Thought I’d give this a go over Christmas as well and after half a day applying the patches I’ve spent about 6 hours on it and at the moment I just get the feeling that it’s just a polished Guild Wars style of game the main difference being that you have to pay monthly to play.
I hope things improve as I was looking forward to this. Can some current players give some insight into the better points of the game?
Eric.
having played both games i can honestly say Lotro is nothing like GW's however AoC felt like GWs with a subscription.
as a fan of Tolkien the game has an instant attraction, you get to vist all the famous places which graphically surpass all other MMO'S.
you can happlily plod along questing or go sight seeing, plus you get to follow the story via the Epic quests..
you have a more mature community (not saying its perfect) but on for example RP Laurelin the chat channels arent filled with abuse idiots, and advice is given quickly when asked for ... afterall the community can make or break said games...
crafting is actually helpful as you progress up the levels and continue's to be a good source of steady income selling materials....
later in the game you get small fellowship instances that last between 30-60mins which are superb, or you can join latrge instances taking days to complete....
you can create a 'Creep' enter the ettenmoors area and fight fellow 'freeps' for keeps and various strategic points, tis broke since MoM but it can actually be more fun than PvE ....
the only MMo ive not tried is WoW, but from all the others ive subbed to Lotro is the only one that kept me coming back, i bought a lifetime about 9mths ago and havent regretted it.... best MMo since Star Wars Galaxies