• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

**** Original Starcraft 2 Thread ****

Was lucky enough to see the last July vs Bomber game and the whole finals... worththe watch!, all very gg's

I was saying that, Dreamhack has him in the brackets as a Brit, TL database says he's swedish though :confused:.

Ahh right, Nah he's swedish afaik! :)
 
Bah, I've played on Tal'darim Alter vs Zerg twice now, both times they just built loads of muta and easily destroyed me!

http://www.sc2rep.com/replays/(P)Iviv_vs_(Z)Eazy__sc2rep_com_20110621/10127

The problem is I can't see a way to safely expand. Besides the natural, there's no way to protect my main/natural + any other expansion, the mutas can just fly between them while my stalkers have to march across. Even with blink its not enough :(

Any tips? Besides build more cannons, I started to get some up once I saw the spire, but there were just too many of them. I know I should harass more, but equally I was expecting to be harassed, so kept back for defense.
 
kept back for defense.

This is basically the reason you are losing to Mutas, you can not win a game where he has Mutas by sitting around and defending. This applies to pretty much anything zerg can do, you HAVE to be offensive in some way, even if it's just denying map control with Phoenixes or running zealots into his expansions, whatever it is he has to be the one defending.

At the moment my favourite build against zerg, especially on large maps like Alter, is Forge FE into 5/6 gate blink stalkers, usually start with a blink & +1 timing attack and later templars or some sort. You can not act passive against a zerg with Mutas, it will always end in a loss for you unless you have crazy unit retention and just wait till he mines himself out, however he will get Broodlords before he gets close to this and you will just die.

DT's are amazing for this reason as they give your opponent "The Fear", they also give you Archons which with stalker/sentry support just don't die to Mutas. Ever. Get aggressive early on, force him to be defensive with his Mutas, whilst doing this get DT's and take a third whilst throwing DT's at his bases.

Also that replay link isn't working for me so can't comment much on that exact game, also I'm only Gold (doing pretty well) so take what I say with a pinch of salt.
 
Last edited:
Mutas are a royal pain in the backside. Marines can destroy them quite well if they stim and focus fire. ALWAYS focus fire with small groups, proves so very effective. Bunkers work well too, mutas do crap damage against them but the 4/6 marines causes problems to the mutas.

Zerg cannot really go mutas without an expansion, so snipe that when you can. My tactics usually revolve around sniping expos when i can and just beat them on macro and starve them out. Sometimes they go uber turtle but if you have 4 expos and they only got their main, they have zero chance.
 
Also that replay link isn't working for me so can't comment much on that exact game, also I'm only Gold (doing pretty well) so take what I say with a pinch of salt.

http://www.sc2rep.com/replays/download/id/10127

That one work?

I'm only silver, so take any advice given at this point XD

On the bright side, I'm deffinately improving. I started out loosing most of my games, but I'm now almost 50th in the league, though the massive bonus pool I have can't hurt either. Doubt I'll make it into gold for a while, but I'd like to see myself around the top of silver somewhere XD

I suffer from the inability to attack early on, I spend too much time turtling and building up a sizeable force before actually attacking, though I've started to warp prism harass, dropping zealots into the opponents mineral line when I get the chance. And if they're slow to react, pulling the prism back a little and warping more units in as well. Hopefully I'll start to time this with a push to split his army/get an easy expo kill.
 
After watching the replay, all I can really tell you is this.

You were in far positions on a massive map, you opened up 2 gate and spammed zealots but didn't put on any pressure, you did scout an early roach warren though you already had 2 gates up at this point, you also waited a long time to get an immortal out after seeing roaches whilst having the robo and resources.

To put it bluntly, far positions on a big map means you are literally obliged to fast expand with immunity.

In that game he had 5 roaches at your base at 6:30, you had 2 gates and a robo building, you had scouted the early roach warren (A warren that early is ALWAYS a roach rush, either all in or pressure), you were taking an expansion but cancelled to defend.

I just played a game vs AI, at 6:30 with a Forge FE I had a completed Expo with several probes, 1 gate, 1 core, 1 assimilator with second almost done, a forge and 3 cannons (more than enough to see off his roaches), 1 zealot and 2 nearly completed additional gates. This with almost constant prope production after halting to get up a forge/nexus/canon/gateway.

