• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

EV general discussion

I really don't get that argument.

The heating controls are in the same place 100% of the time. What difference does it make if it's a physical button or a button on a GUI as long as it remains in the same place.
 
I really don't get that argument.

The heating controls are in the same place 100% of the time. What difference does it make if it's a physical button or a button on a GUI as long as it remains in the same place.
I get what you're saying but even if it's always in the same place on a touchscreen you've got no physical landmark to guide you to it so you generally will always have to at least glance at the screen. A physical button/knob, hand out give it a twiddle (fnar) eyes never leave the road.
 
I get what you're saying but even if it's always in the same place on a touchscreen you've got no physical landmark to guide you to it so you generally will always have to at least glance at the screen. A physical button/knob, hand out give it a twiddle (fnar) eyes never leave the road.
How do you see the temperature you set without looking at the little LCD next to the physical dial?

I just use a voice command, easier than either option.
 
That is a genuinely baffling choice by Tesla. Though the glovebox is so small you can't really put much in there anyway. I just have a microfibre cloth and that's about it.
Not sure I agree.

It having an electronic release means you can lock the glove box with something which isn’t tied to a physical key (not that the car has one). It also automatically locks when in valet mode etc.

It’s not unique to Tesla anyway, the Polestar 4 I drove the other day was identical. The lack of a physical key isn’t unique either, sure some cars have emergency key blades but no one is getting that out to lock their glovebox.
 
I get what you're saying but even if it's always in the same place on a touchscreen you've got no physical landmark to guide you to it so you generally will always have to at least glance at the screen. A physical button/knob, hand out give it a twiddle (fnar) eyes never leave the road.

My rebuttal to this is how often are you changing the temperature in your car? My car is set to 21.5c (the .5 is important, OK) all year round.

Failing that, I expect this depends on your car for the experience, but the voice control works perfectly fine if I want to adjust it without faffing around.
 
The argument is mute anyway as pretty much all modern cars have climate control that seldom needs adjusting.

The climate was set at 20c when I got my car, it’s still sat at 20C now.
 
Not sure I agree.

It having an electronic release means you can lock the glove box with something which isn’t tied to a physical key (not that the car has one). It also automatically locks when in valet mode etc.

It’s not unique to Tesla anyway, the Polestar 4 I drove the other day was identical. The lack of a physical key isn’t unique either, sure some cars have emergency key blades but no one is getting that out to lock their glovebox.

I just think it's a bit weird locking it behind software instead of a much simpler solution of a hatch. But as you say it makes securing it a hell of a lot easier.
 
Based on it being far more clunky and annoying.

Why should I need to look away from the road to turn the heating/AC up.

Looks like NCAP agrees...
NCAP permits climate control temperature adjustment to be via touch interface as long as it's sufficiently large and segregated.

1000052952.webp
 
I just think it's a bit weird locking it behind software instead of a much simpler solution of a hatch. But as you say it makes securing it a hell of a lot easier.

A bit annoying having to switch the car on and press buttons just to open it. Even more annoying if you have disconnected the battery and then need something from it.
 
Last edited:
How do you see the temperature you set without looking at the little LCD next to the physical dial?
That's the point though isn't it? The current temperature is irrelevant, want it half a degree warmer = one click to the right. A degree cooler = two clicks to the left etc.

I'm probably the odd one but if often fiddle my temperature up and down between 20'C and 22'C based on how I'm feeling and what I'm wearing.
 
A bit annoying having to switch the car on and press buttons just to open it. Even more annoying if you have disconnected the battery and then need something from it.
Now you are just making stuff up.

A modern car with this feature is ‘on’ as soon as you open the door.

You aren’t easily getting in a modern car like this if you have disconnected the battery.

Not withstanding the nonsense strawman where you have ‘accidentally left something really important in the glove box of a car which I went to a lot of trouble of disconnecting the battery from’ scenario which just doesn’t happen.

Why are you even in this thread?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom