Best Graphic Design forums?

Caporegime
Joined
1 Mar 2008
Posts
26,303
I find the best way to improve my work is through criticism from a group of people who will look at it differently and so a forum is perfect.

Looking for a forum that is quite busy, as friendly as possible and offers useful feedback.

Also, a well used GD/Chat section would be a bonus to get to know some of the members.

Normally, I would sign up to a few and see which one I end up staying with, but thought I'd see what you guys suggest. :)
 
I think you meant critique which has a slightly different meaning, you don't want people to criticise your work as thats usually a negative experiance, what you would want is a critique (crit) where you would generally expect people to give feedback.

To be honest I would be interested as I haven't see a place yet.
 
Have you looked at the forums in Worth1000? They are a friendly and very talented bunch of people.

Hadn't, but will now. :) Ta.


I think you meant critique which has a slightly different meaning, you don't want people to criticise your work as thats usually a negative experiance, what you would want is a critique (crit) where you would generally expect people to give feedback.

To be honest I would be interested as I haven't see a place yet.

LOL, yep. :p
 
It's a shame people go to other forums when we could build a great section here!

I've noticed that this forum in particular is quite slow, even though I know we have a lot of talented creative people as regulars.
 
It's a shame people go to other forums when we could build a great section here!

I've noticed that this forum in particular is quite slow, even though I know we have a lot of talented creative people as regulars.

I would much rather stay here but there aren't enough people that actively comment, help and give feedback in the design/coding subforum here.

Perhaps something to renew interest? A monthly competition or something similar to the photography ones here?
 
I would much rather stay here but there aren't enough people that actively comment, help and give feedback in the design/coding subforum here.

Perhaps something to renew interest? A monthly competition or something similar to the photography ones here?

Yeah, I feel we definitely need to be more active in here. The competition thing could be a good idea, but what could we do specifically? It's a bit of a broad forum. We've got graphic designers/developers, web designers, coders, etc - might be hard to find something everyone can get in on.
 
Last edited:
[...] I've noticed that this forum in particular is quite slow, even though I know we have a lot of talented creative people as regulars.
I disagree: I reckon we've only got a handful of talented creative regulars, which is why this forum's 'ground state' is slow.

That's not intended to belittle any contributors, by any stretch! By 'talented, creative' I've inferred those with sufficient skills, experience or raw talent to have a career in design/development/whatever, or be actively pursuing a career in one of those fields.

We certainly have got some talented graphic designers, web designers, web developers, programmers and artists here. Between us all [yes, I am including myself - I've got ten years' experience to make up for any talent deficit ;)] we've got a broad and relatively deep pool of knowledge.

But we've got plenty more here that I'd classify as novices, keen amateurs or, at best, semi-professionals [those who do occasional freelance work].

So the majority of threads, by nature of numbers, are going to be ones asking for advice - often at a basic level.

And here lies the problem, perfectly illustrated by Skippi: once a forum member considers that they've reached a certain level of competence from advice given here, they're going to want to mix with a more dedicated peer group; one of greater skill/knowledge. So they move on, and frequent here less often, sometimes forgetting this place altogether.

Alternatively, you'll occasionally see the more knowledgeable members looking for help on a more specific, advanced topic. There simply aren't enough members here to provide a rounded set of responses, so after drawing a blank or a few educated guesses here, they move on to more dedicated forums, where comprehensive answers are more likely to be obtained.

In a nutshell: this forum is just a waypoint for most; it'll never attract the breadth and depth of knowledge required to really bloom due to the nature of the OcUK demographic.

Hell, the only reason I'm still around is that this place - for better or for worse - has been my internet 'home' for the last eight years or so. :D
 
I see your angle. I imagine many get bored of answering the same request over and over. "What's the best CMS", "CSS Help", "Photoshop request", "What's the best e-commerce", etc.

I'm guilty sometimes of not using the search function, but most of my request are a bit more specific.

We could use this forum as a hub to help each other out, even if it's not just a bit of advice, maybe even farm some work off to each other (not sure if I can bring this up, delete if appropriate Dons).

I just see stuff on here and think wow that's pretty good, but we don't get much discussion here at all from the people who have either (as you say) the talent or experience as a creative individual.

Maybe it's because we don't know enough about each other? This is definitely a sub forum of OcUK where there is a distinct lack of community imo.
 
So about a week on from first registering on DesignersTalk.com, I have found them to be very honest and very helpful. Some members even going as far as to mockup their ideas on how to improve your work.

Quite pleased with it. :)
 
I knew that was you on DT skippi!

Hope you find the par-migration over there useful, when you've been there a while you'll begin to realise the credibility of the wider opinions the people will give you. My advice: take their criticism and use it, and you'll get respect. Can see you're already doing fine though :p
 
I knew that was you on DT skippi!

Hope you find the par-migration over there useful, when you've been there a while you'll begin to realise the credibility of the wider opinions the people will give you. My advice: take their criticism and use it, and you'll get respect. Can see you're already doing fine though :p

Yup, have had to bite my tongue a couple of times though when I had just joined as they seem to think that any newbie that asks for help is just there to freeload. :p

But I've given my fair share of advice to others too and have taken theirs, and shown the results of what I've done with it. :)

Good forums they have there.
 
Taken from my CreativeNerd logo thread on DesignersTalk:

cresolve said:
a thread like this compensates for every 1000 threads posted by dip****s who ask for help, ignore it and fail to progress beyond jnr MS paint artist. Great to skim over the previous posts and see how this has evolved - awesome stuff!


:p
 
Back
Top Bottom