Honestly from my experience you should always be planning to fast expand in some manner at the start of the game, if you scout something untoward your reaction should be to augment the FE if you can or cancel it and defend.
 
Last edited:
I havn't watched the game as i'm at work. however if your letting him get this many mutas by sitting back and defending then its not surprising why your losing too it.

Especially on huge maps like this, as Protoss you get a free expansion as it is.

A good way to overcome muta harassment / muta play is to wack down a cannon or two at your expansion/main - This is by no means to kill off the mutas, but more to delay them. They can't attack your mineral line if theres cannons there, and it buys you the extra few seconds to run your stalkers back too them or warp in some more. Be careful, don't build too many cannons. 2 is enough, 3 at a push. anything more is over-kill

Good Zergs, While their harassing you with mutas, will generally run away from any stalker defence as they need to keep all they can for the mid-game muta/ling push. They will also expand while their doing this, so you need to be sending out a few zealots/DT's to deny the expands.

Blink stalkers walks allll over mutalisks. If your in a defensive position with them.. don't burn the blink cooldown untill the mutalisks are flying away. You'll kill more of them :)

This game is all about reactions and decistion making. so if he's using 6-8 mutalisks to harass you and never see anymore through scouting, then he's probably tech switching to a hydra/roach build. in which case you'll want to get your colossi out. If the muta fleet is getting bigger and bigger, or if you see +1 air attack on them. you should really start thinking about a HEAVY stalker build, mixed in with some templar tech. Sentry's will be awesome too.

Alex or Rob may be able to advise you better than myself, both very good protoss players. But yeah, thats my 2 cents from a Zergs point of view. currently sitting in the top end of diamond.
 
Thanks for the advice. Against zerg I'd always been working on the assumption I should sit back and let them attack since a maxed protoss army should be more powerful than a maxed zerg army. So let them attack, they lose most of their army, I can immediately warp in to get back up to max and then push through to their base. I'll deffinately have to be more aggressive in the future then, thanks for the pointers. And I did have cannons down, but 30 mutas just tore through them easily, as well as anything I warped in. Tried to transition to phoenixes but much too late.
 
Don't sit back against Zerg, they will take thge map and soon be able to replenish a full 200/200 army in about 20 seconds.

The more aggressive you are, the more mistakes they will make. they will skip overlords, skip units. saying that, you have to keep up your macro while you do it :)
What also happens when your aggressive is that zerg has to spend more on units rather then getting drones. If you let them power drones for the first part of the game you may as well just quit. because you won't be able to out macro them :)
 
....the assumption I should sit back and let them attack since a maxed protoss army should be more powerful than a maxed zerg army.

Yeaaa shame it doesnt actually work like that. :p One finds that a protoss deathball is just as susceptable to death by positional weakness as any other race, and as zerg uses more higher tier units and most importantly infestors then I think we'll find that it can be just as balanced as any other race's maxed army.

Ok, about the game!

(quick note: by a saturated base I mean at least 16 probes on a mineral line)

Build Advice

Gas Income:
If you put 3 in the gas as soon as your cyber core starts you'll have enough gas to start warp gate immediately when the core finishes. Because of the late cyber core and very late gas income you were stuck building zealots for a long time. In this situation you are seeking actively to do damage while your zealots still have high utility against your opponent's units and economy (queens in particular), rather than investing those minerals in, say, an expansion of your own. I would suggest that if not expanding early you'd be better off with a gate->gas->core->more gateways build.
Quick question: Was the robotics tech a response to seeing the roach warren?

