BitFenix Shinobi XL Review

Caporegime
Joined
17 Jan 2010
Posts
66,731
Location
weston-super-mare
BitFenix Shinobi XL review

Product homepage - http://www.bitfenix.com/global/en/products/chassis/shinobi-xl

Case specifications.
Untitled.png



Packaging

The case arrived in a solid cardboard box from Germany and survived the dreaded postal service very well indeed.
IMG_0021.jpg

IMG_0022.jpg



The specifications are also found on the box.
IMG_0026.jpg



The packing foam used is very thick and suitably up to the job.
IMG_0028.jpg

IMG_0031.jpg



Exterior

The front and top panel have a almost soft finish to them thats very nice to the touch.
IMG_0034.jpg

IMG_0037.jpg

IMG_0042.jpg

IMG_0159.jpg



The top front is where you find 4 USB3.0 ports, 1 quick charge port (Orange), microphone and headphone 3.5mm jacks with power LED and HDD activity LED above them, power and reset buttons.
IMG_0057.jpg



The rear has a 140/120mm fan mount with a 120mm fan supplied, 4 rubber grommets for water cooling tubes and nine expansion slots (it does support XL-ATX after all:))
IMG_0044.jpg

IMG_0046.jpg



Dust filters underneath, the one for the PSU simply slides backwards, the other two are held in place by little plastic poppers that are easy to remove from inside.

The case feet are screwed to the case chassis so wont fall off or rip off if you drag the case.
IMG_0092.jpg

IMG_0095.jpg



Simple fan filter at the front, it just slips into place and held by some metal tabs, the case badge at the front can be easily removed and changed for different colours which I heard are coming as part of an accessories options along with different colour mesh inserts for the top and front of the case.
IMG_0083.jpg

IMG_0084.jpg

IMG_0090.jpg



Size comparison

Heres a side by side against a Antec DF85 and Coolermaster ATCS840, its as wide and as tall as the ATCS840 but not as deep.
IMG_0115-1.jpg

IMG_0121-1.jpg


Accessories and fittings

So a simple instruction guide, 3.5" to 5.25" drive bay adapter and a bag of Black screws (with included standoff spinner which is a nice touch), cable ties, cable clamps and a speaker to attach to the motherboard header.
IMG_0050.jpg

IMG_0111.jpg

IMG_0113.jpg



Interior

The holes for the standoffs are simply marked with a letter representing where they should be fitted and the guide for the letter codes is in the center of the motherboard tray.

All the cable routing holes are fitted with rubber grommets, the roof includes a 230mm fan with the option of adding another or fitting 3X120mm fans.

The front fan is also 230mm and there is also the option of 3X120mm fans.

The drive caddies are simple squeezed and slide in and out, they support both 3.5" and 2.5" drives.

The 3.5" drive bay cage is also simply removed by four screw from underneath the case and four screws in the 5.25" drive bay bottom.

The PSU can be mounted both ways up and sits on rubber feet.
IMG_0065.jpg

IMG_0069.jpg

IMG_0066.jpg

IMG_0070.jpg

IMG_0071.jpg


The drive bay caddies are a bit wobbly and flimsy.
IMG_0148.jpg



30mm of room for cables, this is plenty for even the untidiest of system builders.
IMG_0076.jpg

IMG_0081.jpg



Cables and connectors

Two 19pin USB3.0 connectors each with an internal USB2.0 option, case front panel connectors and a female SATA power connector for the quick charge port.
IMG_0067.jpg

IMG_0105.jpg

IMG_0107.jpg

IMG_0106.jpg

IMG_0104.jpg



Completed build

Plenty of space inside and behind.
IMG_0127.jpg

IMG_0149.jpg

IMG_0153.jpg

IMG_0133.jpg



With the rubber grommets fitted to the cable routing holes it really does look better than what I could achieve with my Antec DF85 as seen below.
2012-01-0220-24-00-IMG_0001-2-1.jpg



Temperature testing

Done some testing with the Antec DF85 (fan speed controllers all set to low) and this Shinobi XL, I used Realtemp to make a note of the four core temps then totaled them up and divided by four, the GFX core temp was taken using GPU-Z sensor feature.

The i5 2500K I have was set to 5GHz.
Antec Kuhler920
Gigabyte GA-Z68XP-UD4
Palit GTX570 (factory fitted twin fan cooler)

Untitled-2.png


Now it needs to be said that the Antec DF85 does have 5X120mm fans and a further 2X140mm fans in the roof so for the Shinobi XL to try and beat it was very unlikely, on the plus side its certainly quieter with it in the same location on my desk.

I think the other reason for the higher temps is the front fan is trying to suck in air from a less than ideal route with the case front panel having a small opening underneath and two small strips of mesh either side at the front.


Pros

Looks great:)
Plenty more fan fitment options.
Lots of room and support for large GFX cards and motherboards.
Great cable management.



Cons

Worse temps than other cases I own (but still acceptable)
3.5" drive caddies are a bit flimsy.

Overall 9/10
 
Last edited:
Great review bud. Was hoping for better out of the box cooling though as am tempted to buy this case. A non-reference dual fan GTX570 idling at 54ºC? Not great IMO but good work on the 5GHz i5 overclock. Cooling option do seem good on paper though, I would probably go a bit mad with the fans and throw the front 230mm in the top and add 3x120mm Akasa Apaches on the front. Thanks for the review, time to ponder...
 
Last edited:
nice review... I think it is normal that the ANTEC cools better because it is all open which will also cause a higher noise level...

I think it comes down to what you want... silence and design or a little bit louder one.
 
Nice review :)

Very glad to see that the feet are screwed on this time!

What about the side panels? Are they sturdy or flimsy? Roughly how thick would they be?


Regarding the drive bay caddies and them being flimsy/wobbly, this is also the case with the Raider's caddies, but once a hard drive is fitted in (3.5") I found them to be pretty good and better than my Antec Sonata 3 caddies, which are solid metal with silicon grommets (the same as the Antec P182), more noise came from the hard drive area in my Sonata 3 than the Raider.

I think it is normal that the ANTEC cools better because it is all open which will also cause a higher noise level...

I think it comes down to what you want... silence and design or a little bit louder one.

+1 to that, as well as the Antec having many more fans and if IIRC the Antec fans move quite a lot of air, a fair bit more than the BitFenix spectre fans (but at the price of being louder)

In fact, I would say going by the temperatures that the XL has held up remarkably well to the Antec! Considering:

- more fans in the Antec
- Antec's fans move more air than the Spectre series
- open design for the Antec

EDIT:

Would have loved to have seen a fan controller on this case like the Raider's fan controller.
 
Last edited:
Really nice job stulid! Enjoyed reading that and the pics are of excellent quality......I look forward to seeing the other two reviews when they are posted to compare :)
 
thanks for this review its helped me decide on a new case
i love the looks of this one
will have to buy some fans though i think
 
Nice review stulid. Regarding front airflow. Ill probably replace the front 230mm fan with a pair of 120mm silverstone air penetrators. Theese are excellent as intakes/cooler fans due to their focused airflow. Currently have two of the 140mm models as intakes on my lian li. They really helped with gpu cooling.
 
Nice review there Stulid :)

Just in the process of transferring mine, water drained, hopefully have the rad installed tonight :)
 
Back
Top Bottom