I've tried all sorts. Membrane (bleh), scissor (1/2 way between membrane and mechanical), and mechanical (MK-85).
I will pretty much never buy a membrane keyboard again. I really like the scissor switches (Logitech UltraX Premium, Logitech Illuminated Keyboard). And getting use to the mechanical keyboard, but it's quite different.
For typing, I really liked the L.I.K. Very quiet, low profile, illuminated. It was OK for gaming, the tactile feel is firmer than the UltraX or indeed the mechanical.
Basically, all three very good for typing, the mechanical feels like it will be better for gaming. More consistent (switch is Cherry MX Brown, but quasi-linear), built like a tank, with all the bells and whistles (NKRO, macros, usb ports).
It's a personal thing in the end. best have a look around. the Enermax Aurora apparently is similar to the logitechs with scissor keys.