• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Greece Elections

doesn't matter if it was Russia or not

Germany lost

Well technically it does as the comment was about diplomacy, which Germany worked masterfully in WW2, if they hadn't messed up the battle tactics part they would have beaten Britain and Russia however they were not as good at that as they were diplomacy.


and honestly you think it was fixed in 66? REALLY?

I think that England would never have made it to the final had a referee not spontaneously taken it upon himself to send off the captain of the team that was knocking England out, then make up a story about it, it's hard to believe he was working alone.
 
Well technically it does as the comment was about diplomacy, which Germany worked masterfully in WW2, if they hadn't messed up the battle tactics part they would have beaten Britain and Russia however they were not as good at that as they were diplomacy.




I think that England would never have made it to the final had a referee not spontaneously taken it upon himself to send off the captain of the team that was knocking England out, then make up a story about it, it's hard to believe he was working alone.



they still lost WW2 - no matter how you spin it , Russia rolled in from the east and usa/uk from the west.

carry on spinning it with excuses , Germany still lost.
 
I think that England would never have made it to the final had a referee not spontaneously taken it upon himself to send off the captain of the team that was knocking England out, then make up a story about it, it's hard to believe he was working alone.

We were never behind in the Argentina game. Think your conspiracy theory needs a bit more work.
 
Last edited:
they still lost WW2 - no matter how you spin it , Russia rolled in from the east and usa/uk from the west.

carry on spinning it with excuses , Germany still lost.

Considering that the whole point of WW2 from Germany's perspective was to establish Germany as the economic and industrially dominant force in Europe (Surrounded by De-industrialized, economically dependent, satellite states)

Then, In the long run, I'd say, the plan seems to have worked out reasonably well. :/
 
they still lost WW2 - no matter how you spin it , Russia rolled in from the east and usa/uk from the west.

carry on spinning it with excuses , Germany still lost.

Regardless of the actual outcome of WW2, Germany arguably benefited the most during the post-war period, largely as a result of assistance and investment from the victors of WW2, who wrote off a large part of German debts to fuel economic growth in Western Europe.
 
they still lost WW2 - no matter how you spin it

Not trying to spin anything, you're the one going on about it, I think you need to look back through the conversation.

All I was pointing out was that losing two wars and a world cup (I think they have lost more than one world cup TBH) doesn't really have anything to do with their diplomacy skills (which is what was being discussed) the second war was lost due to poor battle tactics (they outclassed everyone involved on the diplomacy front) and the football isn't really relevant.



It's already been posted, seven posts ago.


We were never behind in the Argentina game. Think your conspiracy theory needs a bit more work.

No but we were going to lose, even after their captain got sent off for a fabricated reason we only managed a one goal win. Then we faced the favourites to win the tournament and the FA had the venue changed to Wembley so the bigger crowd would help us and we managed to squeeze a one goal win. Finally we faced Germany and won thanks to a goal that never crossed the line.

One of those on it's own would be suspicious but anyone who think all three in a row are probably just coincidence is deluided.
 
Last edited:
Well technically it does as the comment was about diplomacy, which Germany worked masterfully in WW2, if they hadn't messed up the battle tactics part they would have beaten Britain and Russia however they were not as good at that as they were diplomacy.

They could never have beaten Britain. They did not possess the navy to allow a landing. Look at the official Normandy site to see the amount of naval craft involved. Not to mention Mulberry, Pluto etc, etc. Then there was Enigma. That landing was unopposed which would have been different to one on Britain as we had one of the biggest navies at the time. Germany never had a strategic heavy bomber like the Lancaster so the damage was light compared to what the RAF managed. The Germans never had enough U-boats to completely strangle shipping, even Donitz said he needed three times as many U-boats as he had available. All this rubbish you read about "we would all have been talking German" is not founded in fact.

"Russian muscle and American manufacture" probably sums it up.
 
Operation Sealion had 160,000 Heer troops in French ports in june 1940 - the only thing between them and an assault on the UK was that small strip of water.

we had no army - it had been kicked out of france at that point and whilst we had troops we didn't have armour.

The concern was the RAF and the fleet of fast light and medium bombers - and a lot of fighters. So the main objective was to eliminate the aircraft and the eyes before a naval landing. Thus we had the Battle of Britain.

The cost was high for both sides - but Operation Sealion was cancelled on October 11th - as Goering had not delivered the Air Supremacy he had promised.
 
As for diplomacy - I think Operation Overlord was the biggest masterstroke of diplomacy - ever.


persuade your enemy the entire naval invasion wasn't coming to where you think it was.
 
They could never have beaten Britain.

I really don't want to dwell on this as it's OT, however:

They could have very easily have beaten us if Hitler had not messed it up, Goring had the battle of Britain won, the RAF was down to it's last fighters, the were zero reinforcements, Churchill was informed that the Luftwaffe would have total air dominance over Britain in a week. Then RAF bombing of German cities angered Hitler so much that he ordered Goring to ignore the RAF bases and target London/etc instead, that one screw up change the course of the battle of Britain in our favour, we were able to regroup and fight back.

