Remind me on how many goals the both of them have in the EPL?
Don't just hate for the sake of hating.
goal threat, we played a ball to him, he ran at goal with it and won a penalty. I don't think I've seen Giroud do this yet. He is incapable of being a goal threat except inside the 6 yard box, where just about anyone capable of standing up is classed as a goal threat.
Give the ball to Suarez outside the box today, there was a chance he could score or set up a goal for someone else. Knock the ball up to Giroud basically anywhere on the pitch...... nothing at all, for 2 years, he has zero ability to run on the ball, he has zero ability to beat a man, he is quite honestly a terrible terrible striker. His interplay(primarily when stood still) isn't bad, that is simply not enough for a player.
Chamakh I class as a significantly higher goal threat, he does SO much more for the team. Against Arsenal Chamakh was really good, he held the ball up, passed well enough and defended excellently on all but one occasion, and it's not surprising to see a striker not defend brilliantly for 90 mins, particularly against a midget who is much faster than him.
Where was Giroud's fight, defensive work rate, marking of players, physicality, ability to hold the ball up to bring others into a game, control the ball to prevent Liverpool attacking.
Giroud was the epitome of **** today and I found it ironic that Chamakh, deemed as not good enough has done a hell of a lot more for his team this year than Giroud for us. the majority of the goals Giroud has gotten can be scored by just about any striker, he's had a handful of good games and none of them involved excellent "strikers" play.
I can't really remember, outside Ameobi, the last striker so incapable of running at defenders.
Giroud "ran" at the defence once all game, he pretty much lost control and ran into a defender. None of them panicked, they didn't rush out and foul him, they didn't need to risk a foul, he just handed the ball back. Chamakh had a good chance to run at the defence, won a penalty, scored the goal. Liverpool at no stage throughout the whole game ever found Giroud difficult to cope with, unpredictable, he did nothing at all for the team today, if he's outside the 6 yard box you can basically forget he's on the pitch, that is embarrassing.