• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Hard drive disassembly and changing

Soldato
Joined
24 Dec 2011
Posts
4,738
After taking apart 6 old hard drives at work today to destroy them i was thinking with the current prices would it be worth removing the platters from 5200rmp drives (IDE) which are my old ones.. And putting them in a newer 7200 sata hdd drives to avoid having to buy newer sata drives of 1tb+ .. ODD question but i just wonder :) As i may try it
 
Not sure, they came out the drives easily today. Its down to destroy them by bending in half or cutting (some are glass so just are broken) to prevent people doing this exact thing of retrieving data from the drive. (Company info lol)
 
well, I doubt you could just put a platter in a different hard drive and expect it to work? The density and things would be different? Probably best just to destroy them
 
If you remove the platter in anything other than a clean room then it's useless. Also the HDD controller chip is matched to the drive so unlikely it would work anyway.
 
Even the tiniest speak of dust on the disk would stop it working. Since the platers aren't designed to spin at 72k they might just break. I think but don't know for sure that the size of the disk is programmed into the firmware so you couldn't like make them into a 1tb disk from more.

I don't think this is something you could do.

Edit: I see people posted about the same thing above while I was typing.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a clean room, ability to retool PCBs and a excellent working knowledge of magnetic data storage and retrieval mechanisms? If so, you're laughing
 
Clean room.. Yes! To the rest though no, Just thought it might be a cheap way of me getting some more use out of now useless shelved hard drives
 
When they're saying clean room though - they don't mean you've had a whip around with the hoover :p Most hard drive recovery places seem to have a controlled sealed room, with an air filtration system running, and inside that a cabinet with it's own filtration system where they work on the drive. Bearing in mind the staff will be wearing full clean suits etc. as well as any dust on the platter will probably ruin it.
 
I'd say go for it. If it works, then you have save some quid from buying a new HDD, if not, then, at least you've tried and haven't lost anything.
 
I'd say go for it. If it works, then you have save some quid from buying a new HDD, if not, then, at least you've tried and haven't lost anything.

Many have tried this before and have wasted their time as it cant be done but its interesting just to take one apart but watch the platters as they will shred into thousands of sharp pieces if broken.
 
Depends if platter is glass or metal though. We have pulled out both in past.

Might do it and youtube it. Even a disassembly video is interesting
 
Back
Top Bottom