Nurse arrested for murdering babies

I totally understand people arguing the reasonable doubt as well as initial incompetence / corruption in the trial and this is not meant as a dig or anything. I am just curious.

is anyone here defending her over and above possible reasonable doubt and believes she is innocent of all counts.?

ie would you be happy if she was cleared of all charges and was your babies neo natal nurse?
How is it relevant what we 'believe' or if we'd be. 'happy'?

There's either evidence for a safe conviction or there's not.
 
How is it relevant what we 'believe' or if we'd be. 'happy'?

There's either evidence for a safe conviction or there's not.
reel it in a bit mate. I have already said I agree it looks like the case was poorly handled and there could be reasonable doubt, perhaps enough for a retrial. I still think on balance of probability she is guilty as sin however I was just curious if anyone here actually thinks she was innocent.

maybe no one told you. this is a discussion forum not a court , we are not on a jury and as such we are allowed to comment on what we "believe".
 
Last edited:
I totally understand people arguing the reasonable doubt as well as initial incompetence / corruption in the trial and this is not meant as a dig or anything. I am just curious.

is anyone here defending her over and above possible reasonable doubt and believes she is innocent of all counts.?

ie would you be happy if she was cleared of all charges and was your babies neo natal nurse?
I think there’s enough to suggest an unsafe conviction and a retrial should take place. Regardless of the outcome she’ll never work again as a neonatal nurse but if she was truly innocent (and I don’t know either way) then she’s also a victim in all of this and the state is at fault.
 
Last edited:
IIRC, and as pointed out in PE, Dr Lee reworked his original paper after the case and after another round of research into the very thing the 'expert' was misusing the original report for. The research found no evidence of skin discolouration as per the prosecutions case. QED, the babies were not killed the way the prosecution said they were. I might add the Dr. Lee has in fact done the legal service a good turn, his paper will never be used again to mislead a jury.

I still think a retrial is necessary, because there is a possibility that one or more murderers are still at large.
 
Back
Top Bottom