Heh, I would bet my student loan (what's left of it) on the majority of people in this thread saying WoW having never played it for any decent amount of time, or even to max level (you know, where all the content is). Its like saying you hate a car you've never driven because the seat is uncomfortable. I can understand hating what it stands for, complete market dominance due to time investment of players squashing any possible innovation in the MMO genre though, in which case I would agree.
Anywho, my list is probably:
RAGE - I see a lot of people saying they really liked RAGE and I just can't figure out why, yeah it looks all right but its just brown and more brown, the story is utter garbage and the combat is total bog standard modern FPS.
Guild Wars 2 - A pathetic shell of its former self with no content and no fun.
MGS 4 - No idea why anyone enjoys this cut-scene filled pretentious pile of nonsense.