I said a few days ago that $599 was the max for a win in the 9070XT and I stand by that. It is a good price if performance is right around where AMD claims it is. Especially if it is close to MSRP and in good supply.
That 9070 is a miss at $550. It needs to be beating the 5070 by at least 20% price/perf and it just isn’t. Its only saving grace is the fact its power requirements are excellent. Essentially a $150 cheaper 7900XT with 30% lower power used and better RT and upscaling. Erm… actually now I’ve typed that it doesn’t seem so bad
Really if these were even $550 and $450 it would have been an absolute massive win for AMD. Are they already so close to making zero profit that 10% - 17% lower margins are a loss maker?
A very mixed bag from AMD but mostly positive overall. B+
I agree I think this is a pretty good price and launch, I don't really care about the 9070, this is an upsell card, and a half believe it's a cut down card for failed XTs and I see these being more part of system integrator builds than sold separately. It's there to serve a purpose but it's purpose is not to be sold to gamer imo.
I had a break down like this.
$699 Meh usual AMD
$650 Somewhat decent if performance is on par.
$599 pretty good starting price if availability can hold this price will win a lot of people over
$549 big market mover
$499 humiliating for Nvidia.
I did expect 649 when i heard them say 550 for the 9070 so I'm surprised they went 599.
I think it's a pretty good price and will gain market share, Nvidia don't have the stock to compete at the moment, the cards are will above MRSP so the actual difference is significantly more. The RT performance is an incredible leap from what it was before removing the entire argument to even own a Nvidia card if the argument is RT.
Nvidia with the 5000 series have had a rather pathetic performance uplift and changed very little generation on generation, at least with this pending reviews we have a tier of performance that has been brought down a stack to the new generation as per tradition, when you then factor in the multiple Nvidia issues, stock shortages, scalping etc this is a very good announcement.
If AMD can maintain a good stock flow and prices at MSRP level over the next couple of months it will move perception in a positive way. I don't think Nvidia will lower prices to compete, not at first, even even if they did it wont matter if they don't have the stock.
I genuinely believe the only people who are unhappy with this price never would have bought it, even if it was 499 they would be typing how they are waiting to see if Nvidia responds, they would never buy AMD they just want AMD to be competitive so Daddy J can pat them on the head rather than punch them in the nuts.