As DJ clarified, if there was a query over validity if it appears in the dictionary its a valid entry.
OcUK Beers of the World Mk2 Weekly Results - Round H -
- Thread starter DirtyJester
- Start date
As DJ clarified, if there was a query over validity if it appears in the dictionary its a valid entry.
Soldato
Ah it's a good morning. Particularly cheered me up as last night I was at a 50th party and the only beer they had was Carling. I felt I was punishing myself all night!
If you read the details the beer is palm from "palm brewery nv” that owns local Belgium style beers. Yep it's low alcohol version of palm
Edit : think busch & anheuser busch as the brewery
Last edited:
Much like Brains (S.A. Brain & Company Ltd) however as per Brains, the beer name is not actually Palm. That's the short version of the brewery name which was clarified as not allowed by DJ.
So for Brains beers:
Brains Dark (Dark should be taken as the name of the beer)
Brains IPA etc etc
Look at Palm beers:
Palm Speciale
Dobbel Palm
Palm Royale
It's the same idea, so either Brains is allowed in the same vein as your entry or neither is valid. Either way it's not just up to me so I propose a competitor vote, either both yours and K C Leblancs entries are valid or both are invalid.
Btw not trying to pick on you Squid but as it's the same as K C Leblancs situation it's not fair you getting points and him not as it is currently.
Don
I'm going to side with DJ on this one, SA Gold is the name of the specific beer, if it had just been Brains SA or most of the other Brains lines I would agree as Brains does make up part of the name in most of them.
Edit:
http://www.sabrain.com/beers/take-home/sa-take-home
Actually very few of them.
Edit:
http://www.sabrain.com/beers/take-home/sa-take-home
Actually very few of them.
Soldato
Also that Cuttthroat Porter looks excellent. Where was it from?
- Joined
- 17 Oct 2006
- Posts
- 25,703
Morning/afternoon all, just up...
Firstly Ahleckz entry time was posted for all to see ... 21:32:16
Secondly Squid, sorry mate but this is one I missed in my sleep craving state.
Firstly Ahleckz entry time was posted for all to see ... 21:32:16
Secondly Squid, sorry mate but this is one I missed in my sleep craving state.
Soldato
Hey guys - just in from work and am pleased with another four points in this weeks entry. Also good to see many others receiving top scores as well - shame about Ahleckz but I'm sure he'll not make that mistake again and it gives everyone else a chance to catch up with him 
I was expecting a little controversy re my entry but I can assure you it's in the dictionary thanks to the others who clarified (translated
) my entry as well. 
Had a bottle of that just the other week - agree it's a lovely tasting beer
// Edit - JFro Skull Spllitter was my second choice, glad I didn't opt for that now
I was expecting a little controversy re my entry but I can assure you it's in the dictionary thanks to the others who clarified (translated
) my entry as well. Had a bottle of that just the other week - agree it's a lovely tasting beer
// Edit - JFro Skull Spllitter was my second choice, glad I didn't opt for that now
- Joined
- 17 Oct 2006
- Posts
- 25,703
Skelpt Lug is fine simply because it's slang for a smacked ear (skelp is common in N.I. too) and some of you may find this hard to believe.... but I suffered a few of them as a kid
Points have been updated on page one of main thread: http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18425919
Points have been updated on page one of main thread: http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18425919
- Joined
- 17 Oct 2006
- Posts
- 25,703
Soldato
lolNo excuse you have all week, go sit in the corner with Ahleckz...
Soldato
No excuse you have all week, go sit in the corner with Ahleckz...
Rub it in.
Glad mine is ok, I was a little worried about it, my second choice was Otter Head which would have been a 4 pointer.
Also sent my next entries in DJ.
That was from the excellent and one I'm not naming (it's mine, all mine!) beer shop in Glasgow.
It's brewed by Odell Brewing Co in Fort Collins, Colorado so one you'll probably only find in specialist shops.
Yes from that
Brains original stout
Brains black
Brains bitter
Should be allowed as its clear they are part of the naming of the beer.
And as this list shows
http://palm.be/en/vergelijken.php
On some beers palm is in the name including mine.
Can we look into this ?
Also update page 1 to state the name cannot be "brewery name or Brand Of brewery" as it was only clear if you had read every post on forum. as i missed this and the part that states it was a edit !
http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showpost.php?p=24187255&postcount=3608
http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showpost.php?p=24187255&postcount=3608
Don
I agree with you and what DJ had originally, that Palm NA was the name of the beer as well.