• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5850 vs 5870

Personally I would pay extra for the 5870 otherwise I'd spend the next year thinking "damn I wish I'd got the 5870 now". :p

It's your choice though ultimately.
 
Some interesting comments! I'm still not particularly sure what to do but will have to decide within the next next week. Hmmmm!!

Rest of the rig just for reference:

Samsung 24" monitor
Intel E6750 Dual Core overclocked to 3.2Ghz
Artic Cooler for CPU
4Gb Corsair Dominator DDR2
Gigabyte P45 mobo
Antec 182 case
Creative Labs Xfi Gamer

running windows 7 64bit
 
Will that processor not hold back both the 5850\5870?

probably yeah, but then I bought the card (sighs...) for the release of MW2 (sighs some more) - so that worked out well....

Plan on going i5 / i7 at some point this year though, but either way, that doesn't change the deal with the 5850.

To note, if anyone hasn't read the original post, I already have the 5850, it's just broken, DX11 artefacts to hell and it has now been RMA'd. The question posed was more is it worth stumping out the extra for the 5870, not sure if overclockers would let me change to something entirely different, I guess I could ask though!
 
lol...'hi overclockers, would you mind if i gave you some more money?

I like to think they would be ok with that. :)

My two cents is for the 5850, only when i do silly things like playing stalker clear sky on full settings does it even spin up, as for lag nothing I have will test it, and by the time it can, I can take the £100 I saved, take another £100 and buy the latest kickass card.

5850 is all the power you really need esp when outputting to a monitor like yours.

Am also going to look into the overclocking, as far as I am aware 5850's are identical to 5870's but have just had some connections cut, this would mean that their chips and thus the possible clockspeeds should be the same.
 
Last edited:
lol...'hi overclockers, would you mind if i gave you some more money?

I like to think they would be ok with that. :)

My two cents is for the 5850, only when i do silly things like playing stalker clear sky on full settings does it even spin up, as for lag nothing I have will test it, and by the time it can, I can take the £100 I saved, take another £100 and buy the latest kickass card.

5850 is all the power you really need esp when outputting to a monitor like yours.

Am also going to look into the overclocking, as far as I am aware 5850's are identical to 5870's but have just had some connections cut, this would mean that their chips and thus the possible clockspeeds should be the same.

Indeed overclocking the 5850 (well not the one I have now, but a new one, that works and so on) could well be an option. Assume this just kills the warranty???
 
Technically speaking, but there is a reason they ship it with overclocking software, no hardware I know of nowadays can really be damaged overclocking if it works right, and they wont know unless you do some pretty extreme and silly things to it.

I havent yet OC'd mine as i dont see a need (yet...), but just had a look and it will go to 1000 on the core so simply taking the slidersin catalyst and slamming them to the right is absolutley fine. Asus cover their cards overclocking up to 1.3v as well, considering it starts around 1.1 and you dont have to increase voltage up to about 850 core clock, i m pretty sure these cards can go a bit faster 24/7 no trouble.

Way I look at it is this; power of 5850 is enough for a 24 inch monitor. Only real case for a 5870 is increased future proofing. Whack the £100 in an account, and come next year, when the 5850 will blatantly still be more than adequate, sell the 5850 for say, £70 and whichever card is hanging around the £200-250 price range is yours for peanuts. You could possibly end up with a 5970 or a fermi chip that will do all kinda wizardy backflipping tricks and that- and at no point will you have wanted for power.

And you can start arguing over whether to spend the extra £100 on the slightly better card all over again :P
 
Last edited:
imo 5850 is a much better card, currently no one knows the answer to the dx11 question- there is only one game that uses it!

The point has been made though that the 5800 series isnt yet showing what it can do, new drivers will over time mean performance increases, wheras I understand the 4800 drivers to be already well developed. New dx 11 games will also allow the cards to show their power more.

http://www.overclock.net/ati/590560-crysis-benchmark-4890-vs-5850-vs.html

Shows the 5850 is significantly faster- but each new set of drivers will increase that margin and having read up on things, the 5850 can also be overclocked a bit no trouble whatsoever (definitely to the catalyst maxes with no issues at all and no extra voltage with the standard max with no extra voltage being 850 core clock and 1100 memory), and a fair bit (we are talking 1000 core clock, opinion seems to be leave memory at 1100) without any real issues and a tad more voltage (1.225-1.3v but this varies from card to card) so long as you take care. (this is through MSI afterburner with the unofficial overclocking setting from 0 to 1, and a voltage increase to 1.3v, which asus actually cover in their warranty meaning they are happy that people wont be burning out cards using this)

I have it on reliable evidence that this will see an improvement from a 26 av frames per second in furmark standard test (not the graphics burn one) giving a max temp of 62 degrees over a minute to a 29 fps average leaving the card at 70 degrees with 1000 core and 1100 memory at 1.25v.

No one who has ever bought the extra power will ever regret their decision, but lots and lots of impartial and 5850 owners are utterly set on it being the best bang for buck as is, and this is only going to get better as the money you could have spent on tech now gets more and more valuable as computing power gets faster and cheaper. Having looked at the overclocks it turns out you can and will get even more than what is currently enough from these cards- 15% is there just off the back of an overclock, there is probably 20% more as drivers come out.

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/catalyst-radeon-hd4870_9.html#sect0 Gives an idea of how drivers increase performance.

Monitor>24inch then 5870 is a definite option, one I would likley go for, but 24inch=>monitor 5850 is surely the way? When you look at the fact that 30+ frames a sec is enough to play a game quite happily- exactly where in any benchmarks does a 5850 fall short?
 
Last edited:
imo 5850 is a much better card, currently no one knows the answer to the dx11 question- there is only one game that uses it!

The point has been made though that the 5800 series isnt yet showing what it can do, new drivers will over time mean performance increases, wheras I understand the 4800 drivers to be already well developed. New dx 11 games will also allow the cards to show their power more.

http://www.overclock.net/ati/590560-crysis-benchmark-4890-vs-5850-vs.html

Shows the 5850 is significantly faster- but each new set of drivers will increase that margin and having read up on things, the 5850 can also be overclocked a bit no trouble whatsoever (definitely to the catalyst maxes with no issues at all and no extra voltage with the standard max with no extra voltage being 850 core clock and 1100 memory), and a fair bit (we are talking 1000 core clock, opinion seems to be leave memory at 1100) without any real issues and a tad more voltage (1.225-1.3v but this varies from card to card) so long as you take care. (this is through MSI afterburner with the unofficial overclocking setting from 0 to 1, and a voltage increase to 1.3v, which asus actually cover in their warranty meaning they are happy that people wont be burning out cards using this)

I have it on reliable evidence that this will see an improvement from a 26 av frames per second in furmark standard test (not the graphics burn one) giving a max temp of 62 degrees over a minute to a 29 fps average leaving the card at 70 degrees with 1000 core and 1100 memory at 1.25v.

No one who has ever bought the extra power will ever regret their decision, but lots and lots of impartial and 5850 owners are utterly set on it being the best bang for buck as is, and this is only going to get better as the money you could have spent on tech now gets more and more valuable as computing power gets faster and cheaper. Having looked at the overclocks it turns out you can and will get even more than what is currently enough from these cards- 15% is there just off the back of an overclock, there is probably 20% more as drivers come out.

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/catalyst-radeon-hd4870_9.html#sect0 Gives an idea of how drivers increase performance.

Monitor>24inch then 5870 is a definite option, one I would likley go for, but 24inch=>monitor 5850 is surely the way? When you look at the fact that 30+ frames a sec is enough to play a game quite happily- exactly where in any benchmarks does a 5850 fall short?

^^ excellent post sir
 
I would say the 5850, the 70 is quite a price jump plus when the price comes down you can crossfire the 50s the 59xx ones are basicly two chips clocked at the 5850 speeds.
Calc the price per FPS and get the better ;)
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mmj_uk View Post
Personally I would pay extra for the 5870 otherwise I'd spend the next year thinking "damn I wish I'd got the 5870 now".

Doesnt work to my mind, I may be wrong here- but simply take hundred quid, sell 5850 and get a fermi card, or a flagship 6000 card. You will feel just as bad if not worse next year when your card is starting to look old...

Also when really trying to strain the card my phenom 965 becomes the bottleneck and that is top of amd's offerings!

A hundred quid goes a long way- if i took a hundred quid to my processor i could have a MASSIVLEY faster processor, or a mo bo that runs circles round my current one, a top of the range case, full cooling for my rig, an SSD instead of a platter, double the ram, or three new games which are at the end of the day why we buy these cards- all of which make paying the extra for 10% more power that you currently dont need a bit of strange decision.

Not knocking anyone who has gone and splashed out, a would certainly LIKE a 5870 a lot, obviously you cinema monitor or eyefinity lot need all you can get, but for us standard display lot, the only argument I see time and time again is 'might as well' in different forms, just the way i see things.
 
Last edited:
I can see both sides of the argument. Personally a 5850 is more than enough and I can't justify the extra on a 5870. However, I also know what I'm like, so much as "oh damn, I wish I'd spent the extra £XX and got that instead of this", on this occasion though, I can safely say that won't happen though as ~50% extra for ~5% gain doesn't tally :p

Of course, everyone is different, but it wouldn't surprise me if a lot of members of these forums felt like that, and then there's always the "what if (I setup Eyefinity, Crysis 2 comes out and a 5850 struggles, [insert reason here]) and I need a 5870 instead?".
 
There is no excuse not to buy a DX11 card now esp a 5850 i would not buy a 4890 now you'll only have to upgrade when the super awsome AVP is out!
 
After calming down. I have placed my Asus 5770 for sale on MM. I think I have repaired my GTX260, which will last me to the winter when I may actually need a new card. Well, one that I can afford anyway.

I think BC2 will run well on my GTX260. Yes there is no DX11, but tbh I couldn't really notice much difference when I'm hurtling along at 100mph in dirt 2.

I guess it will be the same in BC2. Am I going to be standing around and lokking at the tessalation or am I going to be trying to stab my clan mates?

:p
 
It's simple, if you want the best single GPU card and the extra £100 isnt an issue go for the 5870. The 5850 lacks silicone compared to the 5870 and whilst you can overclock the 5850 to 5870 speeds you can't overclock it to overclocked 5870 speeds. The other thing to bear in mind is we may not yet be seeing games that show the difference in numbers of shaders etc between the 5850 and 5870, the difference may get more pronounced in the future.

If you want the best bang for the buck at the high end go with the 5850, it is far better VFM than the 5870
 
Back
Top Bottom