• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

bad news.

Meh by the time HD DVD or Blueray drives are a reasonable price and readily available everyone will have new gfx cards anyway. Big fuss over nothing imo. Has anyone seen the price of the blueray drive on preorder @ ocuk? If you can justify that purchase then a new gfx card shouldn't be a problem.
 
Yeah it can run Vista, but not fully, to run Vista fully you need a DX10 card, DX9 cards can not do DX10, so it will be like a cut down version of Vista, as the DX10 stuff will not work.
 
LoadsaMoney said:
Yeah it can run Vista, but not fully, to run Vista fully you need a DX10 card, DX9 cards can not do DX10, so it will be like a cut down version of Vista, as the DX10 stuff will not work.
Ah I can live with that, only reason I will change to Vista is because it will go mainstream.
 
This is not about Vista - read the article fully! - this is perhaps the most insidious and destructive attack by 'interested' parties since Sony gave us their rootkit - only this time it really might work and destroy your ability to watch your own movies on your own PC!

And as Mistadave pointed out - even hiding behind the 'anyone who watches DVD's on their pc must be a filthy pirate' will not offer you a chance to gloat - EVERY bit of kit involved in the playing of HD content will have to be DRM compliant - that includes the Screen!

So... Not only will you be able to watch your legally bought HD-DVD on your legitimate pc, you won't even be able to watch it properly on your 'HD-ready' £many tv you thought was a good buy!

But wait... there's more - for those that rely on the fact that the system will be cracked within minutes few of it being released - a log will be kept of all cracked hardware, and it will be barred from playing HD-content :eek:

This means that every time you run HD content - if a new list of banned players in on the disk it will update all your kit - that means that at the stroke of a binary code, Holywood can disable your machine (yes that includes your set top player!)

Surely this will only affect filthy pirates? Riiiiiiiight, you'll never guess what I saw the pope doing in the Polish woods on sky tonight?!?!?! It means that any time you run a new HD-DVD there's a chance that you'll lose your kit because someone in the DRM office ****-up and decided that your model was cracked - and guess what you'll be able to do about it? (And no, I don't condone firebombs and multi-generational curses - even if they are aimed at computer-illiterate-troglodite-crybaby-luddites from B***cks-wood!)

This is a serious problem - read the article - seriously - read the article - if you're not outraged - read it again!
 
From what I remember drm doesnt come into effect for a couple of years because sony and ms made an agreement because most people dont have hdmi/hdcp tvs.
 
Best idea! Don't buy Vista! Simple as that. People should vote with thier money by not buying it then. Who needs Vista anyway?
 
I really am amazed how little there has been on this considering the massive impact it is going to have on the way we go about out computing over the next few years. For the first time you will no longer own your system, rather you will 'borrow' it from content owners to be used as they see fit! I have to say I find the whole idea repugnant - already if I find a CD I've bought is 'protected' from play on PC's I take it back - it's time we started taking back the 'fair usage' corner and stood up to this stupidity. As much as I hate to admit it, I think the French have the right idea dealing with Apple's Itunes - I hope it's the start of the end for oppressive DRM.
 
why are you guys worried about this? it will be easily hacked. the xbox360 has been h4x0r3d and if this form of protection is being a muppet like starforce etc then it will not be around for long.
 
WatchTower said:
What's thos about DirectX 9 cards not supporting HD-DVD I'm sure it reads on my old 6800GS XXX box it supports HD.

HD isnt the same as hd-dvd or blu-ray. It just means it can play hd videos.
 
Cyber-Mav said:
why are you guys worried about this? it will be easily hacked. the xbox360 has been h4x0r3d and if this form of protection is being a muppet like starforce etc then it will not be around for long.

Its not like starforce its built into the cards/dvd players etc.
 
Read the Article - seriously - don't skim, don't skip, READ IT :p

We should all be very worried - if for no other reason than I can bet they vendors won't be highlighting the fact that your shiny new hardware is incapable of doing the job you bought it for .

Vendor: "but it clearly stated on page 144332 section AAz sub-para MMDCCIX of the EULA that your machine isn't fit for purpose - you signed it you fool - don't cry to me now"

The French and Canadians will hopefully prove that nation states are not beholden to individual manufacturers, and will start to protect the consumer rather than the corporate wallet with outrageously-draconeon laws (how the hell can piracy (theft) carry worse penalties than rape FFS :eek: talk about losing sight of the big picture!)

As for you guys feeling smug because your kit says HD ready:

READ THE ARTICLE

Don't come crying to us when your first HD-DVD runs at 200*100 resolution through your shiny new GFX card on your Shiny new 'HD-Ready' TV - just don't!
 
From the article:

HDCP stands for High-bandwidth Digital Content Protection and is an Intel-initiated program that was developed with Silicon Image. This content protection system is mandatory for high-definition playback of HD-DVD or Blu-Ray discs. If you want to watch movies at 1980x1080, your system will need to support HDCP. If you don’t have HDCP support, you’ll only get a quarter of the resolution. A 75% loss in pixel density is a pretty big deal – Wouldn’t you be angry if your car was advertised as doing 16 mpg, and you only got 4 mpg? Or if you bought a 2 GHz CPU and found out that it only ran at 500 MHz?

Every bit of kit that's involved in the playback loop (HD-DVD player/GFX card/TFT monitor) must comply or your get shafted!

And here's the kick in the nuts!

Although ATI has had “HDCP support” in their GPUs since the Radeon 8500, and NVIDIA has had “HDCP support” in their GPUs since the GeForce FX5700, it turns out that things are more complicated -- just because the GPU itself supports HDCP doesn’t mean that the graphics card can output a DVI/HDCP compliant stream. There needs to be additional support at the board level, which includes licensing the HDCP decoding keys from the Digital Content Protection, LLC (a spin-off corporation within the walls of Intel).

After some investigation, Brandon and I determined that there is no shipping retail add-in board with HDCP decoding keys. Simply put, none of the AGP or PCI-E graphics cards that you can buy today support HDCP.
 
Cyber-Mav said:
why are you guys worried about this? it will be easily hacked. the xbox360 has been h4x0r3d and if this form of protection is being a muppet like starforce etc then it will not be around for long.
The core security system on the 360 has not been hacked, so it remains a completely closed system.

What has been hacked is the the protocal between the disc drive and the console, so you can play 'backed up' games, however the process is very complex and it requires new firmware. Microsoft should be able to detect the firmware over Live and ban users accordingly.

HDCP will be hacked - the question is how long will it take?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HDCP
 
I particularly like the fact that even if you buy kit that is compeletely HDCP compliant if the manufacturers fall out with the DRM controllers, they can switch off your kit whenever they like:

Key revocation procedures ensure that devices manufactured by any vendors who violate the license agreement could be relatively easily blocked from receiving HD data.

So even if you do nothing wrong you can still end up with a useless piece of kit.

Will be interesting to see what happens when all the consumers conned into buying HD-ready tvs find out the 'ready' is not quite true:

HD DVD and Blu-ray Disc players will allow content providers to set a flag that will only output full-resolution signals using HDCP. If such a player is connected to a non-HDCP-enabled television set and the content is flagged, the player will output a downsampled 540p signal. Most television sets currently in use are not HDCP-capable, and this would initially negate some of the key benefits of HD-DVD and Blu-ray for many consumers.

Note that the TV/monitor must be HDCP compliant, not just HD ready - at the moment there are only 10 HDCP compliant monitors, think yours is one? Did you when you bought it? Have you been ripped off? (Why did you buy HD-ready if not to be able to watch HD content?)
 
LoadsaMoney said:
Eh, isn't it obvious as Vista is DX10, and theres no DX10 cards out yet, and everyones known this for about 50 years, or am i missing something. :confused:

Really?

A Windows Vista Capable PC includes at least:

* A modern processor (at least 800MHz1).
* 512 MB of system memory.
* A graphics processor that is DirectX 9 capable.

Windows Vista Premium Ready PCs
To get an even better Windows Vista experience, including the Windows Aero user experience, ask for a Windows Vista Capable PC that is designated Premium Ready, or choose a PC that meets or exceeds the Premium Ready requirements described below. Features available in specific premium editions of Windows Vista, such as the ability to watch and record live TV, may require additional hardware.

A Windows Vista Premium Ready PC includes at least:

* 1 GHz 32-bit (x86) or 64-bit (x64) processor1.
* 1 GB of system memory.
* A graphics processor that runs Windows Aero2.
* 128 MB of graphics memory.
* 40 GB of hard drive capacity with 15 GB free space.
* DVD-ROM Drive3.
* Audio output capability.
* Internet access capability.


Not forgetting:

* Processor speed is specified as the nominal operational processor frequency for the device. Some processors have power management which allows the processor to run at lower rate to save power.
* Windows Aero requires:
o DirectX 9 class graphics processor that:
+ Supports a WDDM Driver.
+ Supports Pixel Shader 2.0 in hardware.
+ Supports 32 bits per pixel.
o Adequate graphics memory.
+ 64 MB of graphics memory to support a single monitor less than 1,310,720 pixels
+ 128 MB of graphics memory to support a single monitor at resolutions from 1,310,720 to 2,304,000 pixels
+ 256 MB of graphics memory to support a single monitor at resolutions higher than 2,304,000 pixels
+ Meets graphics memory bandwidth requirements, as assessed by Windows Vista Upgrade Advisor running on Windows XP
* A DVD-ROM may be external (not integral, not built into the system).

Nothing about DX10 in there ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom