• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Fuji X Series

Without pixel peeping or going forensic, so at a glance...

4 is definitely smartphone.
2 I'd say with high level of confidence it's a smartphone.
3 and 1 look more like a proper camera

...but I guess you're going to say they were all smartphone right? None of these are particularly good examples of the signature smartphone look I was criticising.
 
Last edited:
Without pixel peeping or going forensic, so at a glance...

4 is definitely smartphone.
2 I'd say with high level of confidence it's a smartphone.
3 and 1 look more like a proper camera

...but I guess you're going to say they were all smartphone right? None of these are particularly good examples of the signature smartphone look I was criticising.

They are all Smart phone. Actually half of them are taken with the selfie camera.

Shame this phone exploded in my hand about 10 days later but that’s another story lol

They are really good for a phone, I’ll show you some pics from the same time from my Fuji later when I get home.
 
Last edited:
They are good (especially the third one) but definitely not representative of what most people get using their iPhone camera app. I'm guessing you did some work on these and they're not SOOC?

Would be interested to see the Fuji ones.
 
They are good (especially the third one) but definitely not representative of what most people get using their iPhone camera app. I'm guessing you did some work on these and they're not SOOC?

Would be interested to see the Fuji ones.

Fuji X100VI

04353a35434d.jpg


DSCF0873.webp


Vivo X200 Ultra, straight out of the phone.

923658b7c991.JPG
 
Last edited:
I stand by my point. There is very little between the Vivo X200 Ultra and the X100VI on the particular shot of the women in the hat with the flowers behind.

I imagine the X300 is even better.
 
Last edited:
You can tell but they are really close at a glance and most people, especially if you just look at it on the phone or a small screen, won't be able to tell the differnce.

btw, it's easy to tell because she puts all her phots with 831 watermark on the bottom corner.

Vivo

IMG_20260505_153249.webp

IMG_20260505_153511.webp

IMG_20260513_111824.webp

IMG_20260513_125853.webp


XT5 with 56/1.2

DSCF4135.webp


Although not blowing my own trumpet, the common denominator here in both are that I took them all. :p

DSCF4839.webp
 
Last edited:
But this just proves my point. Firstly, these are all impressive photos. However, those last two XT5 photos are beautiful to look at and professional grade with completely natural and multi-dimensional bokeh. It's best illustrated in the last photo where the pebbles closer to her are less blurred than the ones in the distance. This is how our eyes see the world.

The phone ones above the bokeh looks completely unnatural especially the last one - it's just a uniform one dimensional blur across the background, there is no depth. It's like someone got a photo with everything in focus and no subject separation, created a background layer on photoshop and applied a blur to it - which is exactly what computational photography does. It's a shame you don't have an XT5 version of this one because it would look completely different.

In the examples above that where she is sitting the bokeh looks less processed because of the closer composition (I'm guessing it was telephoto lens maybe or if not just closer to subject) but the Fujifilm still blows it away on colour reproduction, depth etc. Surely no one can compare those two directly and say the phone one doesn't look comparatively flat!

Smart phones have come along way but there is still no comparison IMO and what you are showcasing here is the very best a smartphone can do in ideal conditions. Maybe some people genuinely can't see it but for those of us who can it's painfully obvious and it's literally the laws of physics in action that differentiate the two.
 
Last edited:
Most people can't tell and yes...my iPhone, even the 18 Pro max isn't this good.

But there are times when the Vivo cooks it too much.

The key thing is here is that mine required me to edit it with my presents in LR. She gets that look instantly. This is where most of the friction lies.

What really surprised me is the selfie cam, all the photos where i am in it are with the selfie cam. But they are all filtered, my skin isn't that good!
 
Last edited:
Are they just as comparable in low light or indoors etc? Smartphones have definitely got better but physics still applies.
I do agree though for viewing on a phone it almost doesn't matter which device is used as it's so hard to tell on such a small screen now especially if you process to a similar style.
 
Last edited:
Are they just as comparable in low light or indoors etc? Smartphones have definitely got better but physics still applies.
I do agree though for viewing on a phone it almost doesn't matter which device is used as it's so hard to tell on such a small screen now especially if you process to a similar style.

I can get pretty good shots from my iPhone 17 Pro Max outdoors and in well lit conditions, providing I shoot in ProRAW and remove all the processing the standard camera app does. For indoor/low light the small sensor becomes much more obvious.
 
Picked up a used 23mm f1.4 to go with the 33 and 18mm primes. It's an incredible lens, leagues ahead of the X-E5 pancake kit lens and still quite a bit sharper than the F2 WR which I've owned for 10 years now and I've always thought that produces incredible images. I'll probably put that up for sale in the MM now as don't have a use case for it anymore.

Also I am finding myself tempted by the 16-55 f2.8 MK II. Have any of you owned this? I've always owned primes and they definitely are my preference for street photography and otherwise when I need the best possible image quality. BUT I am finding during family/trips with my partner I always seem to have the wrong lens on so thinking of buying this as a compromise. Have any of you done any work looking at how this compares to the primes in terms of the images? I did have a look on Youtube but there's so much rubbish content.
 
Last edited:
Picked up a used 23mm f1.4 to go with the 33 and 18mm primes. It's an incredible lens, leagues ahead of the X-E5 pancake kit lens and still quite a bit sharper than the F2 WR which I've owned for 10 years now and I've always thought that produces incredible images. I'll probably put that up for sale in the MM now as don't have a use case for it anymore.

Also I am finding myself tempted by the 16-55 f2.8 MK II. Have any of you owned this? I've always owned primes and they definitely are my preference for street photography and otherwise when I need the best possible image quality. BUT I am finding during family/trips with my partner I always seem to have the wrong lens on so thinking of buying this as a compromise. Have any of you done any work looking at how this compares to the primes in terms of the images? I did have a look on Youtube but there's so much rubbish content.
I would (and did) look at the Sigma 17-40 f1.8 before opting for the 16-55.
Anecdotally, IQ seems to be a wash between them - some people say the Sigma is sharper and others vice versa.
I replaced all my primes (with the exception of the 23mm pancake) with the Sigma and I’m very happy with that decision. It’s plenty fast at f1.8.
The only [subjective] downside is the smaller zoom range. If you must have something around 55mm then obviously the Sigma isn’t for you however I very rarely shoot in that 50-55mm range so I don’t miss it.

I’m also surprised to hear you say the 23mm f1.4 is “leagues” ahead of the pancake. I owned said lens and wasn’t massively impressed with it. I found it slow to focus (if it focussed at all) and exhibited a not insignificant amount of fringing wide open.
Admittedly, on the occasions it did nail focus it produced beautiful images but it missed more than it hit for me.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom