OcUK Mafia game thread -Game 5

Shami I've got no issue with how anyone plays. However if styles change it is something I'll consisdor if there is no over riding reason to vote for someone
 
It's starting to get silly now, still talking about whether I'm tracker. I knew Malteser was the jailkeep yesterday and basically claimed us both, before it was revealed. There's no way I'm not, and even if I wasn't, it would be crazy for the real tracker to stay quiet now.

Thank you for voting. Pudney?
 
chriscubed said:
Can Pudney and Brabbinho vote please with your strongest suspicions?
Click to expand...

It would be Leprechaun, because:

1) his inconsistent approach to aggressive voting, targeting Malt for doing that then applying the same tactic
2) his apparent dislike of gut voting and using questioning to reach a conclusion. Again, inconsistency with not even bothering to do that with me.
3) his immediate defence on day 3 claiming I'm mafia and influencing the vote like I did with 47. Despite me even stating I was voting that way because you made it clear not to vote Malt, making it obvious he wasn't a possible mafia. I even stated I was making that vote to save Malt, not because I thought 47 was a good idea.
4) his certainty to vote for Malt despite a clear message not to from someone who had the highest probability of being the tracker and having useful info.

All the above may be sour grapes that he came out to vote for me straight away, but I think of all the people he has been the most changeable.
 
Pudney said:
It would be Leprechaun, because:

1) his inconsistent approach to aggressive voting, targeting Malt for doing that then applying the same tactic
2) his apparent dislike of gut voting and using questioning to reach a conclusion. Again, inconsistency with not even bothering to do that with me.
3) his immediate defence on day 3 claiming I'm mafia and influencing the vote like I did with 47. Despite me even stating I was voting that way because you made it clear not to vote Malt, making it obvious he wasn't a possible mafia. I even stated I was making that vote to save Malt, not because I thought 47 was a good idea.
4) his certainty to vote for Malt despite a clear message not to from someone who had the highest probability of being the tracker and having useful info.

All the above may be sour grapes that he came out to vote for me straight away, but I think of all the people he has been the most changeable.
Click to expand...

your points are sour grapes because you are mafia and know i have caught you out. From my point of view of being town and chris being town you are mafia, unless shami and brabb have done something beautiful by voting for each other to throw people off. But assuming one of brabb and shami is townie by the vote for brabb from shami you have to be mafia.
 
Pudney said:
Yeah, I feel bad that it's sour grapes! So:

vote leprechaun

Also, I think it's interesting both lep and Shami have avoided directly pointing the finger at each other as one of their main 2 suspects.
Click to expand...

The reason i haven't pointed at shami is because until now i thought he was town for sure. I will worry about him and brabb tomorrow, atm you are my focus as i know for sure you are mafia, you have to be unless shami is voting brabb to throw people off
 
Though if Brabb and Shami were doing that, i'm certain that they would have jumped on my vote for pudney, and they haven't so i think my assumption is right, out of Brabb and Shami one is town one is mafia
 
Wouldn't that have looked a little suspicious if after being entirely suspicious of each other me and Brabbinho had both suddenly voted for Pudney :D

Leprechaun keeps saying he is town, perhaps to detract attention from himself? The only thing we know as a group is that Chris is town and 2 from the other 4 are mafia. Continuously claiming you are town is pointless.
 
Shamikebab said:
Wouldn't that have looked a little suspicious if after being entirely suspicious of each other me and Brabbinho had both suddenly voted for Pudney :D

Leprechaun keeps saying he is town, perhaps to detract attention from himself? The only thing we know as a group is that Chris is town and 2 from the other 4 are mafia. Continuously claiming you are town is pointless.
Click to expand...

Well i know i am, all i am trying to do is convince people
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom