Android/Nexus One: First Impressions

Caporegime
Joined
26 Aug 2003
Posts
37,508
Location
Leafy Cheshire
So, I've had my Nexus One for a few days now, and I've got a few observations of it as both a platform, and the hardware itself.

Firstly the phone as a chunk of hardware. It's pretty good once you get past the fact that the casing isn't as premium as the iPhone 4, and that the fit and finish won't be perfect (differing gaps and fitment of parts). It's by no means a badly finished phone though, and once you do ignore the few slight build quality issues you realise that its got a lovely display, nice styling, and the few hardware buttons (and trackball) it does have feel sturdy and well placed. Like all touchscreen phones, it attracts fingerprints like a demon, but at least the soft-touch back of the phone will attempt to resist scuffs and scratches.

The screen is stunning for the most part. I'd read lots of worrying things about AMOLED screens and over-saturation and inability to be seen properly in bright sunlight. I've experienced in neither however; in bright sunlight, the display correctly adjusted its brightness so it was very readable, and looking at images on both a calibrated display and the phone doesn't make it obvious that the images on the phone are over-saturated.

So, the Android platform. The phone shipped with 2.2, with no updates available (obviously), and first impressions appeared to be solid. The phone booted up very quickly (compared to other smartphone platforms, and I've owned the major 5 - symbian, winmo, iOS, blackberry, android) and quickly presented me with the setup screens. Painless runthrough the initial setup and you're away, which for the most part is a fluid and immersive experience.

Unfortunately this doesn't last long though, I've noted serious problems with WiFi, the Touchscreen, and a few of the default apps themselves:

WiFi - Why do I need to turn it off and then turn it back on for it to connect to ANY WiFi network after the phone has gone to standby? I turn WiFi on, and it will see (for example) my home network (although I've also had the same happen at work, and at a WiFi hotspot in a bar in town) and connect straight away. If I were then to leave the phone alone for a minute (the screen-off timout length), it will drop the connection and then no amount of unlocking the phone, running data-intensive apps, or wandering around will allow the phone to reconnect. Turning WiFi off and back on is the ONLY way to get it to reconnect.

Touchscreen - Ok, so this fails far too often for a "premium" product, infact it fails far too often for ANY product who's main interface is the touchscreen. From randomly thinking I wanted to bring up the keyboard (which I can deal with) to just completely losing all input and causing me to reboot to get it to work again. This is just annoying.

So, all in all, I was initially impressed, but now I'm giving serious consideration to giving it back and getting a second iPhone 4.
 
WiFi - Why do I need to turn it off and then turn it back on for it to connect to ANY WiFi network after the phone has gone to standby? I turn WiFi on, and it will see (for example) my home network (although I've also had the same happen at work, and at a WiFi hotspot in a bar in town) and connect straight away. If I were then to leave the phone alone for a minute (the screen-off timout length), it will drop the connection and then no amount of unlocking the phone, running data-intensive apps, or wandering around will allow the phone to reconnect. Turning WiFi off and back on is the ONLY way to get it to reconnect.

Touchscreen - Ok, so this fails far too often for a "premium" product, infact it fails far too often for ANY product who's main interface is the touchscreen. From randomly thinking I wanted to bring up the keyboard (which I can deal with) to just completely losing all input and causing me to reboot to get it to work again. This is just annoying.

So, all in all, I was initially impressed, but now I'm giving serious consideration to giving it back and getting a second iPhone 4.

There is a setting for wifi timeout

Go on the settings menu and then wifi. Then press menu key on advanced then change the timeout to never, that will stop your problem

I have never had a touch screen problem maybe yours is faulty?
 
There is a setting for wifi timeout

Go on the settings menu and then wifi. Then press menu key on advanced then change the timeout to never, that will stop your problem

Even if WiFi has a timeout (which it should, the battery is pretty awful as it is), surely it should wake back up once the phone is used?

I have never had a touch screen problem maybe yours is faulty?

I've got two handsets here, both do the same.
 
I cant help you because i just set my wifi to turn off when screen goes out and itstill works. Also never had problems with the screen. then again im using custom rom

Sorry
 
Never had the wifi issue and the screen's touch input has only gone haywire 2-3 times in 6 months use. Sounds like you may have a dodgy unit. Did you buy it from Google or elsewhere?

Going back to the wifi issue: go into wifi settings and set it to never turn off. You actually get better battery because when your wifi turns off it uses 3g to continually check your mail/news/weather/twitter etc etc. So many people have reported better battery life with wifi set to 'always on'.
 
I've had the keyboard bum out on me a few times, like the quick reply on this forum. Nothing like what you described though (or iOS 1.2, hehe that was terrible for me)
Androids still relatively new so expect a few niggles, just don't expect the full polish of iOS 4.

As for the touch screen, all the N1s I've used had a similar response to the iPhone (the screen sits deeper in the chassis, maybe that's catching you out?)
 
Even if WiFi has a timeout (which it should, the battery is pretty awful as it is), surely it should wake back up once the phone is used?

I have Hero which runs 2.1 atm. Has run on 1.5, and I had a Tattoo which ran 1.6. They all did (and do) wake up the wifi when the phone wakes up.

I have used my friends Desire for a few days and that woke up the wifi properly as well.

Not had any serious issues with the touchscreens on any of the above phones either.
 
I get the WiFi issue on my x10. Doesnt happen often but when it does, it's annoying. I think it may have something to do with my Weather & toggle app as I use the toggle widgets a lot.
 
My missus has the Nexus one and I really don't like it as much as my desire - the soft buttons are periodically unresponsive. IMO the Desire is the superior design... Never had issues with the touch screen on mine.
 
On my Galaxy S the wifi does the same. I use the wifi on/off toggle to get it to connect to a previously connected to access point. This is at various people's houses so not just one router.

Sometimes it just works though but a lot of the time it doesn't after coming out of standby!
 
Are there any decent backup software solutions for Android devices? Muchlike Blackberry Desktop Manager, iTunes, or Nokia PC suite that take snapshots and allow full restore of all data/apps/contacts/etc?
 
Well, i use HTC Sync for my Desire.

Did the Nexus One not come with a CD with any software on it? Mine also came with a setup exe preloaded on the actual phone. I had to set the phone to storage mode (?) so i could explore it in My Computer, and then i copied the exe to my PC and ran it. T'was in the root dir of the phone iirc.
 
The wi-fi issue is, I believe, a problem that a fair number of people have had. There is a custom rom or program that will sort it out on XDA devs somewhere.

The touchscreen isn't brilliant, and issues were well documented on release. In six months of having mine, I had occasional problems but nothing too bad. Certainly never needed to reboot, but did need to sleep and then wake the phone sometimes to get control back.

Re: contacts backup, they will all be on Google's servers so you don't need to worry about those.
 
BTW, is there any reason you decided to go for the Nexus One? I ask because the Desire is widely accepted as being the best Android phone around (or at least was, before the Motorola Droid X)

However, some, like me, really dislike Motorola phones so i still consider the Desire as number 1.
 
The wi-fi issue is, I believe, a problem that a fair number of people have had. There is a custom rom or program that will sort it out on XDA devs somewhere.

The touchscreen isn't brilliant, and issues were well documented on release. In six months of having mine, I had occasional problems but nothing too bad. Certainly never needed to reboot, but did need to sleep and then wake the phone sometimes to get control back.

Re: contacts backup, they will all be on Google's servers so you don't need to worry about those.

Well no, they won't as I use an exchange email account, but yes they are backed up to that. However that's besides the point, having snapshot style backup ala my iPhone is wonderful. Restore to a fresh/new software update, restore from backup and everything, settings, apps, app settings, everything and anything is restored.

BTW, is there any reason you decided to go for the Nexus One? I ask because the Desire is widely accepted as being the best Android phone around (or at least was, before the Motorola Droid X)

However, some, like me, really dislike Motorola phones so i still consider the Desire as number 1.

With it being 99.5% the same phone as the Desire, and me not liking the style of the desire (buttons at the bottom, what's that all about :confused:), I went for what I knew to be a "good" phone that also had styling I got on with.
 
Well no, they won't as I use an exchange email account, but yes they are backed up to that. However that's besides the point, having snapshot style backup ala my iPhone is wonderful. Restore to a fresh/new software update, restore from backup and everything, settings, apps, app settings, everything and anything is restored.

Installing a custom recovery image (ClockworkMod or Amon Ra) would get you that. But it's maybe a little hardcore.
 
Installing a custom recovery image (ClockworkMod or Amon Ra) would get you that. But it's maybe a little hardcore.
Exactly, its OTT, and something that really does make android "not as good" as iOS.

People rant and rave about how the iPhone is too restrictive, but at least the experience is polished.

I like both platforms, but it's obvious that android still isn't "there" yet.
 
Exactly, its OTT, and something that really does make android "not as good" as iOS.

People rant and rave about how the iPhone is too restrictive, but at least the experience is polished.

I like both platforms, but it's obvious that android still isn't "there" yet.

Heh, that's why I ditched my Nexus One last week and got an iPhone. I had a Magic before that, and a year of owning Android has seen massive improvements, but for me the OS still needs a lot of work in making it visually as satisfying - polished - to use as iOS. It's a shame.
 
WiFi - Why do I need to turn it off and then turn it back on for it to connect to ANY WiFi network after the phone has gone to standby? I turn WiFi on, and it will see (for example) my home network (although I've also had the same happen at work, and at a WiFi hotspot in a bar in town) and connect straight away. If I were then to leave the phone alone for a minute (the screen-off timout length), it will drop the connection and then no amount of unlocking the phone, running data-intensive apps, or wandering around will allow the phone to reconnect. Turning WiFi off and back on is the ONLY way to get it to reconnect.

Touchscreen - Ok, so this fails far too often for a "premium" product, infact it fails far too often for ANY product who's main interface is the touchscreen. From randomly thinking I wanted to bring up the keyboard (which I can deal with) to just completely losing all input and causing me to reboot to get it to work again. This is just annoying.

So, all in all, I was initially impressed, but now I'm giving serious consideration to giving it back and getting a second iPhone 4.

Nothing you've described are native android problems, wifi ALWAYS reconnects for me (and always has on every 2.1 and 2.2 rom I've used, vanilla or custom).

As for the touch screen, either you've got 2 faulty handsets or you've got fingers like richmond sausages and you're just mashing away on the screen.
 
Back
Top Bottom