Carrick is great with the ball in general, the issue is the rest of the team around him and the way we implement LvG's 'vision'. Put Pirlo, Alonso, Xavi, Scholes or any of the great deeper playmakers into our team and we would struggle just as much as we do now.
Our defence constantly has either 2 midfielders in it or some u18/21 that many would never have heard off before this season, and while Borthwick Jackson, McNair or Valera have done well they should really be no-where near the match day squad for an important trip to Chelsea.
Its criminal that we are so short on quality defenders, as much improved as Smalling has been he's not good enough to turn an average defence into a good one like Ferdinand could do when partnered with Silvestre, O'Shea, Evans, Jones, etc or in fact anyone or has the ability to dominate a forward line on his own ala Vidic.
Then add the fact that we have Fellaini as our 'default' midfielder when both Herrera and Schniederlin are fit and an attack that relies on Rooney having a good game to work (thank the various deity's that he's found some form again) the fact that we are still 5th amazes me.
We simply don't have the personnel to play the way our manager wants us too, and after 2 seasons and a shed load of money that's his fault, it's also his fault that he is completely unable to change things up to better suit who he has available. He's worse than me in Football manager when all I do is swap 1 player out for another in exactly the same position and role when I'm losing.
@The Running Man - Either you were in a coma for the last 8 Fergie years or you've had a terrible terrible stroke, neither is an excuse for that post and I demand compensation for having read it.
![Big Grin :D :D](/styles/default/xenforo/vbSmilies/Normal/biggrin.gif)