Probe Production:
You shouldve bad enough probes at your main to just about saturate the main and the expo by the time it finished, so you wouldve instantly had 2 fully functional bases. Remember you get additional income for every probe up to 3 per mineral line. So that's up to 24 probes to maximise your income on an 8 patch mineral line. Generally as you get to 4-5 mining bases you want about 2 on each mineral line because the 3rd probe will give less marginal income than the other 2. But this means that you can keep building probes in your main and keep getting more income. This is very very important when taking on terrans, because you have to expand ahead of them to stay ahead, and you have to use chronoboost on probes to equalise on income.
Also don't forget that you can have more than one nexus building probes. This is incredibly important for fast expand builds, because you can chronoboost out twice the probe production and match, if not surpass drone production from a zerg, while still being able to build an attacking force. It is also very useful when you have a main and natural that are still unsaturated at 14:20. You ended up in a position where you were slowly building probes one by one from 0 at your third when you could have had a saturated main and 25-30 probes at the natural. Transfer the excess over 16 probes to your third and you have a near fully saturated mineral line. You'd be surprised how fast 3 nexuses worth of chronoboosted probes can make up the difference and get you a fully functional base running.

A note on probes in the gas:

I've never considered rallying 3 probes of production to the gas, although from what I can see there, it may lead to mistakes such as too few or too many probes in a given geyser. As your game improves and you become more focused on other stuff it'll be more difficult to have that focus to re-rally your nexuses like that. I would suggest that if you want to put probes in gas, just box 3 of them and click on the geyser. Keep building probes as normal from your nexus and you never have to worry about going back to reset rally points or anything like that. Just less to worry about over all :)

Unit producing structures:
I was a bit confused when you added 2 more gateways and a stargate, but continued collossus production. This brought you up to a total of 6 gateways, 1 stargate and 1 robo facility. All this was added and you had 200 minerals and roughly the same amount of gas. And your 4 existing gateways were ready for a production cycle! If you'd taken a third just before then it wouldve made sense, but don't go overboard with unit producing structures if you can't build out of them. Your money was keeping pretty low that game, partly because you needed more probes :D, so you were certainly ok on structures. Did you panic and want to mass stalkers and phoenixes? 4 gates + a stargate wouldve been fine. But you also made collossi so you were never going to have the resources to sustain that production.


Unit based advice

About zealots:
At about 7:00 we see how bad zealots are at dealing with roaches. It's ok to keep producing a few more zealots against zerglings but either way you need to get stalker production started a bit earlier. Stalkers scale well against zerg compared to zealots as you approach the midgame and actually do ok against zerglings when not surrounded and supported by a few zealots. As you approach the mid-lategame zealots should generally be a lesser part of your army composition (unless they really are just going pure zergling in which case roflirl and build zealots :D. But chances are that they're teching to mutas in secret). This is a problem I have, that I rely too much on being able to build chargelots as a core part of my army and they just get destroyed against a late-game zerg army.


Dealing with roaches:

Don't bother, it's gg as soon as they start massing them.

Dealing with mutas:
Don't bother, it's gg as soon as they start massing them.

...:p

Seriously though, in both cases, it's all about stalkers. If your opponent starts investing in roach upgrades, get an observer out, a few immortals and get blink! Also keep investing in attack upgrades. Alright let's do this seriously..

Dealing with roaches:
In the early game the most important thing is having something that'll hold a roach all-in, especially while expanding. This can take one of two forms: stalkers or cannons. I like to play a very greedy mass-expand style so I tend to rely on having one or two cannons at the natural at the start to guarantee my early nexus. If you don't want to expand that quickly invest in some stalkers. Any zerg will also tell you that forcefield from sentries is just a pain, because they can't just take their roaches, run in and take advantage of the range 4 and frankly unreasonable damage on roaches to smash you apart. Get the right position and you cut their army in half, then a quarter, then an eighth and suddenly all of their units are vulnerable to stalker fire. A few pew pews later, they have nothing left and you're free to secure another expansion :D

Dealing with roaches later on:
Roaches are one of zerg's best scaling units, and best of all they're super cheap. They get huge gains from +attack upgrades (don't let the +1 fool you, if you look at the attack values they go up by more than one :eek:). So while your army dies, they can replenish their roaches in greater numbers for a lower cost. Conclusion: Don't let your army die. There are a few ways to go about this in the mid-late game.
1. Collossus deathball - Yea ok, not that interesting but it can get the job done if you have ok positioning. I'm not sure how unbeatable it is as a counter now that zergs are using better units in their composition though.
2. Blink Stalkers - Blink stalkers alone are alright against roaches. Blink allows them to stay alive, whereas assuming you have an observer they don't have the luxury of a quick retreat. However, if you get behind at all(!!) on attack and armour upgrades they will just run in and kill you. These battles will be very much about positioning, and sentries with
3. Blink Stalker/Immortal - My personal preference. I've been playing around with responding to mass roach with a 2 robo immortal style on 2 bases with mass blink stalkers. It's actually pretty sweet :D and you can invest in chargelots and templar pretty easily as you secure a third to help deal with hydras and infestors in the lategame. (Templar will be very important in this, as said I use chargelots too much).

Dealing with Mutalisks:
Unless you're being rushed, in which case cannons and stalkers are your friends, mutas will only tend to pop up in the midgame. There are some pretty brutal transitions which if not correctly scouted can take you by surprise whcn 15 mutas waltz into your base and start killing your dudes.
General guidelines -
1. 2 cannons at each mineral line to delay the mutas. They will not destroy them, but they may fend the mutas off for a while and at least give your stalkers time to get there.
2. Twilight council + blink. This should happen ASAP as soon as you know mutas are coming. What makes them so difficult to deal with isnt so much the damage they do (although it is insane), but the mobility they have. So assuming you havent been massing phoenixes from the early game, stalkers with blink are your best option to chase them down. Get as much vision on the map as you can and react as fast as possible with your stalkers as soon as you see an attack vector from the mutas.
3. Armour+shield upgrades. Another thing which makes mutas incredibly annoying to deal with is their bouncing attacks. 3 bounces in total, so a single +1 armour upgrade negates 3 total damage per shot, so +3 will negate up to 9 damage. A worthwhile upgrade to be investing in to be sure!!!
4. HT+Storm. High templar are not what they once were. Once upon a time, as soon as mutas came out, you could drop the templar archives, and as soon as storm and amulet were done you were in pretty good shape. Once mutas were out, you'd warp in 2-3 templar and storm them to hell. Not so any more! Now our core defence is stalkers with blink. But that doesnt mean that storm isnt still useful. It does massive damage, and mutas clump as much as any unit in the game. Of course it's pretty easy to just retreat from a storm, but that's exactly the point. It does some damage and buys even more time for your stalkers to get into a good defensive position. It also delays their harrassment. While your core army continues to get stronger.
Once the HTs are out of storm, you can morph them into Archons. Archons are not very mobile in this context, but in the right spot they'll make mutas their ***** and have them for breakfast.
5. Go kill them?. Funny thing, but mutas are really expensive. Catch an inadequately prepared zerg at the right time before this investment pays off and it's an easy win.

A note on carriers:
Keep building them, they're awesome. :D



A Better Build?

I'm hesitant to do this, because ultimately you should feel comfortable and happy with what you're doing, so I dont want to just come along and preach my favourite style if you're happy with what you're doing. Also I think you have more important things to think about in your gameplay. Your macro is your weakest point, so that's what I'd suggest as a main focus point. Keep those probes building, and get a sense for how much you can do production-wise with the resources you have.

But on Tal'darim I find that the best style is an aggressive mass-expanding style. You need to be able to assert map control and keep the xel'naga towers. Otherwise you end up with the problem of your opponent having a large number of potential attack paths, whether that be generally looping around paths to your 3rd/4th or dropping anywhere around your base (or in this case, muta harrass). The best way to deal with it is vision, and vision is obtained by asserting map control and placing units and observers correctly around the map (zerg has this easy as they can put overlords wherever they like).

So what's a good build? Honestly, I think a 2 gate zealot opening is going to be very weak on Tal'darim. Zerg will almost always fast expand and you'll instantly be behind unless you can pull off a miracle harrassment (due to the long distances). You saw the weakness there when having to deal with roaches. You ended up very far behind.

1. Early Nexus:

The ever popular greedy protoss build. It requires scouting to do effectively (or just luck?), but the idea is essentially to wall off your expansion and build a nexus as fast as possible, with 1 cannon (2 or more if under big pressure) to defend.

