Question to Vegans and Vegatarians.

Conclusions Red meat consumption is associated with an increased risk of total, CVD, and cancer mortality. Substitution of other healthy protein sources for red meat is associated with a lower mortality risk.



Massive study (110,000+ over 28 years) undertaken at Harvard Medical School.
There are huge issues with that study, many people have written about them, here are just a couple of links which might get you thinking:
http://garytaubes.com/2012/03/science-pseudoscience-nutritional-epidemiology-and-meat/
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/will-eating-red-meat-kill-you/
 
I hate vegetables and don't eat them I am the complete opposite of a vegetarian and it's great as I am not worried about dying from eating it either.

I dont like the idea, small or taste of veg.
 
I don't get vegetarians, vegans for ethical reason almost has some logic, completely daft but logically complete. But vegetarians, don't eat anaimals directly but don't give 2 hoots about what animals died or differed on the way to give you the vegetarian food. E..g, any milk based product, artificially force continuous pregnancy in cows, any male calfs produced as a byproduct are slaughtered and the hefers are incarcerated in conditions worse than free range beef cattle.

Give my a good steak produced from a happy bull any day week over some pretentious pseudo ethical choice to eat quorn burgers and Brussel sprout dip.

I suppose it's a case of "half a loaf is better than none". There are vegetarians who don't eat eggs or dairy products either. They're not vegans - veganism extends beyond diet.

I think it's also the usual human "if I don't see it, it didn't happen" thing. It's easier to ignore the animal origin of cheese and yoghurt than it is to ignore the animal origin of meat.

Brussel sprout dip? Does anyone eat that? I eat vegetarian meals sometimes. I rather like the taste of quorn.
 
There are huge issues with that study, many people have written about them, here are just a couple of links which might get you thinking:
http://garytaubes.com/2012/03/science-pseudoscience-nutritional-epidemiology-and-meat/
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/will-eating-red-meat-kill-you/

I thought the study might be a bit shaky, but I had no idea it was so utterly baseless. He jokes about space aliens causing heart attacks, but that's not much more baseless than the "red meat shortens your life" conclusion. All the study actually seems to show is that people who don't smoke, do more exercise and are more careful about their diet tend to live longer and are more likely to be vegetarians. It's not even just passing correlation off as causation. It's ignoring the correlation that has good evidence of a causal link - smoking, drinking and exercise levels.

I am genuinely surprised at how much credibility such shoddy work has been given.
 
I guess it comes down to the reason you are a vegetarian.

My mate has openly said that he would be fine eating laboratory "grown" steak, as his only qualm with eating meat is the ethics involved in killing an animal solely for human consumption (be that for food, or product).
 
I guess it comes down to the reason you are a vegetarian.

My mate has openly said that he would be fine eating laboratory "grown" steak, as his only qualm with eating meat is the ethics involved in killing an animal solely for human consumption (be that for food, or product).

Have you ever asked his opinion on animals eating other animals?
 
Yeah, he has no issues at all, as other animals are not self aware, and don't "choose" to eat another animal. He is insistent that humans have a choice (but wouldn't go around trying to convert non-vegetarians).
 
Why do people start threads like this?

I mean really what did you expect to happen? All we will end up with is the raving nutters from both sides arguing about protein and how eating meat kills you.

Mods please just lock this before it gets out of hand.

its a good question I thought... I am interested to know what people think... meat grown in a vat is no different to a plant so I would assume vegans and vegies would eat it (but I dont know and am interested to kn ow)
 
Have you ever asked his opinion on animals eating other animals?

Then they spurt this whole lot about reaching a level of intelligence where we can choose not to eat meat. Where as other animals have not reached that level and for them its pure instinct. They'll also try the whole ranching destroying rainforest approach too but dont mention much about the even larger rainforest removal for the planting of soya beans.

Its an unwinnable argument, and while a vegan/vegitarian doesnt bother me at all and I really like some of their food too. I get really irked when they try and convince me im some how morally inferior to them for eating meat.

Its like the religion argument.

You cant win, stop trying. Both sides are absolute in their belief.
 
Utter nonsense! A well balanced vegan diet is far healthier than one that consists of meat every-day, especially if it's red or processed meat!




More nonsense, you do realize that Quorn has a higher protein density than pretty much any meat apart from fish:confused:
Plus many other vegan foods have high levels of protein, difference is most of them don't come with the protein wrapped around a fatty heart attack!!

It doesn't have the amino acid profile than meat has. So yes, you can get a lot of protein from processed foods like quorn, but the nutritional profile isn't quite as good.

However, you can be perfectly healthy eating vegetarian diets, but to get the nutrients you do need to eat a LOT more lb for lb to get the equivalent nutrition - and if you're opposed to highly refined/processed foods, you have to be even more fastidious and ogre-like with your food consumption.

However, ultimately, a well balanced diet is far easier to get all the nutrients - i.e. a meat, fish, fruit, veg, nut, pulse based diet.
 
