Your player didnt even get any of the ball when he hacked down Defoe.
So? I'm not talking about that one, I'm talking about the Dawson/Beckford one. How could it possibly not be a pen? You have to play the ball before the man, Dawson played Beckford with both legs before any touch on the ball.
He gets the ball with his right and then his left comes around. What's he supposed to do? Cut his left leg off?
No, just play the ball first. He clearly didn't, as was agreed by the guys in the studio who have had plenty of chances to view it.