Good review, just to clear up a few points tho a lot of the problems you have seen Rilot were from the first models that have since been resolved. They know about the alloys/strakes and have taken steps to rectify as well as many of your other points.
I have only had a cold start problem once and that was after the missus decided to take it to Tesco (2min down the road) she simply will not believe me when I say it has to be warmed up on a proper drive first
(most infuriating!).
I dont do the milage you do Rilot as I commute by train to work everyday (its more of a fun weekend car
) But I have done a good amount of motorway driving in it and have to say I havn't needed to drop a cog (let alone 2!) in order to over take (but I guess I am probably doing a little more than 70 not driving at rush hour
).
Also i'd say the torque hits at lower RPM than 5500 (but I do so enjoy hitting 60+mph in 2nd gear).
I haven't as much experiance as yourself driving cars only having my sisters S2000 to compare it to but taking off from the lights isnt as bad as you appear to make out - but as you rightly point out this isnt where the car shines (thats in the handeling).
As for the external styling this is all down personal opinion (other than the fact your review echoed almost exactly what Jeremy Clarkson said in Top Gear
) I love the external look and the flowing nature - much nicer than a RX7 imo and 99% of the other cars on the road.
All in all a pretty good fair review, i'd say only tainted slightly by having one of the early RX8's off the production line.