Which version of Gish do you have?? The rough?? the original release?? Or the re master??... I use the original release and it is/was the spur for me asre rock recordings... Huge fat sound close miced etc etc.. Of all the criticisms leveled at the album, "Sounding like it was recorded in a bathroom" would be the very last comment I'd make about it.. That, to me, sounds like a phase issue in however you are listening to it... If i do have a criticism, it would be that the Bass end is a tad hyped with the compression used on it...