Soldato
The truth is that OLED's have 0.1ms pixel response time and LCD can't touch that - the absolute best of the best LCD gaming monitors come in at 2-3ms and the average gaming monitor is more like 6-10ms.
Because of that, the OLED will always produce a cleaner image with greater clarity which makes it easier to spot targets in a competitive fast paced game.
OLED TVs do have more input lag though but its still very low (as low as 4ms at 120hz 1440p)
Once we get OLED monitors with all the post processing turned off that TVs use, it's game over for LCD.
At the end of the day LCD can't match this, its simply impossible - which image would you prefer to play your multiplayer game on?
Right hand one - because it doesn't have black dots all over it!
No seriously. Pixel response time has noting to do with input lag. If you are a gamer in FPS, driving or piloting games - you need low input lag.
The way OLED manages it's clarity is, through pixel response time, so no ghosting as you display in your image. But if you are asking which multiplayer FPS, then I'd say the RH image if the input lag or input response time made it 'feel' like I was playing the game.
You are comparing apples to oranges.