Caporegime
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2013
- Posts
- 30,203
The reality of Wizards in a magic school that seems to be the most dangerous place imaginable for children?
Harry Potter HBO TV series
- Thread starter Bigpig
- Start date
Soldato
- Joined
- 16 May 2004
- Posts
- 7,270
- Location
- Derby
yeah, bad casting /jk. Just as well Robbie Coltrane was 8ft in real life
Pretty sure in this day and age, they can make a 4ft anorexic look 8ft and fat
Not allowed. Whitewashing innit.
Pretty sure in this day and age, they can make a 4ft anorexic look 8ft and fat
Yeah but their costume bloke was probably banking of saving a few quid on a fat suit, and then he saw recent photos of Nick Frost and was like, oh for flips sake!.
To be fair, he was chronically obese.
Soldato
- Joined
- 29 Jul 2004
- Posts
- 7,172
This is a good point, however Gambon played the role much better, so it worked out in the end.
What have you been smoking? He was atrocious, although not sure it was his fault - the writing/directing on the later ones was horrendous anyway in comparison to the source material.
This is weird. I vaguely recall that J K Rowling tried to explain that Hermione was never explicitly Black in the books after Cursed. Child casting was announced but this is gonna be a lot harder to swallow.
Its bad enough she has allowed American cast, which she didn't for the movies, but this is just weird.
I read the books before the movies came out and imagined Snape being a white, greasy haired, sneering anti-hero, which is exactly what the author wanted. Alan Rickman was perfect for the role.
rp2000
Its bad enough she has allowed American cast, which she didn't for the movies, but this is just weird.
I read the books before the movies came out and imagined Snape being a white, greasy haired, sneering anti-hero, which is exactly what the author wanted. Alan Rickman was perfect for the role.
rp2000
Other than age, I 100% agree. He was far, far too old for the character. But at least they seemed to age all of the group up, or it felt like they did it made very little difference.
Caporegime
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2013
- Posts
- 30,203
Looked in to this, and yeah you are right.
He was 54 when it started filming and 64 by the end.
Harrys parents were supposed to only be 21 when they died, which means when Harry starts school at 11, that whole group in the same year should have been in their early 30's
He was 54 when it started filming and 64 by the end.
Harrys parents were supposed to only be 21 when they died, which means when Harry starts school at 11, that whole group in the same year should have been in their early 30's
Yeah that scene where he throws Harry against the wall in Goblet of Fire… wtf. It could have been the directing I suppose.
It is funny seeing how the style and direction changed over the films. I seem to recall that Harry and Ron have long ‘emo’ hair in 3 & 4.
3 (Azkaban) is odd re: lore … it starts off with Harry doing a lumos charm in his bedroom… which is an instant expulsion, no?
In terms of vibe and ‘magic’, the first film is by far away the best - a very good adaption of the book.
Soldato
- Joined
- 12 Feb 2006
- Posts
- 17,716
- Location
- Surrey
thinking about it, in some ways going clearly different, rather than an alan rickman clone, helps distinguish the 2 apart, which may be a good thing due to this role being probably most watched
is my only worry too.
Soldato
- Joined
- 29 Jul 2004
- Posts
- 7,172
He played the role better than Richard Harris did, how's the source material, writing or directing relevant to that? He did what was asked of him and put in a far more memorable performance.
Last edited:
Because it's an adaptation of the source material, and Richard Harris played the character much, much closer to the source material. The most memorable part of Gambons Dumbledore was the complete antithesis of the book character in the fourth movie and became such a meme that it's still reposted today. Again, not necessarily Gambons fault if that's what was written or directed.
Soldato
- Joined
- 31 Jan 2022
- Posts
- 3,630
- Location
- UK
Because ... J. K. Rowling needs more money.
But, seriously, looking forward to this. No pre-judgement.
But, seriously, looking forward to this. No pre-judgement.
‘Harry Potter’ HBO Series Casts Harry, Ron and Hermione
The HBO 'Harry Potter' series has cast its Harry, Ron and Hermione.
variety.com
Soldato
- Joined
- 4 Aug 2007
- Posts
- 22,432
- Location
- Wilds of suffolk
Inb4 grown men start malding over the choice for Hermione.
Edit: HBO had to disable the comments on the Facebook post after just a couple of minutes due to the frothers.
TBF it would be far easier if every role, for every production simply had a middle age white bloke cast.
Seriously though the actors look young enough that they will be fairly convincing for the roles as they age.
Those lucky three have pretty much won the golden tickets of acting.
They have, but also hopefully they are shielded from the vitriol that will no doubt be coming from lots of people. I have no real care about the kid actors - it's a complete gamble each way I didn't think much of the original ones for the most part. Unless HBO cancel it season two haha.
I honestly don't think I'd want to be any of the kids involved in this show, I actually feel bad for them and hope they don't get negatively effected.
On one hand you have the people who are going to be mad at the choice for characters like Hermione, on the other you have the Rowling hate brigade that regularly go off over her views. Not that the latter had much effect on the game from a couple of years back, still I feel there's going to be a lot of negativity on top of some big shoes to fill.
On one hand you have the people who are going to be mad at the choice for characters like Hermione, on the other you have the Rowling hate brigade that regularly go off over her views. Not that the latter had much effect on the game from a couple of years back, still I feel there's going to be a lot of negativity on top of some big shoes to fill.