Not really hiking/backpacking as such, but since I couldn't find a general camping thread, this is probably the most appropriate.
Looking for a new family tent - we're going away at the end of August, so got our current 5 man (Coleman Mosedale 5) out to check over, and was reminded that it has a cracked pole, broken zip, and several tears/holes in the flysheet. All stuff that's relatively easy to repair, but it's a pretty cheap and cheerful tent anyway, and we seem to crack a pole every time we use it (appears to be a common issue if online reports are anything to go by).
Debating the merits of another cheap tent to last a couple of years again, vs paying a bit more for something which will last a lot longer.
I'd really like to go cotton/polycotton - the polyester ones are so stuffy, and basically unusable when it's hot; even worse when it's raining but muggy - you end up with the choice of going out and getting soaked in the rain, or staying in and getting soaked with sweat.
Was initially looking at a used Outwell - someone selling a Wolf Lake 5 not too far from me which seems to be the right size for us, polycotton, pretty cheap, however I just find tunnel tents so bland and ugly (plus a pain to put up.
Then I've done something stupid and started looking at bell tents, and almost pulled the trigger on a 5m one plus porch, for almost 4x the price
. I love the look of them, how cosy and versatile they are, and how quick & easy to put up, but not so sure about the practicality side, and obviously there's the fact the packs are massive!
We don't tend to go to big campsites, more the quieter "nearly wild" basic sites, and maybe 2-3 times a year for a long weekend. I'm thinking if we had a nicer tent, we might try to make that more often.
TL;DR - polycotton tunnel vs bell tent for a family of 4 plus dog - thoughts from anyone who has tried both? Or just grab another cheap and cheerful option from Go Outdoors (I get a 15% discount) - the vanguard 6 in particular is a tempting option right now.