2. 3 gate expand:

Yea I always mention this, because it's so good! Can be defensive or offensive, but either way you get an easy expansion from it. Idea: get 2 gas, 3 warp gates and warp enough sentries that you end up with 400 minerals for an expansion.

My preference is an early nexus, because it's not easy to pressure in the early game and it's not easy to guarantee enough damage to justify delaying the expansion. But this section whould be taken with a pinch of salt. Until you're simply dying in the early game, do what works for you. :)

Your main focus of improvement should be on macro and getting into the rhythm of probe and unit production. Once you have that down, you'll already be well into diamond league :D so then we can talk about precise builds.
 
Wowza! Thanks for the post!

Quick question: Was the robotics tech a response to seeing the roach warren?

Unfortunately, no, I always go robo early, since the splash from the colossi works so well against most zerg units. Unfortunately I've only played against a couple of zerg players on the ladder, most of the time its terran or protoss so I don't actually know a whole lot about what's good Vs what for Zerg, but I'm slowly learning! :D

As for the unit structures, that's me overcompensating for how poor my macro is, I generally end up in the later stages of the game having too many resources and no way to spend them, so I've taken to building more unit structures early on so I can quickly spend everything if it gets too high. I was still sticking with collossi because I was expecting lots of ground still, the stargates were there to add on some carriers, but quickly switched to phoenix when the mutas appeared.

I've started along the 2 gate zealot as a good way to wall myself in, as its safer than using the cybernetics core as part of the wall in, and can be completed much faster. Though as you mention it is a somewhat limiting start. When I started playing I really liked to fast expand, but after several games where I couldn't defend it enough, I've fallen into expanding slightly later now, though I've never really used canons except for mineral line protection, so I'll try and get a forge and some cannons earlier.

Side note about upgrades, I always go shields before armour, since the shields regen and they're what get hit first. Is there much difference, or should I deffinately be getting one upgrade before the other?

Once you have that down, you'll already be well into diamond league

I thought I was doing fairly well, up to 50th in Silver, winning around 50%, but I just lost and got booted down to bronze XD
So much for that, time to work my way up again!
 

Yea it is tough to create and defend a walloff sometimes. I've found that an alright-executed gate->core holds off most early aggression, and an emergency forge and chronoboost on zealots will be the key to stopping zergling harrass. What 2 gate will allow you to do is get zealots out quickly to put a bit of pressure on the zerg before they have roaches. Play around with it and see what works. Once they have roaches out though, you need a response :)

I used to open with 2 gate robo as well, no idea why i stopped. :confused: I think I was losing to a 5-6 roach rush on small maps like xel'naga. But I've not seen anything I couldnt hold with gateway openings recently. Fair enough with the collossus transition, it fits in nicely with your early opening. :)

Upgrades are really dependent on the situation. Armour upgrades are generally preferable against terran because of the ever-present threat of emp. Shield upgrades should depend on the units you have and the amount of money you can spare. For the same cost you can get an armour upgrade and a weapon upgrade so I suppose it's really down to what you can fit in cost-wise. If you're going mass archon though, I see no reason not to get those shield upgrades. :D They'd probably work well also with blink stalkers if you're keeping them alive well, for the reason you gave. But only if you can afford them and keep up in weapon upgrades!
 
I thought I was doing fairly well, up to 50th in Silver, winning around 50%, but I just lost and got booted down to bronze XD
So much for that, time to work my way up again!

you must have been losing a lot of games and games to bronze level players id expect.. tbf your probably learn a lot more in bronze and slowly working your way up.
 
Indeedy, Just keep playing and playing, watch your replays of you losing, see the times in the game when people move out etc, what point their weekness is.. and you'll be see massive improvement!
 
Anyone seen the 4 new maps that will be released next season?They are on the PTR server already,and from what I have seen in the pictures they look great.Everyone is whining on TL about them,but it looks like Blizzard did a good job.I hope that some of the older maps will be removed though,like Scrap Station,Delta Quadrant and **** Pits.
 
Delta Quadrant can go die... the rest I can live with!

What are the names of the new ones? be nice to have a little looky!
 
Back
Top Bottom