• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5850 vs 5870

Soldato
Joined
11 Oct 2009
Posts
2,581
Location
Edinburgh
My 5850 has been RMA'd - and I have the option of paying more for a 5870. Worthwhile??? For the 100 notes will I notice a difference at all or best just get another 5850???
 
Not worth paying £100 more - but if you can get a refund and depending on how much you paid for your failed 5850 - 5870's are in stock elsewhere for under £300..... Prices are becoming a little more sensible - but still a way to go yet.
 
+1 5870 speeds can be done on the 5850
5850
# 2.15 billion 40nm transistors
# TeraScale 2 Unified Processing Architecture

* 1440 Stream Processing Units
* 72 Texture Units
* 128 Z/Stencil ROP Units
* 32 Color ROP Units

# GDDR5 interface with 128.0 GB/sec of memory bandwidth


5870
# 2.15 billion 40nm transistors
# TeraScale 2 Unified Processing Architecture

* 1600 Stream Processing Units
* 80 Texture Units
* 128 Z/Stencil ROP Units
* 32 Color ROP Units

# GDDR5 interface with 153.6 GB/sec of memory bandwidth

How can the 5850 do what the 5870 does 5870 has more bandwidth,stream proccessing units,texture units

if i'm totally wrong then slap me with a wet fish but i didn't think changing the core clock or memory would increase the stream pocessing and texture units
 
^^ The 5850 can't make up for the slightly lower number of processors or texture units architecturally, but it can meet or exceed the 5870 in the number of fps it can generate due to overclocking the core and memory clocks.
 
5850 overclocked will beat the 5870 and if you overclock the 5870 you might get 2-3 fps more for a extra £100 lol
 
Last edited:
I went with a 5870 for now. When, prices come tumbling down in a few months (guessing ofc) i will look to get another and crossfire.
 
5870 all day. why would he get a 5850 when the 5870 is clearly faster ?

If he overclocks he is still going to be better off with the 5870 as it clockes further.

And its not £100 difference anymore, he might get £240 back or whatever he paid and pick up a 5870 for £300 elsewhere.

I had the choice on release when they was £300 and £200 and still stick by my choice.
 
Back
Top Bottom