Is this game better than the second?
Imagine Assassin's Creed on an island and you're half way there.
It's definitely better than FC2 because I've spent about five hours in it now, which is about three more than I ever managed in Malaria Quest. And I am now collecting relics rather than diamonds. Diamonds are a girl's best friend, so relics are clearly an improvement.
It is... fun in parts. Not full price fun IMO, but fun... if you can wade past the initial barriers to entry for PC gamers; like crafting items you ought to be able to make from readily available materials, annoyingly limited saves, and islands teeming with wildlife and guns... not a combination you find for long, generally.
You may also find it puzzling why people keep leaving money all over the place, and items in chests which are so nasty that they'd even get rejected by Bargain Hunt teams. I guess the money might have come from already selling the good stuff on Flog It.
Approach it like a five year old, let it hold your hand, do as you're told for a few hours and -- if you're good -- they'll let you play in the sandbox on your own later on. Just don't come running back to mummy when the nasty save monster steals your pocket money.
One really good user mod could sort this game out though. It has the most user friendly (if limited at this stage) editor I've ever messed with, so I'm hopeful that the under the hood stuff might be just as easy for talented people to play with.
I'd probably be happy with a simple quick save at this stage! Although some scenarios might be interesting to play in different ways, playing them from the very start in different ways requires more motivation than I have. Not when there are always other titles to explore.