• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

co-op ID rant

I' m 20 and got ID'd while buying wine at M&S. Did I whine and moan? No. I just gave him my ID and then was on my way. Whats the big deal?

The OP mentioned that his details (including his address) had been recorded in a book behind the counter. I wouldn't be entirly happy about this since the book can probably be read by anyone who works in the shop. It get's worse when you consider the spotty herbert behind the counter will also have had sight of my debit/credit card.

The second objection is if these guidelines helped reduce teenage drinking wwe'd be seeing less ****ed up teenagers in our public spaces, not more.
 
Yep, sadly it's true. Supposed to be name, address, age, what they're wearing, etc.

I can tell you now, when I worked at Tesco we just gave up doing it - all we got was a load of attitude for filling out a pointless book.

But I know the police came down on Head Office like a ton of bricks because nobody in our "area" was bothering either - hence the irate phone call and staff meeting about it.

I still don't think it gets filled in, but no doubt some stores do try and enforce it.


http://www.thisissouthwales.co.uk/n...ge-alcohol/article-606589-detail/article.html


This is quite funny, as said above, there's plenty of details floating around.... and the other issue can be supply to minors, I agree a book is a micky take though, as well as being somewhat patronising it slows down service...
 
Just an addition to my earlier posts, my off license doesnt take the address, only the name, dob, and licence number. I know its still rubbish, but better than taking everything.
 
Why are so many people missing the point of the thread?

because the whole reason rules are so tight now is because of the old "I don need ID to buy this, i old enough" argument. Because of all thoses "types" we are having to do logs like Co-op's. In the past we'd just ID you, now we have to write all this rubbish down to proove we ID'ed you.
 
My guess would be the person who logged the details has mis-understood the request to log details of who has been requested for idea AND refused, not of everyone asked.
 
The level of personal information requested is not acceptable.

Regarding the ID requests, I would rather be asked for ID every time I buy something that requires it than have an unregulated system which allows 15/16/17 year olds to be buying whatever.
 
Regarding the ID requests, I would rather be asked for ID every time I buy something that requires it than have an unregulated system which allows 15/16/17 year olds to be buying whatever.

The system does not need to be unregulated ... the system should be "if you have a suspicion that the person is not 18 then ask for ID", the system should not be "ask everyone for ID" (has been reported by media a few times where even old people got IDed), or "ask every person under 25 for ID", or "refuse to sell to people who happen to have un-IDed or under 18 people with them" (again has happened where a guy was refused alcohol because he took his younger cousin to the shop with him).

Funnily only the first system description is the law - all others are store policies.
 
My local co-op started doing the age 25 check about 3 weeks prio to it starting, even when the displayed signs said different.

When i asked why they didnt seem to understand...idiots...
Co-op is overpriced anyway, why should we have to pay double for convenience?
 
Lets list people who suffer in that scenario. The seller, the family, the people who have to clean up the mess, the taxpayer paying to clean up the mess.
It takes no effort to carry your id, if you look under 25 its your own fault if you havent got it.
 
Lets list people who suffer in that scenario. The seller, the family, the people who have to clean up the mess, the taxpayer paying to clean up the mess.
It takes no effort to carry your id, if you look under 25 its your own fault if you havent got it.

The seller ... one less person to worry about id'ing ;)
The family - probably didnt give a *&£$ then they were alive. :D
The people who have to pay for a clean up the mess - ok now i understand why its a bad thing......:p
 
The seller will get fined, sacked maybe if the kid keeps the reciept, and a kids death hanging over their head the rest of their life. And you cant seriously think a family wont care when their son/ daughter dies falling off a building.
Point is, the rules are there for a reason, if youre old enough to buy alcohol or whatever whats the problem?
 
Last edited:
It's supposed to be done. We got a right rollicking from Head Office because we didn't keep ours up to date.

Don't like it? Talk to your MP. These rules are made at government level.

poor response, your company has no right to take someones details without their permission, its the same as when you return something to say Argos and they turn around and ask for your home address! I refuse everytime, because I have the right to protect my personal details.
 
The only effect I can see this having is cashiers and such not being arsed to ID people? Way to go.

I had this in Coral recently, thought it was just their policy.
 
The seller will get fined, sacked maybe if the kid keeps the reciept, and a kids death hanging over their head the rest of their life. And you cant seriously think a family wont care when their son/ daughter dies falling off a building.
Point is, the rules are there for a reason, if youre old enough to buy alcohol or whatever whats the problem?

Some one needs to take a chill pill and find out the age they need to be to buy a sence of humor :p
 
The system does not need to be unregulated ... the system should be "if you have a suspicion that the person is not 18 then ask for ID", the system should not be "ask everyone for ID" (has been reported by media a few times where even old people got IDed), or "ask every person under 25 for ID", or "refuse to sell to people who happen to have un-IDed or under 18 people with them" (again has happened where a guy was refused alcohol because he took his younger cousin to the shop with him).

Funnily only the first system description is the law - all others are store policies.

It can be quite difficult to tell whether some 16 years olds are not 18+ as they look much older, equally some 20 something’s can look under 18 or close to it. It can still be quite difficult to tell with an under 21 policy.

ID’ing people who may look under 25 provides a sufficient contingency to pretty much ensure no under 18s slip through. The big issue is the risk to the employee selling the alcohol if they get it wrong and are caught out. Therefore, for their protection it makes sense to have these safeguards in place. If I worked in a shop and Knew if I got it wrong that I could be hit with a £1000 fine and loose my job, I would prefer to ID everyone.

Challenge 25 or asking everyone draws a clear line in the sand. If we had always had to produce ID to buy Alcohol, then people would obviously just accept it as the way it is done.

This is actually a sensible scheme for once which attracts some rather unnecessary opposition. I would personally rather see it as a blanket “produce ID approach” without the need to record details etc.

The above is of course a separate issue to the OP’s problem with the quantum of personal data required.
 
Back
Top Bottom