West Midlands Police target drivers too close to cyclists

Have you seen what U.K. roads are like 50cm from the kerb? Have you seen what the cycle lanes are like? They're atrocious.

We have crap like drains in the road too, doesn't stop cyclists from going on cycle paths like they should:

https://goo.gl/maps/thMi8eg2FKm

Over here you're actually required to go on that cycle path, I guess you'd find it to narrow:
https://goo.gl/maps/viETM4mZbEy


Another good example on how it should be:
https://goo.gl/maps/q55EGwt47gt
 
"how it should be" ? welcome to real world, where london has narrow roads, loads of traffic and 10% of infrastructure that NL has.

Come over here, start riding at the pace I do and see how long you last on the roads while sticking to "cycle lanes only"

on that note, feel free to plot me a route that allows me to use 1m wide/segregated cycle lanes to cycle from Croydon to Hyde park, once you do that can you also pop another one in for the way back please?

you literally have got no idea of infrastructure available here and you're bashing me for doing nothing wrong, unless doing what I am legally allowed/advised is now wrong? and all of that is coming from you, basing your opinion on infrastructure from ANOTHER country.

brilliant.
 
Last edited:
We have crap like drains in the road too, doesn't stop cyclists from going on cycle paths like they should:

https://goo.gl/maps/thMi8eg2FKm

Over here you're actually required to go on that cycle path, I guess you'd find it to narrow:
https://goo.gl/maps/viETM4mZbEy


Another good example on how it should be:
https://goo.gl/maps/q55EGwt47gt

Jolly good, must be fun for you in a whole other country that actually invests in real infrastructure. Over here our cycle paths aren't nearly so nice as those pictures, and we're not required to use cycle paths and drivers aren't required to stay out of them, and by god they don't.
 
snowdog : Roads in the UK (as VonHelmet said) are typically minefields in first 50cm and so you have to cycle nearly a meter out, so there is then no room for a car overtaking in that same lane; and you then have to cycle slightly further out so that a motorist will not even try.
If you have wide/clean cycle lanes in the Netherlands - great - what about the cyclists who wan to travel >25km/h though ?
[from you last comment they have to use cycle lane]

In the 2nd vid, van driver should not have started his overtake when it could not be completed safely as there was a cyclist overtake already underway ahead ?

amigafan2003 : cyclists running red lights etc are ultimately having accidents that our taxes are having to clean-up - so (with both motorist&cyclist hat) that is annoying.
Common mortality seems to be cyclist being wiped out, with left turning lorry because in blind-spot - cyclist are foolish to undertake/filter in the gutter to put themselves at this risk. [saw the french had banned headphones on cyclists good on them - a personal pet hate]

EDIT correction Grudas's video sorry
Vonhelmet my utube ran on to your next video ! SPEEEEED and TRAFFIC - London Cycling
 
Last edited:
I ride 11.6 miles to work and 11.1 miles back and have about half a mile of half arsed cycle path each way in that, and even then it's like the surface of the moon. Abysmal.
 
"how it should be" ? welcome to real world, where london has narrow roads, loads of traffic and 10% of infrastructure that NL has.

Come over here, start riding at the pace I do and see how long you last on the roads while sticking to "cycle lanes only"

on that note, feel free to plot me a route that allows me to use 1m wide/segregated cycle lanes to cycle from Croydon to Hyde park, once you do that can you also pop another one in for the way back please?

you literally have got no idea of infrastructure available here and you're bashing me for doing nothing wrong, unless doing what I am legally allowed/advised is now wrong? and all of that is coming from you, basing your opinion on infrastructure from ANOTHER country.

brilliant.

Regardless of the infrastructure, I'd keep to the side like I was taught when I was a kid and rode to school on my bike... I've been cycling by myself on the roads since the age of 10 or so (and since 4 yrs old or so with parents) and not once did it ever spring to mind to hog a whole car lane.
If you have wide/clean cycle lanes in the Netherlands - great - what about the cyclists who wan to travel >25km/h though ?
They can, on the cycle path, if traffic allows.

If there's a blue sign with a bicycle on it, you are required to use them and are not allowed to use parallel roads. Same goes for blue plated mopeds (slower that don't require helmets).:
120px-Nederlands_verkeersbord_G11.svg.png


Then there's also some paths where faster (yellow plated, ones that require helmets) mopeds are forced to go:
G12a_0.gif


So even on your 45/50km/h moped you're forced to go on them, to not hinder car traffic.
drivers aren't required to stay out of them
Neither here, if it's a dashed line, you're even allowed to stop on them (to load/unload or allow a passenger in/out) if you want to as a car driver. Hell we have some bus stops on them in some places.

Most people (both drivers and cyclists) know to stay out of each others space though and cyclists know they belong by the side of the road.

The only ones that don't (and are universally hated by normal cyclists and drivers alike) are the ones on racing bikes, you know the types who wear spandex and helmets and think they're Armstrong on the public roads, shouting all the time instead of using their bells (as they lack em), no lights on their bikes, no reflectors, refuse to go on mandatory cycle paths, race past pedestrians or pets at fullspeed, etc...


Regardless what state your roads are in, cycling in het middle of a car lane is not going to help cyclist acceptance. It's a blatant disregard for faster traffic and unnecessary.

My last visit to London I saw cyclists waiting in queue behind cars in the middle of the lane, I was amazed at the stupidity of that. There was more than enough space to pass near the kerb.
 
Last edited:
It's a 'car' lane? That's the mentality issue with a lot of drivers here.

"Roads are just for cars"

The moment you're cycling on a shared use pavement though and they're a pedestrian they're shouting get off the pavement.

Can't win.
 
That's the problem, you need a culture change, space near the kerb is for cyclists, that way cars can overtake cyclists without any problems, while cyclists can pass queues no problem.

Roads are for everyone, but a clear distinction is made between fast and slow traffic, and when possible, they're segregated.

Cyclists claiming up so much space though is working against their acceptance.

The whole idea is that cyclists don't need so much space...
 
It's a 'car' lane? That's the mentality issue with a lot of drivers here.

"Roads are just for cars"

The moment you're cycling on a shared use pavement though and they're a pedestrian they're shouting get off the pavement.

Can't win.

Thats what cycle paths are for:D, you just have to walk your bike between them:p.
 
This is what I'm being taught on a motorbike, but cyclists, no, it only creates friction between them (slow traffic like mopeds or pushbikes) and fast traffic (cars and motorbikes).

It only creates friction because some motorists are vaginas!

no one is doing this.

I got shouted at yesterday "get off the path you ****" while I was cycling on a shared use path (not very fast either). It's even got a bloomin' great big bike sign painted on it! It's probably caught on my GoPro - I'll dig it out later.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
seems you have won worldwide accolades for the Dutch cyclist/motorist segregation eg yes it looks nice.

These Dutch stats interesting too 1.4Mil electric bikes (do not fancy sharing a bike lane with them) average commuting distance 2.9KM, 25% of people commute by bike(inc car+bike)

Neighbour told me today about this UK abuse of cycle lanes, a local club - fortunately they got the registration plate via backward looking camera (apparently camera integrated inconspicuously in reflector mounting)
guy was annoyed they were using road !
 
That's the problem, you need a culture change, space near the kerb is for cyclists, that way cars can overtake cyclists without any problems, while cyclists can pass queues no problem.

Roads are for everyone, but a clear distinction is made between fast and slow traffic, and when possible, they're segregated.

Cyclists claiming up so much space though is working against their acceptance.

The whole idea is that cyclists don't need so much space...

You're missing the point though. When someone on a bike is at or just below the speed limit there is no legal way* for a motorised vehicle to be a faster traffic. If they overtake you they ARE breaking the law.

No one is suggesting someone doing 10mph on an open road should be in the middle of the lane. No, they should be within a metre of the curb** (but still with space to swerve into if someone cuts you up). If you're doing close to or the speed limit then it's perfectly reasonable to be in the middle of a lane.

*other than emergency vehicles.
**For most situations at least, for example turning right would be reasonable.
 
Last edited:
State financing permitting, I think the Dutch segregation system is what is in store for us in the future in the UK cities (reduced mortality/accidents - for the greater good), and us cyclists who do not want to adopt the speed limitations/dangers imposed by the cycle ways will become social pariahs./ criminals ?
Whether, with need to reduce pollution & congestion the cars themselves will be much more restricted so that space is given exclusively to public transport and cycles, so we will leap-frog the Dutch solution.

OK that is longer term, and in the meantime need more driver and cyclist education and enforcement (I do not know the cost of a mortality in relation to cost of additional enforcement capability ?) which W. Midlands are trying to drive.
 
These Dutch stats interesting too 1.4Mil electric bikes (do not fancy sharing a bike lane with them)

Why wouldn't you want to share a bike lane with an ebike?

My two penneth - cyclists AND motorists need to stop being so concerned with getting somewhere as fast as they possibly can. If people took a more leisurely approach to commuting, it would solve a lot of problems.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
About Ebikes (I start digging a hole) - they require lower physical fitness/strength, and maybe as a consequence of that, the people I typically see riding them show less competency maneuvering/controlling them - an accident waiting to happen, so I steer clear.
I am dubious about the riders safety awareness/experience too.
...but I would probably institute a mandatory proficiency test for all riders
(do they do this in the Netherlands?)

It would be interesting to know the demographic of typical ebike purchasers.


About speed, in a city context little difference between the exploitable capability of cars (they all do 30mph), but on the other hand cyclists have very different abilities, so I think road system should accomodate riders who commmute at >15mph (their commuting may only be viable at that speed)
 
Back
Top Bottom