Bit like saying Bioshock had a better story than The Witcher 3.....
Nice try, James, good digging
The difference is, I only gave an example of Bioshock's story and premise being one of those I found more intriguing in comparison to W3's main story arc, which was painfully average compared to very good sidestuff writing. Only that one aspect and nothing else. I didn't compare other mechanics, content etc. nor said Bioshock was objectively a better game than W3 overall AFAIK. And most importantly, I actually finished the two titles, not played one for a few hours and compared the amount of recycled content and the storylines, which cannot be done at that point, to illustrate the overall superiority of a given game.
It's kinda hard to connect the dots between "tired of Soulslike" and recycled content/no emotional story, it isn't even the argument that was put forward in the first place, nor is it an argument by which to judge the quality of a game, that's all.
I'm actually fine with comparing GoG and ER in terns of story if one wishes to do something so unproductive, comparing stories between genres is usually one of the more reasonable things one can compare in such cases so
But yeah, wasn't the most fortunate comparison on my part either and I explained myself poorly, so if we really have to dig up stuff from 7 years ago to illustrate how poor the comparison here is then I'm fine with it, I think it's actually beneficial.