stabbing_of_Heather_Dyer/

While she was no doubt a nuisance she didnt deserve to die for it.
 
Should've given him a medal!

unlawful wounding at Liverpool Crown Court
Click to expand...

eh?

and our thoughts remain with the family of Heather Dyer and with William Taylor, who was seriously injured during the incident.
Click to expand...

Ah but not the thoughts of the poor man who had to have his life ruined night after night by music and you *** did *** all about it?.
 
Last edited:
hyperst said:
I swear people in this part of the forum post nonsense like this to get a reaction, am I wrong?
Click to expand...

You obviously never experienced noise pollution first hand.

When you can't get sleep because of it your mental state becomes erratic. Sleep deprivation is actually a form of torture.
 
norm said:
You obviously never experienced noise pollution first hand.

When you can't get sleep because of it your mental state becomes erratic. Sleep deprivation is actually a form of torture.
Click to expand...

Yep

Flat neighbour at the top of mine, Music from 11pm till 4am every night, boom boom boom boom... You try to sleep, the boom boom boom goes through your earplugs, your heart races. You feel ill, you fear going to bed or coming home. Then the quietness and silence, sleep then suddenly BOOM BOOM BOOM 2am in the morning, your chest hurts. You want to kill them, you go insane, your mind races.

I've been through it, i feel for the poor guy 10years was wrong. He should've been given much less and questions need to have been asked why wasn't this horrible family dealt with before it got this far
 
hyperst said:
I swear people in this part of the forum post nonsense like this to get a reaction, am I wrong?
Click to expand...

Yes, you're wrong.

Be thankful you've never experienced a noisy neighbour. I can fully understand why someone could be pushed over the edge and do something like this.
 
You are all idiots, if you can condone taking a persons life over some noise, you need a reality check, seriously.

If you have noisy neighbors and don't like it, move house/flat/area, or get them evicted, she had 3 days left before being evicted.
 
hyperst said:
You are all idiots, if you can condone taking a persons life over some noise, you need a reality check, seriously.

If you have noisy neighbors and don't like it, move house/flat/area, or get them evicted, she had 3 days left before being evicted.
Click to expand...

But his life was being ruined by the noise torture. Torture is worse than death, that's why the government is allowed to kill people but not torture them.
 
hyperst said:
You are all idiots, if you can condone taking a persons life over some noise, you need a reality check, seriously.

If you have noisy neighbors and don't like it, move house/flat/area, or get them evicted, she had 3 days left before being evicted.
Click to expand...

Well i'd rather be an idiot for condoning what has happened than that poor sod who suffered night after night of utter torture.

Hate people like that they don't deserve to be on this earth destroying other peoples lives.
 
for those that dont wish to be stabbed;)

10zmmwn.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom