4 Different tyres - what do?

Take it back and ask for them to sort the tyres out.

Still can't get my head around how a car this young can have four odd tyres.

Why? As I said before, I was aware of it when I bought the car and took it into consideration with the price I paid. It meets the approved used criteria so I can't see them doing anything about it. The history and explanation are in the post above yours.

I'm more than happy to put new tyres on there so that I know its right. I was just looking for advice on the best approach and will be ordering 4 new ones today
 
Last edited:
Why? As I said before, I was aware of it when I bought the car and took it into consideration with the price I paid. It meets the approved used criteria so I can't see them doing anything about it

I'm more than happy to put new tyres on there so that I know its right.

How does a 10 month old car end up with 4 odd tyres?

Does the front number plate have the same registration number as the rear one?

Are the body panels all the same colour, it's not blue at the front and red at the back is it?

Why post on an internet forum that your new car has 4 odd tyres when you knew that when you purchased it and have adjusted the price accordingly.

:confused:
 
How does a 10 month old car end up with 4 odd tyres?

Does the front number plate have the same registration number as the rear one?

Are the body panels all the same colour, it's not blue at the front and red at the back is it?

Why post on an internet forum that your new car has 4 odd tyres when you knew that when you purchased it and have adjusted the price accordingly.

:confused:

As I've said several times, all 4 were changed at the same time. It wasnt taken to Kwik Fit or anything, it was done by the previous owner's own depots. It was done just before it was returned to Peugeot, presumably a condition of the contract. It's pretty obvious that the depot have just thrown on whatever was available to get it done. There's absolutely nothing wrong with the car.

I posted for advice on the tyres. I was simply asking if it was best to buy 2 to match the pairs, buy 3 to match all 4 or replace all 4 to be safe. I'll be replacing all 4. I have no issue with doing this - I wasnt asking for feedback on my purchase.
 
As I've said several times, all 4 were changed at the same time. It wasnt taken to Kwik Fit or anything, it was done by the previous owner's own depots. It was done just before it was returned to Peugeot, presumably a condition of the contract. It's pretty obvious that the depot have just thrown on whatever was available to get it done. There's absolutely nothing wrong with the car.

I posted for advice on the tyres. I was simply asking if it was best to buy 2 to match the pairs, buy 3 to match all 4 or replace all 4 to be safe. I'll be replacing all 4. I have no issue with doing this - I wasnt asking for feedback on my purchase.

Ok.
Personally I would just drive it until they wear out then replace with a matched set.

It's not ideal but I have had older cars in a similar condition.

Otherwise, if your not happy with this, just go for the most affordable set of 3 to match the one you like best.
 
What on earth possessed you? :p

Joking aside, it's a cracking car. I spent a while looking at options - I needed an estate/large hatch for doing big mileage. Value for money, comfort and spec were the main criteria. I looked at all sorts - the A4/3/C were all too expensive to justify, I could have got one for 17-18k and had a years warranty on it. This was 14 with 3 years warranty. I didnt click with the Skoda and was on the expensive side anyway. Mondeo is OK but long in the tooth and a bit dull, Insignia I hated.

I dropped by the Peugeot garage after seeing the prices of them. They had a 2.2 GT and I loved it. The build quality is astonishingly good, the switchgear has all the solid feel of the german rivals. It's a genuinely great place to be, with the big panoramic sunroof and comfort of the seats. They're *extremely* quiet and smooth, much more so than anything else I tried. It goes around corners surprisingly well too. The auto box is seamless and there's a lot of nice touches that make it feel special.

The GT, with HUD and massaging seats was on at 18k but I found this Allure 2.0 163 auto (which has everything the GT has sans 19" wheels, full massaging leather and HUD) advertised at 15k and paid 14 in the end.

Apart from the tyres needing doing, which in reality most people wouldnt notice or bother with, it's immaculate.

It's a real surprise of a car and nobody that gets in it believes it's french. Time will tell for the longevity but with 2 years manufacturers warranty and a dealer's extension for the third year, I dont really have any concerns.

(Dons flame proof Jacket) I really like the looks of these will you let us know what its like to drive, when you get new tyres on. Also if it falls apart after six months?

As above, I think it's a genuinely impressive and surprising car. Given how well it's screwed together, I don't anticipate anything dropping off during my ownership. It's really good to drive, the tyres havent caused me any concern, it stops and goes around corners just fine.
 
They aren't a bad car the 508, be interesting to hear how you get on with it.

