Associate
- Joined
- 1 Oct 2009
- Posts
- 1,306
- Location
- Norwich, UK
The more I look back on half life the more I really start to be "meh" about HL2. This game was carried on having integrated Havok tech for the physics as middleware, it was a fun innovation for the time, but looking back now that we have that level of physics in a lot of games, the rest of HL2 was kinda bland and boring.
The original HL in the lab was great, it was a maze of human tech, experiments, research and innovation and just all sorts of cool stuff. It felt like a real research bunker. HL2 setting is really awful, it's like this nameless faceless uninspired "city 17" with combine tech everywhere. There's nothing cool in the city. They embraced more of a horror theme for it eventually especially in HL Alyx which I think suffered because of the same problems, while the tech for the valve index and the experience was just brilliant, the setting was just really rubbish. A VR game set in black mesa type lab with teleportation experiments, portal experiments, lasers and whatnot would be amazing.
We're now far away enough from HL2s release that any gimmicks in game design have faded, and we just get to compare the game elements between the 2 games, and if I could only ever replay 1 of them again it would absolutely be HL1, no contest. I'm probably more excited for some kind of portal/half life cross over, or just portal sequel. I think going from lab disaster to global invasion was a disaster move. It was like letting the infected spread outside of racoon city in the RE universe, especially in the movies, and having earth be a wasteland. The drama in the disaster, not the aftermath, same goes for things like the terminator franchise, it was better people being chased through malls and modern cities and stuff, rather than the end of the world and terminators have killed or enslaved everyone. Yawn.
The original HL in the lab was great, it was a maze of human tech, experiments, research and innovation and just all sorts of cool stuff. It felt like a real research bunker. HL2 setting is really awful, it's like this nameless faceless uninspired "city 17" with combine tech everywhere. There's nothing cool in the city. They embraced more of a horror theme for it eventually especially in HL Alyx which I think suffered because of the same problems, while the tech for the valve index and the experience was just brilliant, the setting was just really rubbish. A VR game set in black mesa type lab with teleportation experiments, portal experiments, lasers and whatnot would be amazing.
We're now far away enough from HL2s release that any gimmicks in game design have faded, and we just get to compare the game elements between the 2 games, and if I could only ever replay 1 of them again it would absolutely be HL1, no contest. I'm probably more excited for some kind of portal/half life cross over, or just portal sequel. I think going from lab disaster to global invasion was a disaster move. It was like letting the infected spread outside of racoon city in the RE universe, especially in the movies, and having earth be a wasteland. The drama in the disaster, not the aftermath, same goes for things like the terminator franchise, it was better people being chased through malls and modern cities and stuff, rather than the end of the world and terminators have killed or enslaved everyone. Yawn.



