I've now been on 4 cruises, all with P&O. Three on Aurora and one on Arcadia (both the adult ships) and we are booked now to do Iona next year and a MSC PREZIOSA one early next year too as we try out different Ships and companies. Impression we have so far is P&O is a pretty low cost but decent cruise, we have enjoyed all so far.
But the reason I've quoted you is I'm looking at something special, probably Northern Europe for 2026 and an anniversary. Whilst looking at alternatives to P&O I did spend a bit of time looking at Celebrity Apex. Main negative reviews seem to be lack of outside space, large portions of the best bits of the ship are for the top tier people only (retreat class?) and entertainment seems patchy with little to do during the day with not many places to sit on poverty class with difficultly getting served. Rough numbers for comparison, P&O cruise comes in at 4k, Apex (without the Retreat class) is 5k total but 10k with retreat which is over my spend tbh.
Did you go top class? or did you go standard and found it good? Everyone says the rooms are fantastic but thats not really the selling point for me!
I have sailed on all the Solstice, most of the Edge class Celebrity ships, and never higher than Aquaclass, and I would say those negative reviews are overblown.
Yes, Celebrity is more of a relaxed atmosphere, it does not have the party vibes of Carnival or Royal, but my wife and I have been sailing with them since our 30s, and have never been bored. Admittedly, we aren't stay-up-late party people, as we tend to get up early and explore the ports that we visit, but even on sea days we have plenty of time to chill, do quizzes, watch shows, eat, drink, take part in activities (we really enjoyed the pseudo-escape room on Apex). They do skew on the older side in the UK (averaging around 60), so the entertainers are often geared more towards the oldies, but we love the production shows, which are much more contemporary, and the theatre on Edge class is blooming gorgeous. Eden is also a great place to chill and take in the views of the ship's wake, and the Eden cafe is one of my favourite places for lunch.
In terms of the Retreat, the biggest difference is that it does not come with the same issues that the MSC Yacht Club or NCL's Haven concepts. On Edge class they do get their own sundeck at the front, their own dining room (which is way too fancy fru-fru for us any way), and their lounge. When you leave the Yacht Club on an MSC ship and go into gen-pop, the experience degrades massively and it becomes like a zoo. On Celebrity ALL areas of the ship are spacious, well designed and frankly just lush. There is no 'poverty class' as you put it, and is the main reason why I never even consider the Retreat, as I don't feel I am getting a worse experience not being in there.
I'm not sure on the issue of outside space, were they perhaps referring to the Infinite balconies? Those are pretty polarizing for some, but I actually prefer them to traditional balconies, especially in cooler regions like Alaska or the Fjords. In terms of outside public spaces, you have a pretty baller main pool deck, with a sick infinity loop walking track that spans 2 decks, sunset bar, big are of the rooftop garden, plus the Magic Carpet. There is also space on the lower decks outside Eden.
Also, Oceanview cafe on Edge class is a fantastic buffet, big, bright double height windows with amazing views, free ice-cream counter, a variety of foods that a notable step up from Royal/MSC, and a pizza counter right at the back. We actually tend to have most of our dinners there rather than in main dining, as the whole restaurant faff of having a waiters, being served courses, etc, is not how we like to holiday (others love that obvs), and being able to picks and choose a variety and eat more leisurely is our preference.
I have done 4 northern Europe cruises, Baltics and St Petersburg (pre-Ukraine) on Azamara, Norwegian Fjords on Celebrity Eclipse and then again on Apex a few years later, and this year we did a Best Of Scandinavia cruise on Apex again. The one this year we were just in an Oceanview (and were in Aquaclass on Apex for the Fjords), and honestly had no issue. Room was still spacious, and much cheaper than Aquaclass (which admittedly did have full access to the Spa facilities for the whole cruise, and Blu as the exclusive restaurant).
Basically, Celebrity offers a relaxed, premium experience with good food and great service (honestly the crew are amazing), fewer kids, and sexy hardware.