Just put 4 new ones on, you'll get at least half the money back on selling the existing tyres on. People pay over the odds for well treaded part worns
 
Ok.
Personally I would just drive it until they wear out then replace with a matched set.

It's not ideal but I have had older cars in a similar condition.

Otherwise, if your not happy with this, just go for the most affordable set of 3 to match the one you like best.

For peace of mind, I'd prefer to get them "right". I have no issue financially replacing all 4 if that's the right thing to do, but I didn't want to waste my money if it wasn't needed.

They aren't a bad car the 508, be interesting to hear how you get on with it.

Just put 4 new ones on, you'll get at least half the money back on selling the existing tyres on. People pay over the odds for well treaded part worns

Honestly, I've done about 1000 miles in it in the week I've had it and it still surprises me. Of course there are better cars out there, but if you're after something as new as possible then you'd struggle to find something better for 14k. There were a few Mondeo Titanium X business editions with similar age and mileage for 17,500 - but 3 grand more for an older generation car...

I assume it's all above board to sell part worns on as a private individual? I know there are fairly strict requirements for companies, but assume it's anyone's game for private individuals.
 
Last edited:
For peace of mind, I'd prefer to get them "right". I have no issue financially replacing all 4 if that's the right thing to do, but I didn't want to waste my money if it wasn't needed.

I would replace 3 then.

I would keep either the Michelin or the Continental however I think you may struggle to get the Sport Contact 2 now.
 
You are unlikely to die in a ball of flames.

Personally I have no issue with 2 different sets of decent tyres on different axles, Or say 3 sport contact 5's and a 2. However as they're so new and they're all bloody different it makes sense to do the 4 and recover what you can.

I'd bet the net cost to you ends up about 200 quid

No idea on the legalities but I've never struggled to shift them
 
Last edited:
I would replace 3 then.

I would keep either the Michelin or the Continental however I think you may struggle to get the Sport Contact 2 now.

Few places with the SC2, none with the Michelin. Lends credence to the "whatever was in the corner" theory :)

That leaves the Pirelli as the other premium tyre, but I can only see "P Zero Nero GT", mine just says "P Zero Nero" on the sidewall, so not sure if thats a different tyre or not. Hence thinking about just putting 4 new ones on

You are unlikely to die in a ball of flames.

Personally I have no issue with 2 different sets of decent tyres on different axles, Or say 3 sport contact 5's and a 2. However as they're so new and they're all bloody different it makes sense to do the 4 and recover what you can.

I'd bet the net cost to you ends up about 200 quid

No idea on the legalities but I've never struggled to shift them

Thats exactly what I'm thinking. It feels absolutely fine to drive - stops in the wet without fuss etc. Suspect it might be hurting fuel economy a bit, but thats just a hunch. Would you just use ebay to sell them on?
 
The Goodyear F1 AS 2 looks to be a good shout, seems to be well regarded, £140 a corner and the ratings look better than others (if they mean anything)
 
personally I would replace all 4 tyres to match and sell the 4 mis match ones off
check ebay for prices of them before you decide
it be worth it
 
Initially I wasn't sure about mine but as they've worn a bit the grip in damp conditions improved massively ( I Dont mean the first hundred miles or so took a lot longer) and I've got nothing to complain about with them. Wet or dry, warm or cold outside they've been impressive...and I tend to push on now and then so youd really notice any shortcomings in a Scottish winter
 
Last edited:
Unless your likely to hoon it around, track it or drive on the edge of the car/tyres ability i'd be surprised if it really made any difference.

They are all reasonable tyres and if they are the same sort of tread depth you'll be fine, even under heavy braking they should all perform in a similar enough way (especially when your esp/abs kicks in) to not make a difference.
 
I Dont think it would make a significant difference either tbh - but it would really annoy me and if they're pretty new then now is actually as good time to change and move them on
 
http://autotraderblog.co.uk/2008/06/24/tyre-facts-you-need-to-know/


If you need to buy new tyres:

• Make a note of the information on the sidewall and use it to order tyres of the same type online with Auto Trader’s Tyre Centre, or at a garage
• It’s always advisable to fit tyres of the same tread depth, make and model on each corner of the car. Mismatched tyres with different grip levels will affect the cars handling and safety
• Always have tyres fitted by a professional

Look after your tyres and your tyres will look after you. Inspect them at least one per month and after driving through bad pot holes or rubbing them against a kerb.

If they are low on tread, torn or cracked, order new tyres or seek advice from a professional tyre fitter.
 
Back
Top Bottom