I'm someone who cannot post within SA because i think i am superior but really i'm not due too many issues within my life where i have been belittled
just did some extensive reading on barefoot walking/running, etc. it seems as though there is a strong chance my professional physiotherapist is wrong.
i have now came to the conclusion that, i should throw out all of my shoes and only wear vibram five fingers or go barefoot whenever possible.
shoes are causing the problem, and most likely what caused me to have collapsed arches and, since wearing insoles i have actually developed severe pains in my good knee, i mean so much pain i struggled to stand on it.
barefoot is a lot healthier for your foot, joints, bones and knee's. by going barefoot it forces you to walk, run and lift properly, the way the body was designed to do so.
read below for more information:
So, if you feel that I am wrong about recommending Vibrams to people with your condition, please read these articles written by and about people with flat feet and collapsed arches who ran in Vibrams without issues and even found their legs and feet much stronger and healthier and even gaining their arches back. I beg you, I beg you, I beg you not to pass judgment without reading each of these articles. I have quoted a few specific quotes from the articles in this post, but each article contains more information:
http://venutip.com/content/flat-footed-runner-tries-vibram-fivefingers
People in this thread state that their feet actually adapted and began to have arches:
http://birthdayshoes.com/forum/five...ussion/flat-feet-and-the-vibram-five-fingers/
This man had "clinically-diagnosed arch problems as a child -- flat feet supreme -- and was prescribed not only custom orthopedic insoles but also exercises for the feet themselves, rolling up towels with the toes, etc."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/tim-ferriss/the-barefoot-alternative_b_207121.html
He reported these results after wearing the VFFs:
"Needless to say, the exercises fell by the wayside, and I took to increasing levels of support through the shoes themselves. VFFs have been nothing short of spectacular for me, despite my history of flat feet.
Barefoot runners are often asked "but what do you use for arch support?", to which they respond: "your arches". I've found that my arches, and foot as a whole, feels better with less support rather than more."
This article:
http://buyvibrams.com/why-buy-vibrams/vibram-five-fingers-and-flat-feet
Says that
Many people who want to buy Vibram Five Fingers or other 5 finger shoes are concerned because they have flat feet or a collapsed arch. It’s easy to see how this could raise some concern, but there’s good news. Barefoot running actually helps people with flat feet.
A collapsed arch, or flat feet, can be caused by improper running form. When you slip on a pair of 5 finger shoes, you are forced to correct your stride. The arch in your foot is actually composed of a series of muscles, tendons, and ligaments. The arch is supposed to be there to help absorb the impact of running. When you are wearing a traditional running shoe, you completely eliminate the need for that arch since it is molded into the shoe.
Take this as a comparison. If you were to wear a cast on your hand for 18 years, would your hand have any strength? The answer is no, your hand would likely be held to whatever form it has been held in for 18 years.
To get back to the point, Vibram Five Fingers actually aid people with flat feet. Many people have recovered from a collapsed arch or developed one by changing their running style. With 5 finger shoes, the runner is unable to run on their heel, and subsequently run on the balls of their feet. In turn, the lower leg muscles and muscles in the feet are strengthened.
A Harvard Professor has reviewed the health benefits of barefoot running and shared it with Nature Video. We suggest you watch his video; Harvard Professor’s View of Barefoot Running
http://www.runblogger.com/2011/01/stories-of-success-running-in-vibram.html
This one says that
"Almost two years ago, according to a podiatrist, I had posterior-tibialis insertional tendonitis. He recommended more support and rest, but even with my urging didn't check wear pattern or watch me run. Although flat footed, I am pretty neutral. I think the injury came from an "update" to a favorite shoe. The "update" had an increased heel-forefoot drop, increased arch support and stiffened midsole. My guess is that rather than too little support, there was too much support and pressure on the posterior tibial tendon at the navicular bone, but who knows?
After a few weeks of rest, I decided to go 180 degrees from the recommendation. I got rid of my shoes and insoles and switched to Vibram Fivefingers KSOs. Within two months I had adopted a midfoot/forefoot landing and was running 15 miles on concrete/asphalt in my KSOs. I alternated the KSOs with neutral trainers and racing flats.
About 9 months ago, I retired my KSOs and started running about 80% of my miles in my new Bikilas, including 18 mile long runs and speed workouts. The remainder of my runs have been in racing flats and barefoot. I now believe that starting out barefoot would have been even more helpful. I’ve had no additional injuries (still have 10 year chronic high hamstring tendinopathy...but that’s another story). It’s now cold, icy and snowy here in Chicago, so I’m primarily using my flats (even tried a trail shoe for a few runs) until it warms up."
Here is:
http://www.supplementreviews.com/vibram/five-fingers
A review of VFFs (they were given 10/10 for weightlifting and a 10/10 for running) by a person with "fairly flat feet and generally poor posture, but my Vibrams are very comfortable and I’ve noticed that my posture has greatly improved during my cardio sessions. Additionally the burn throughout my calves during these workouts is FAR more intense and satisfying."
I found ARTICLE after ARTICLE written by people with YOUR condition who reported much healthier feet, arches growing back, less pain in their feet and other joints, better run times, and so on. Tons of benefits for people with YOUR specific condition.
Now, on to the other thing mentioned. Many people recommend the VFFs for squats and deadlifts because MOST people who train want a shoe that is good for that AND running/doing cardio. This is where the VFFs excel over proper lifting shoes.
Also keep in mind, I am not recommending flat shoes for you (or anyone). I am essentially recommending no shoes.
The good news is, I may have found you a cure.