Had that not happened then with air dominance the Luftwaffe would have cut the Royal Navy to pieces and obliterate any land defence, even if a sea invasion wasn't possible at that point then the ability to destroy British targets at will with no way for us to fight back would have lead to us having no choice but to sue for peace.
 
Last edited:
Operation Sealion had 160,000 Heer troops in French ports in june 1940 - the only thing between them and an assault on the UK was that small strip of water.

Numbers of troops are irrelevant if you cannot get them across the water controlled by your enemy.

The concern was the RAF and the fleet of fast light and medium bombers - and a lot of fighters. So the main objective was to eliminate the aircraft and the eyes before a naval landing. Thus we had the Battle of Britain.

Really the Battle of Britain is also irrelevant to a landing. It was about trying to intimidate Britain into signing a peace deal to allow the Germans to have their war on the continent. The Germans never appreciated the worth of the radar stations. This allowed Fighter Command to concentrate their resources where it was needed rather than having planes scouring the skies for the enemy.


The cost was high for both sides - but Operation Sealion was cancelled on October 11th - as Goering had not delivered the Air Supremacy he had promised.

German air supremacy would have made the Navy's battle harder but the outcome would never be in any doubt. Germany never had enough capital ships to shield their invasion barges.
 
Greece's tantrum appears to be causing Germany to toughen up their stance:

SPD leader Sigmar Gabriel (German vice chancellor) has for the first time admitted that it was a mistake to allow Greece to join the euro zone. “The entry of Greece into the euro is carried out from today’s perspective, very naive,” Gabriel said in an interview with Stern. “Worse is that all have watched far too long” as the country fell deeper and deeper into crisis, added the Vice-Chancellor.

"If Greece wants to stay in the euro, the Greek government must quickly make a substantive offer that goes beyond its willingness thus far", Gabriel, who is also leader of Germany's centre-left Social Democrats, told a news conference.
 
They could have very easily have beaten us if Hitler had not messed it up, Goring had the battle of Britain won, the RAF was down to it's last fighters, the were zero reinforcements, Churchill was informed that the Luftwaffe would have total air dominance over Britain in a week. Then RAF bombing of German cities angered Hitler so much that he ordered Goring to ignore the RAF bases and target London/etc instead, that one screw up change the course of the battle of Britain in our favour, we were able to regroup and fight back.

German never had enough planes to even replace those lost in the BofB. Britain was producing them far quicker. They never targeted the centres of war production enough to make a difference. See my later post about radar.

Had that not happened then with air dominance the Luftwaffe would have cut the Royal Navy to pieces and obliterate any land defence, even if a sea invasion wasn't possible at that point then the ability to destroy British targets at will with no way for us to fight back would have lead to us having no choice but to sue for peace.

Rubbish. The Germans never had enough planes. They also never had enough of the types of planes to target our Navy. That is even disregarding the numbers that would have been lost to Naval gun fire. An invasion was never a possibility.
 
I really don't want to dwell on this as it's OT, however:

They could have very easily have beaten us if Hitler had not messed it up, Goring had the battle of Britain won, the RAF was down to it's last fighters, the were zero reinforcements, Churchill was informed that the Luftwaffe would have total air dominance over Britain in a week. Then RAF bombing of German cities angered Hitler so much that he ordered Goring to ignore the RAF bases and target London/etc instead, that one screw up change the course of the battle of Britain in our favour, we were able to regroup and fight back.

Had that not happened then with air dominance the Luftwaffe would have cut the Royal Navy to pieces and obliterate any land defence, even if a sea invasion wasn't possible at that point then the ability to destroy British targets at will with no way for us to fight back would have lead to us having no choice but to sue for peace.



no they did not have us beaten - stop reading revisionist history.

We had 1 thing the germans did not - an effective pilot rescue system , which worked when you look at the amount of aircrew killed in action vs aircraft lost.

we also had a rough parity in serviceable aircraft

that's the important part - whilst the germans had more aircraft at the start, the ratio of 4 to 3 in those which were serviceable -

that and having the crews to fight them. the brits shot down more aircraft and killed more aircrew.

technically it was over by august 12th - goering had lost the bulk of his bomber force , the 109 could outclimb the spitfire , but the spitfire could out turn it ; the stuka force had been swept from the sky - so the ability to accurately hit radar was all but gone.

the hardest day was the turning point - the RAF kill ratio was 2:1 , and they maintained close to that for the whole battl.e

so please , don't say we were close to losing - - after august Goering didn't know what to do and was running out of the aircraft to do it.

why? the UK were cranking out near 500 aircraft a month - and with pilot recovery - we hade the crews to fly them. the Germans did not - for each pilot and crew killed - the same number were captured.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom