Bought undeclared Cat N car is there anything I can do?

SquirrelMadness

SquirrelMadness

SquirrelMadness

Associate
Joined
30 Aug 2014
Posts
705
Bought yesterday from private seller. Just did an HPI check and shows as Cat N. Used bank transfer to pay, added car reg to transfer notes. Seller refuses to refund says they didn't know it was Cat N. Doesn't saw Cat-anything on the log book. Car is sitting uninsured on the grass (or still on his insurance).

Any solutions to getting money back?

Thanks.
 
Private sale, sold as seen. Why wouldn't you do the HPI check before buying? Costs a fiver. Chalk it up to experience, and when you sell it on hope someone else doesn't do the check!
 
Unless it was explicitly sold as not a Cat N, etc. I doubt you have any comeback here. It is worth doing the HPI check as often you get some protection against it being wrong then for the sake of a few quid.
 
I suppose police could find out if he did an HPI check on it himself if they wanted. So "I didn't know" wouldn't work and it's fraud. But I doubt they would care that much.
 
Last edited:
Is there any way I can find out when the car was purchased by him? The accident is noted as being on Dec 2018 and he said in a call he was the owner for over a year... but then came back in a text to say he bought it in Jan 2019. Is there any way I can find out his actual purchase date/transfer of ownership? I have the call recorded.
 
Regardless of whether they knew, unless the advert said 'not a write off' there isn't much you can do about it anyway. You'd need to prove he deliberately lied about it to get anywhere in small claims court and from what you've said here, I don't think you've got enough to prove that.
 
Kenai said:
Regardless of whether they knew, unless the advert said 'not a write off' there isn't much you can do about it anyway. You'd need to prove he deliberately lied about it to get anywhere in small claims court and from what you've said here, I don't think you've got enough to prove that.
Click to expand...
He stated in the recorded call that he didn't know it was Cat N. Accident happened Dec 2018. If I can prove he owned the car during it getting catted that is proof he is lying.
 
SquirrelMadness said:
He stated in the recorded call that he didn't know it was Cat N. Accident happened Dec 2018. If I can prove he owned the car during it getting catted that is proof he is lying.
Click to expand...
This is all after the sale though isn't it? It's irrelevant if he didn't lie during the sale (and so mislead you deliberately) and as I understand it, as a private seller, he's only obliged to say something if asked - he doesn't have to volunteer the information.

This is the inherent risk with private sales (and partly why they're cheaper than buying from a dealer) - if you haven't checked and you don't ask, you're up **** creek unless he was daft enough to write something in an advert that's evidently a lie.
 
Clov!s said:
Next time you buy a car, don’t be stupid enough to do a HPI check after you’ve handed cash over?

What were you thinking?
Click to expand...

I've forgotten to do it before to be fair - fortunately doing it after came back clear. I would have only blamed myself if it hadn't though.
 
Problem with private seller, as you must do the right questions. A whole different thing if it was a dealer.
The car document should show when he registered it? Also the original listing, any mention to no accident or general condition?
 
MrPotato said:
Problem with private seller, as you must do the right questions. A whole different thing if it was a dealer.
The car document should show when he registered it? Also the original listing, any mention to no accident or general condition?
Click to expand...
I went with my friend who's bought loads of cars and the first thing he said when he saw the log book was that it ain't registered as a Cat so I took that for it. Seller also agreed with this.

Also how would asking questions matter if it wasn't recorded? Someone can just say he explicitly stated it's not a Cat N and have whoever they were with back them up.
 
SquirrelMadness said:
I went with my friend who's bought loads of cars and the first thing he said when he saw the log book was that it ain't registered as a Cat so I took that for it. Seller also agreed with this.

Also how would asking questions matter if it wasn't recorded? Someone can just say he explicitly stated it's not a Cat N and have whoever they were with back them up.
Click to expand...

It won't help if it wasn't recorded, but yours was....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom