Beginner's Question - Should I go for SDD

Associate
Joined
19 May 2004
Posts
1,046
Location
Horsham, West Sussex
I have just refreshed my son's PC. It started off when the MoBo died (bad capacitors) and I intended to get it up and running as cheaply as possible.

But as usually, upgraditis took over and it is now spec'ed much higher than I originally intended.

At the time I did consider putting in a 128GB SDD alongside the original 320GB HDD.

But in the end I decided to just go with a newer SATA III 1TB.

I'm now having reconsiderations, but still not convinced what benefits an SDD would bring.

Here is my thinking :-

I appreciate that they are faster, but that is for loading and once the programme is in RAM the disk speed is of little relevence.

When talking speed increase we are talking a boot taking 15 seconds rather than a minute, or a program loading in 5 secs rather than 15 seconds. Orders of magnitude bigger but in absolute terms saving you a few seconds waiting.

From what I've read, contrary to what you would normally excpect, SDDs are less relaible than HDDs.

The small size is inconvenient - making you put thought into what you store where, juggling things around when you run out of space and tidying up (TRIM) to keep performance decent as the disk fills.

And I would expect to pay around the £80 mark (maybe a little cheaper). Would I be better adding an extra £30-£40 to upgrade the graphics card from HD4870 to something like a HD7850 instead.

Cheers,

Nigel
 
Last edited:
Every machine I own now has an SSD in it, mechanical HDD seem so slow in comparison.

Just do it, you won't regret it!
 
Okay, supplementary question.

SATA II vs SATA III

I get the impression that with mechanical drives SATA III is a bit of a marketing spin, because whilst the MoBo and the HDD may have SATA III interfaces, the tecnology simply can't move data that fast can't even fill SATA II bandwidth.

So the net result for mechanical drives is that the performance of SATA II and SATA III drives is practically the same.


But is the same true for SSD?

Cheers,

Nigel
 
sata2 speed ssd is around 260mb read/write

sata3 speed ssd is around 550mb read 450-550mb write

you'll need a motherboard with intel sata3 speed ports to see the full sata3 rated speeds
 
sata2 speed ssd is around 260mb read/write

sata3 speed ssd is around 550mb read 450-550mb write

you'll need a motherboard with intel sata3 speed ports to see the full sata3 rated speeds

And although the difference between 260mb/s and 500mb/s seems large, the real world experience isn't so great. The main improvement experienced when upgrading to SSD is from the much lower access times.
 
Guys, read posts before you comment blindly. The guys asking if he should buy a small SSD, or upgrade his sons graphics card which is an HD4870.

What do you think his son would want? A faster boot up time or infinitely better gaming performance?

Get the graphics card.
 
Guys, read posts before you comment blindly. The guys asking if he should buy a small SSD, or upgrade his sons graphics card which is an HD4870.

What do you think his son would want? A faster boot up time or infinitely better gaming performance?

Get the graphics card.

With all due respect, he has asked other questions too, and I'm sure some of our answers may have helped him understand a little more about a possible SSD upgrade.

He hasn't specifically stated that his son plays many games, or uses his PC for more "serious" stuff. If it is a games machine, then going from a 4870 to a 7850 would be a good idea. A gfx card upgrade and an SSD upgrade would be even better (if finances allow).
 
Back
Top Bottom