radeon 9600 vs gf4ti4400

[bledd]

i've got both spare, putting into an amd 1700+ (clocks to about 2.4iirc)

to be used as a quake + cs machine

which is best!?

thanks

 

[INFECTION]

erm ad go with 9600 coz thats what i got n runs both fine dont know bout the other

 

[lemonkettaz]

definitely the 9600

is it 9600 or pro?

 

[m3csl2004]

actually i think the ti will be a lot faster - ill check

 

[Logsi]

The 9600 will look better because it has specular. An should be faster. Overclock it!!! My 9600 was abeast of an overclocker.

 

[Indy500]

Unless you're using AA\AF (which I doubt the 9600 will handle much of), the Ti4400 will be faster.

 

[foxxx]

people what are you talking about the 9600pro is a much better card, and when oc'd mine ran BF2 all medium @ 1024x768 with 4xAA and high TF fine and i'd love to see a TI4400 do that at all. well he says quake n CS, which versions? 1.6 then either will do, quake 1-2 any will do, q3 or 4 def the ati, and CSS loves the ati so thats no brainer. id def go for the 9600

 

[Indy500]

people what are you talking about the 9600pro is a much better card, and when oc'd mine ran BF2 all medium @ 1024x768 with 4xAA and high TF fine and i'd love to see a TI4400 do that at all. well he says quake n CS, which versions? 1.6 then either will do, quake 1-2 any will do, q3 or 4 def the ati, and CSS loves the ati so thats no brainer. id def go for the 9600

I'm talking about the non pro...and hes only playing quake and CS.

 

[bledd]

just quake 3, cs 1.5 + a few other multiplayer games with crapper graphics


system will be very heavily nlited xp, athlonxp @ 2.4ghz, 2x256mb ddr on whatever hard drive

9600 (non pro)
ti4400 (reference model)

won't be enabling AA or any special features, just a pc made of spare parts for one off lans etc, not REALLY worth selling it all, would rather have the odd weekend of an extra player

don't want the pc to make any noise, so won't be overclocking the gpu as i don't have any blocks for it and the 9600 is fanless, so i'd have to make a cooler for the 4400 if i used that

going to use the 9600 i think

 

[OV3RCLOCK3R]

directx 9, 9600 will be better but in every other situation, i would say the ti4400 has more raw power and will do a lot better in direct x 8.1