• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Do PHEVs charge whilst driving?

Anyone who thinks they are saving the planet by purchasing a PHEV needs to think again
BBC News - Plug-in hybrids are a 'wolf in sheep's clothing'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54170207
It is all just a folly and purely electric cars aren't really the solution either and should not sorely be the focus of attention
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/opini...ust-consider-how-we-generate-electricity-them

In a surprise to no one, the test cycle doesn’t reflect real world usage. Particularly where company car drivers get them for the tax savings and don’t bother to charge them at all.

Not sure what the point is about BEVs, no one argues they are carbon neutral, only emission free at the tail pipe. They still put out particulate emissions from the tyres and brakes. At the end of the day they are considerably better than an ICE car on lifetime emissions, particularly where people breathe the air which is the entire point. EVs are not going to ‘save the planet’, just damage it less.

There is nothing in the legislation that prevents other alternative fuelled vehicles being developed. Nothing stopping hydrogen fuelled vehicles from being a thing either.

But there is a certain irony about an article titled ‘we need to think about where the electric comes from’ which also contains a section promoting hydrogen as the solution, got to chuckle sometimes. :p
 
Anyone who thinks they are saving the planet by purchasing a PHEV needs to think again
BBC News - Plug-in hybrids are a 'wolf in sheep's clothing'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54170207
It is all just a folly and purely electric cars aren't really the solution either and should not sorely be the focus of attention
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/opini...ust-consider-how-we-generate-electricity-them

so it’s neither? What’s the message and narrative you are constructing as opposed to regurgitation?
 
Anyone who thinks they are saving the planet by purchasing a PHEV needs to think again
BBC News - Plug-in hybrids are a 'wolf in sheep's clothing'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54170207
It is all just a folly and purely electric cars aren't really the solution either and should not sorely be the focus of attention
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/opini...ust-consider-how-we-generate-electricity-them

No surprise there but its still a third less than ICE cars so thats still got to be good as a stop gap? I know some people who have specced hybrids as company cars purely for the BIK tax breaks and they have never charged their car up once in a year of owning it. There are perfromance hybrids which will hardly ever be driven on pure electric except for maybe through towns. They are sold for the performance, nothing to do with environmental reasons.

I might have gone full EV if there was EVs which could tow decent weights but they arent there yet. That and the fact i live 27 miles from work so I can actually go to work and home purely on electric so thats 15,000 of my annual 20,000 miles covered on pure electric. The other 5,000 miles I will tank around like a loon though :)
 
See, as others have said, i kind of see a PHEV as my next step towards a BEV. Mainly due to the charging infrastructure that 'seems' to still be playing catchup against all the new sales of BEVs. (unless someone can prove otherwise). A friend of ours has a corsa-e and she plans all her longer journeys so she can charge up. The other week she went to Fulham, planned to charge up somewhere near but all the charging points were being used and it made her nearly 2 hours late.
So, until more charging points are available AND you can book your charger for an allotted time (don't know why this isn't a thing already), then BEV isn't for me right now.
Happy to have my mind changed though. :)
 
Mainly due to the charging infrastructure that 'seems' to still be playing catchup against all the new sales of BEVs. (unless someone can prove otherwise).

Still seems to be the case around here.

One the charging equipment is entirely missing, despite being advertised and the bays there, and has been for awhile, the one at a dealer has cars for sale parked in the bays. There is an Osprey one with mostly good reviews and availability but also a good number of reviews from people saying it wouldn't charge their vehicle. Another has long queues every time I go past and 90% 1 star reviews saying the chargers are broken or only running at reduced wattage.
 
If it’s configured as a generator like the BMW i3 then potentially, but even that only gets about 40 mpg while using its range extender and it’s a tiny little hatch. The i3s little range extender engine is not connected to its wheels at all. They don’t make them anymore because it’s just better to give the car more range in the first place.

PHEVs are not normally configured in this way as they are an ICE powered car first and foremost. The ICE connected to a gearbox and the rest of the drive system because they need to be. The electric system doesn’t have the power needed to do the job on its own and it’s generally there to assist. While some can get you up to 70mph, it’s a very steady acceleration. As soon as you mash the go pedal, the engine kicks in. Want heating? That will be the engine kicking in etc.

I think the i3 120AH (latest one) with a Range Extender (REX) is still available in some countries, just not here. Bit of a shame really - the charging network is and probably will continue be one of the big trouble areas here so having a petrol generator to fall back on will be appealing to many. Infrastructure improving but needs to improve at a fast pace to keep up with adoption, you just know we're going to go through periods of trouble with charger availability. Shame a BEV with a generator penalised so badly. Alternative is people go for big heavy EV's with a massive battery so they don't fear running out of juice so much which doesn't seem great for the environment either

The Mazda MX-30 is available in the UK. Smaller battery than the i3 I think but can buy them new with the range extender soon.
 
for I3 rex system, at least, after having read it is a 3rd party rex motor with questionable reliability - I'm a bit more sceptic, despite the cars ergonomics/design/materials

That's pretty unsatisfactory. The kymco engine in the rex was identified by sandy Munro of Munro and associates as having this issue. Idk how BMW can requisition an engine build that isn't as good as the original engine. The rex runs on premium fuel at half rpm max when compared to the original gt650 engine. A 60 hp motor detuned to 34hp should last forever with just fluids/ plugs/ and coils.
 
Anyone who thinks they are saving the planet by purchasing a PHEV needs to think again
BBC News - Plug-in hybrids are a 'wolf in sheep's clothing'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54170207
It is all just a folly and purely electric cars aren't really the solution either and should not sorely be the focus of attention
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/opini...ust-consider-how-we-generate-electricity-them

Many people buying these don't care about saving the planet, predominantly it comes down to running/ownership costs, if BEVs/PHEVs were taxed the same as an ICE vehicle as you purchase and on the fuel, no one would buy them.
 
for I3 rex system, at least, after having read it is a 3rd party rex motor with questionable reliability - I'm a bit more sceptic, despite the cars ergonomics/design/materials

like what does that even mean? Can you ask Santa for a tub of anti-conjecture grease to lubricate your posts…

BMW essentially use one of their scooter engines and no suprise it’s difficult to now meet emissions requirements aswell as some NVH issues. Nothing an OEM fits to its own cars at the factory is “third party”.

It terms of i3 and BEV it’s a shame really as loads of space for i3 was packaged out to protect for its
 
Back
Top Bottom