Greenlizard0 PL & FA Cup QF Football Thread ** spoilers ** [17th - 19th March 2023]
- Thread starter explicit4u
- Start date
- Status
Soldato
- Joined
- 14 Oct 2007
- Posts
- 9,715
- Location
- newcastle
The last time we played forest at there place the referee shafted us, you know what’s coming don’t you
Honestly, I have no idea about the offside rule anymore.
But the Forest player clears it intentionally so its a new phase.
Exactly, he wasn’t active until a forest player kicked it to him.
How is it a new phase? If the Newcastle player had be onside, the clearance would gone out for a throw it. The newcastle player wouldn't have been near him
Last edited:
Because the forest player played it. So it’s a new phase because Newcastle are not attacking.
Same way Mo was onside this season, can't remember the game, Wolves maybe, a player tried to head it with Mo behind him.
Kane v Liverpool a few years back as Lovren was said to have played the ball.
That's the rule
He played it, but it comes off a newcastle player who is offside. The newcastle player gains a massive advantage, he wouldn't have been near the clearance to make that block had he been onside originally
But that is classed as a new phase, same with the Mo goal this season and there's been others like it too.
Soldato
- Joined
- 31 Oct 2005
- Posts
- 8,846
- Location
- Leeds
This has forest 2-1 sucker punch written all over it
I dont see how its not the fair call. That ball goes out for a throw in had the newcastle player been onside originally
Last edited:
Were they checking the badge last week when Pope should have been sent off and concede a penalty?
Come on now, theres no conspiracy, we just have rubbish refs. I havent actually seen this offside tho tbh.
Yes I agree to some extent but the rules say different. Unless we are missing something as they haven't actually said why it was offside yet.
Like the Mo one and I'm a Liverpool fan. He was stood offside but not going for the ball, their player went to head it and made a mess of it and it bought Mo back onside and into play.
What's new for 2022/23: Offsides
IFAB has clarified what constitutes defenders deliberately playing the ball for offsides
www.premierleague.com
These are the rules by the way. Offside player doesn't automatically become onside just because a defender has touched it. Y'know, like with a lot of decisions in football, its open to interpretation
Last edited:
Forest player clearly intentionally plays it for me. He's clearing a cross. Unless they think it just hit himWhat's new for 2022/23: Offsides
IFAB has clarified what constitutes defenders deliberately playing the ball for offsides
These are the rules by the way. Offside player doesn't automatically become onside just because a defender has touched it. Y'know, like with a lot of decisions in football, its open to interpretation
Last edited:
- Status