Soldato
In the last 8 years i've never once contacted another insurance company to shop around. I let my renewal come through, phone them to tell them no, fabricate a story that I've already had other quotes, they always go away for 5 minutes, come back and match or better the fabricated quote.
This year the renewal was 530. I paid 330
I do exactly the same thing, except after a quick price comparison site check to make sure I'm not completely taking the ****.