• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

co-op ID rant

Funnily only the first system description is the law - all others are store policies.

congratulations on missing the point, supermarkets are private property, owned by the company, it's well within their rights to refuse sale to you for any reason. the think21/25 scheme is designed to ensure minimum chance of under 18s being served, the possible consequences of this are:

for the cashier
fine (1k)
disaplinary action (the result often being a sacking)
a possible criminal record

for the company/store
much larger fine (i dunno the exact amount of the top of my head)
loss of license to trade (loss of revenue)
bad press

the scheme may not BE the law, but it is designed to UPHOLD the law and there is nothing you can do about it ;) don't like it? tough.
 
Im 22, I get asked for id in supermarkets nearly every time nowadays.

It doesn't worry me, they record the type of alcohol purchased normally the date and time then sign. Not once have they copied down anything personal, name or description. (generally in Sainsburys)
 
It can be quite difficult to tell whether some 16 years olds are not 18+ as they look much older, equally some 20 something’s can look under 18 or close to it. It can still be quite difficult to tell with an under 21 policy.

ID’ing people who may look under 25 provides a sufficient contingency to pretty much ensure no under 18s slip through. The big issue is the risk to the employee selling the alcohol if they get it wrong and are caught out. Therefore, for their protection it makes sense to have these safeguards in place. If I worked in a shop and Knew if I got it wrong that I could be hit with a £1000 fine and loose my job, I would prefer to ID everyone.

Challenge 25 or asking everyone draws a clear line in the sand. If we had always had to produce ID to buy Alcohol, then people would obviously just accept it as the way it is done.

This is actually a sensible scheme for once which attracts some rather unnecessary opposition. I would personally rather see it as a blanket “produce ID approach” without the need to record details etc.

The above is of course a separate issue to the OP’s problem with the quantum of personal data required.
If you have a suspicion someone is not 18 you ID, there is no need for this under 25 nonsense.

congratulations on missing the point, supermarkets are private property, owned by the company, it's well within their rights to refuse sale to you for any reason. the think21/25 scheme is designed to ensure minimum chance of under 18s being served, the possible consequences of this are:

for the cashier
fine (1k)
disaplinary action (the result often being a sacking)
a possible criminal record

for the company/store
much larger fine (i dunno the exact amount of the top of my head)
loss of license to trade (loss of revenue)
bad press

the scheme may not BE the law, but it is designed to UPHOLD the law and there is nothing you can do about it ;) don't like it? tough.
We have every right to complain about the store policy, which is what we are doing here. Don't like the negative press and complaints? Well then change your policy.
 
It's not a weapon, but it can be destructive.

Lets say you sell a 15 year old chav alcohol, chav gets way to drunk, gets onto a roof and starts the walk along the edge, slips, caves his head in and dies.

Wait what? I think you missed my admittedly crappy 'screwdriver' joke....
 
We have every right to complain about the store policy, which is what we are doing here. Don't like the negative press and complaints? Well then change your policy.

Don't like our policy? Don't come in our stores. Simple as, really. Every supermarket is adopting the same policy, what are you going to do now then? You'll do as we tell you to. :)

Gillywibble - not everyone is missing the point here. I've stated several times that I call BS on the OP because it isn't our policy to record personal details.

I'll quite happily take a photo of our logbook at work so you can see for yourselves if you like :p
 
Gillywibble - not everyone is missing the point here. I've stated several times that I call BS on the OP because it isn't our policy to record personal details.

And of course it's not possible for the cashier to have misunderstood these policies and written the address down by mistake?

Why would the OP lie?
 
And of course it's not possible for the cashier to have misunderstood these policies and written the address down by mistake?

Why would the OP lie?

Search me, it's the internet. Obviously, there's an outside chance you're right but I'm quite surprised by it I guess. Perhaps it was a misunderstood new employee.. nobody knows.
 
It's not a weapon, but it can be destructive.

Lets say you sell a 15 year old chav alcohol, chav gets way to drunk, gets onto a roof and starts the walk along the edge, slips, caves his head in and dies.
Woosh, I think that joke went over your head :D (Vodka & Orange = a drink called a Screwdriver).... :p
 
Back
Top Bottom