Are you overweight?

You're supposed to be thin, you know.

Exactly but a better word is lean.

You wouldn't see our ancient ancestors chasing prey for three days across the savannah if they were a little chunky (be that excess fat or excess muscle), would you?

I'm lean but after four decades it takes a lot of effort and good eating to remain in shape.
 
Can you exercise with a zimmer frame?

Try walking to the bottom of your garden and back, then to the nearest lamppost and then to the next one. Just very small steps you don't have to start walking miles. Maybe in a few weeks you might make it to the end of your road.

This is a short video, very inspiring of a big chap who pretty much done what I posted above and now he's thin and healthy and running marathons.

 
The BMI method is flawed and useless. I have no idea why it's still used.

It is flawed, but it is not useless. For the vast majority of society it gives a reasonable suggestion of a good weight range. There are people that are carrying a lot of muscle mass that are out of the range but still a healthy weight, but in the grand scheme of things they are relatively few. There are very few that are actually in the obese or higher range who genuinely couldn't do with losing SOME fat even if it would not be realistic to aim for <25 BMI.

A lot of people want to kid themselves that because BMI has some flaws they should ignore it for themselves, when it may be for their build a very appropriate tool and a wake up call.
 
dont weigh myself very often, but last time I did, it put my BMI at 26.
I think I've lost a few pounds more since, so maybe creeping into 'not overweight' territory for the first time since I was 11, however I still have more visible fat (belly and moobs) than I would like (although with the number of compliments I receive versus how I see myself in the mirror, I'm starting to worry the issue may be more mental :-/ )

pretty much 6' dead on, was 13st10lbs at last check, definitely improving (was 17.10 this time last year!), but I'm still feeling more overweight than BMI would indicate, want to lose another 1.5-2 stone, and then start packing on more muscle
 
No.

2 reasons.

I dont drink. 90% of the time thats why people pile on unwanted weight, the copious amounts of alcohol they consume over a weekend quickly catches up..

I walk everywhere. Could afford a car but dont have a need for one, plus due to the sedentary nature of my job its even more important I dont get a car and continue walking where I need to.
 
It is flawed, but it is not useless. For the vast majority of society it gives a reasonable suggestion of a good weight range. There are people that are carrying a lot of muscle mass that are out of the range but still a healthy weight, but in the grand scheme of things they are relatively few. There are very few that are actually in the obese or higher range who genuinely couldn't do with losing SOME fat even if it would not be realistic to aim for <25 BMI.

A lot of people want to kid themselves that because BMI has some flaws they should ignore it for themselves, when it may be for their build a very appropriate tool and a wake up call.

Exactly, BMI never claimed to be the definitive answer but taking your height and weight and dividing them is a lot quicker than getting a proper fat %age check.

Somewhere in between is a calliper check but even that isn't 100% accurate. I tell you what it is though, its a damn site better than smart scales.. I have some of those and the difference in my body fat percentage is incredible, by my scales I'm into the danger area with BF %, with a calliper test I'm ever so slightly towards the higher end of fine.
 
I dont drink. 90% of the time thats why people pile on unwanted weight
I think there is a lot more important factors in a person's lifestyle than drinking that helps people put on weight. Snacking in-between meals to keep you going etc. being bigger factors in my opinion.

Sedentary lifestyles in general don't lend themselves to helping stave off the weight and convenience food is a big one for those who lead busy lives.
 
Last edited:
According to BMI I'm just overweight. My body fat % of 17% and the fact that I cycle every day and go climbing 3 times a week means that I'll take it with a pinch of salt though...
 
I dont drink. 90% of the time thats why people pile on unwanted weight, the copious amounts of alcohol they consume over a weekend quickly catches up..

I walk everywhere. Could afford a car but dont have a need for one, plus due to the sedentary nature of my job its even more important I dont get a car and continue walking where I need to.

I drink and it is perfectly possible to drink and not pile on the pounds. It's all about moderation and keeping active and on that subject...

I have car but I don't use it to get to work nor do I really use it 'round town as I cycle everywhere. Better for me, cheaper and often quicker.
 
I hit 21 stone (294lbs) and decided to change before 300lbs became a reality.

I gave up smoking (50+ a day) and have started eating healthier, bought myself a bike and started doing some miles on that.

Im currently 19st 2lbs (268lbs) closing in on my 1st goal of 2 stone lost.
 
What is odd for me is that whilst my weight isn't terrible (I am a little underweight), my waist size is decreasing. I'm now 27 and a half inch waist..
 
Try walking to the bottom of your garden and back, then to the nearest lamppost and then to the next one. Just very small steps you don't have to start walking miles. Maybe in a few weeks you might make it to the end of your road.

This is a short video, very inspiring of a big chap who pretty much done what I posted above and now he's thin and healthy and running marathons.


Exactly, you can exercise with a zimmer frame. What matters is how much effort you are putting in; even if the most basic thing seems a struggle, do it. Begin to cut down food intake, and take small steps. :)
 
Do you have a suggestion for how much you think a normal 6ft person should weigh? 16 maybe 17 stone?

Are you wolverine?

Unless he is rather stacked then that is overweight for the height. I was pretty fat myself at 15st11 and 5ft11. I'm probably about 13st5 now, trying to get back under 13st.
 
What I've picked up on recently is that it isn't calories that's the problem.
It's ****e food that's the big problem.

Food in packets or tins is in general nutritionally poor compared with fresh food.
It also tends to have loads of preservatives, and man made chemicals, which make the food last longer (ie it doesn't spoil quickly), but these additives also screw up your body.
They also tend to be laden with carbohydrates which spike bloodsugar and long term leads to diabetes.
And try finding a processed food that doesn't contain wheat (which is a carbohydrate).
Wheat isn't very nutritious, but also increasingly is being asserted as having a huge role in all kinds of health issues.

So - if you want to lose weight, just avoid processed food.
Eat more healthy fats - don't be scared of full fat milk, cheese and butter, olive oil, or coconut oil, but steer clear of vegetable oils which tend to be very inflammatory.
Don't be scared of meat - just make sure that you eat plenty of veg - the odd bit of fruit here and there (but not such a huge amount), and you'll shed weight easy peasy, with little effort.

I lost a stone and a half easily by eating till I was satisfied, but only eating high quality, unprocessed food. I've about half a stone to lose to get to the same weight I was when I was 20.

These days, when I'm in the supermarket I spend about 90% of my time in the veg and fruit aisle, and the meat aisles - the odd visit to the sweet aisle for some high cocoa content chocolate but that's it.

Here's the thing - if you are overweight - just cutting calories won't help long term.
You need to get your body in the habit of burning fat, so it starts to get shot of those excess thousands of calories held in your fatty tissues. By eating a carbohydrate rich diet (like most people tend to do - and what generally leads to them being fat in the first place), all you do is keep topping up your fat reserves, as if you don't use up quickly bloodsugar produced by digested carbohydrate quite quickly, it tends to turn into fat.

One of the main reasons why people are fat is because their body's don't KNOW that they are fat. Hormones. Insulin, Leptin, Ghrelin. The hormonal signalling is screwed up. And that generally happens from eating food that produces inflammation.
Lack of sleep doesn't help either.

If people are so used to eating lots of carbs, their bodies tend to expect carbs every 3 or 4 hours. That's why you get hunger pangs so frequently, even though you are clearly overweight. Your body is hooked on glucose (which for the most part results from metabolised carbs).
But if you can become more reliant on fat as your main fuel source, you don't need to eat quite so much, or rather so often. Then it's just a case of topping up on essential vitamins and so on, and protein for muscle repair and growth, rather than energy.

Remember - if you are fat, the last thing you need is more stored energy.
What you need is a way to switch on the fat burning - and you do that by eating stuff that contains fat - rather than carbs.

Of course - you could adopt a method of calorie restriction in order to lose weight, but for the most part that isn't long lasting, and metabolically tends to screw you up.
The body goes into starvation mode, and the body goes into a mode where it prioritises essential processes, rather than working at optimum.
 
The reality is that the bigger they are, the harder they hit!

I've had plenty of practise sparing with my 6'7 24st house mate, as long as you don't let them hit you first then even a 5'6 midget like me can take them down :D
 
Back
Top Bottom