I don't get vegetarians, vegans for ethical reason almost has some logic, completely daft but logically complete. But vegetarians, don't eat anaimals directly but don't give 2 hoots about what animals died or differed on the way to give you the vegetarian food. E..g, any milk based product, artificially force continuous pregnancy in cows, any male calfs produced as a byproduct are slaughtered and the hefers are incarcerated in conditions worse than free range beef cattle.

Give my a good steak produced from a happy bull any day week over some pretentious pseudo ethical choice to eat quorn burgers and Brussel sprout dip.

Wow, how they treat those poor pregnant almonds, hazelnuts and soy is really really terrible, I guess I'll stop drinking almond milk because of how they treat the product.... wait, did you not mean to say ANY milk product?

Ultimately its a trade off, doing what you can do rather than everything is frowned upon only when someone wants to make a point. Hey the 12,000 animals that you didn't eat in your life is great but you had 1 pint of milk.... you lose, vegetarians are the worst... briliant logic.

Less animals die to support my life than if I was a full on meat eater, hence, I'm happy about that, have I or can I prevent every single animal dying as the result of my personal choices, no, does that make what I can do worthless, no.

Pseudo ethical, lol, others raised the question, take a lion, can you see a lion out in a field, farming an alternative to meat? No, lions have no choice, that is where we are different. We can and do make alternatives, we CHOOSE to eat meat or not and there lies the reason I'm vegetarian, because I chose not to eat meat because I don't have to.

There are places on the planet it wouldn't be possible to be a vegetarian, and places on the planet it makes more sense than not...

It would also be easier to be a vegetarian, infact, insanely easy, if everyone made this choice because every food stuff you could buy would be vegetarian, the industrys and food production would make life much easier for vegetarians and provide less instances of eating a food you didn't know had a animal by-product in.

I don't really care what other people do though, thats up to them, the only time I mention my being a vegetarian is in defence of people who insist on having a go at it. There are a million moral choices people make, everyones moral choices are different, one person thinks eating meat is bad, war is bad, hookers/drugs are fine, another person thinkgs eating meat is fine, war is fine and hookers/drugs are evil.

People are free to make their own choices, I always find it funny that those who are so adamant they are right, are often the most vocal about how their choice is right, and how often it sounds like they are just trying to make themselves feel better.

IE these threads always come across as "I eat animals, I like animals when I really think about how they are treated it kinda sickens me, but I like meat.... look at those vegetarians/vegans not eating meat and making me feel guilty, time to bash them to make myself feel better about my choice".

But hey, you keep making your "lets have a go at vegetarian" threads... I notice a distinct lack of "hey why aren't you vegetarian" threads around here and really all other forums.
 
What do vegans think would happen to animals if we didnt use them ?

Do they think we just keep breeding and looking after them for the hell of it ?

For example do they think we'd let heard a of cows roam around our fields when we now need the land and money to grow veg or to build factories that produce synthetics ?

We'd probably only see cows/chickens/pigs etc in a zoo
 
Top tip

Vegans dont live any longer than a Omnivore and believe it or not a Vegi has a slightly lower life expectancy, due to eating to much dairy products.

And I found that on a vegan website (will look for link)
 
Good argument, DM. :)

I will always choose to eat meat as I enjoy it.

I also wear leather and like it.

If the animal is going to die, I might as well eat it! I have hunted, caught and eaten my own catch too. I think if more people did that they'd get a better understanding of what it's like to actually kill your own food.
 
What do vegans think would happen to animals if we didnt use them ?

Do they think we just keep breeding and looking after them for the hell of it ?

For example do they think we'd let heard a of cows roam around our fields when we now need to grow veg or need the land to build factories that produce synthetics ?

I'm not even sure I know exactly how to reply to this.... without being banned.

Yes veganism could result in the genocide of all the cows we breed for the purpose of eating.... sure sure, eating meat prevents genocide of cows.
 
Top tip

Vegans dont live any longer than a Omnivore and believe it or not a Vegi has a slightly lower life expectancy, due to eating to much dairy products.

And I found that on a vegan website (will look for link)

God damn vegans always lying about vegetarians... :p

Seriously though, all groups of people have an agenda, you'll find a billion meat eaters websites saying its healthier than the other possibilities, and loads of vegetarian websites saying its healthier than vegan/meat eating, and loads of vegan websites that say the other two suck.

Very very VERY little information isn't biased, almost any stat can be used to prove anything you want, almost any research can be picked apart as to where it failed in a way that supports your argument.

Good argument, DM. :)

I will always choose to eat meat as I enjoy it.

I also wear leather and like it.

If the animal is going to die, I might as well eat it! I have hunted, caught and eaten my own catch too. I think if more people did that they'd get a better understanding of what it's like to actually kill your own food.

Thats fine, I don't give a monkeys, if I had no choice I'd eat meat, though I'd far prefer to catch my own wild animals than battery farm food which seems like nothing short of torture to me.

Survival of the fittest I can understand, me a thousand years ago, living or dying on what I can catch, thats fine. Me today in a city with a choice of what to eat is a completely different situation.
 
Back
Top Bottom