It was on the horizon, I just rate Castelli very highly and these are proven. I'll be honest, for most clothing I prefer Castelli too. Just not found anything to compare to the Rapha jerseys/jackets.
I got these in a Medium, but I shouldn't have any issues getting a liner in should I really need one! So if it gets really bad I may yet get the rapha merino liners.
Right, well. First journey in these today, ~7oC with probably 3-7oC in wind chill? So, thoughts..
First and foremost, my hands were toasty warm. The warmest they have
ever been on a bike. I realise that it's not yet 'deep' winter, but given how nippy it was when I first set off I think it's a good indication.
The gloves, thus far, are totally windproof. It rained for the first half of my commute this morning, quite heavily, and no water got through, so fairly waterproof, though I'm sure not fully if exposed to rain/spray for an hour+.
My hands did sweat a tiny amount, but there was no discomfort, I felt like they were breathing well. I could fit a liner in there without much issue so should temperatures drop way below zero I can't, yet, see it being an issue.
The only downside is the bulkiness, but given that this is a winter glove I don't think it's too much of a negative. Don't get me wrong, I don't consider them especially bulky, indeed they are less bulky than previous winters attempt at hand protection - a liner and a pair of goretex gloves - but they do make some simple operations difficult. I use 3 keys to get out/in in the morning, and this was ok. Use of rear pockets whilst getting my bike out to the road was not easy (I put keys, and cleat covers into the rear pockets once out), the gloves are well padded so you lose a lot of dexterity/touch, and I would not want to have anything valuable in the rear pockets (not that I do anyway) that could easily be brought out by accident whilst cycling.
Shifting/braking no issues at all, the gloves are cut extremely well to sit comfortably on the hoods. The grip was excellent, and the padding fine.
All in all, a pretty excellent good deep winter glove. Yes they're bulky, but it's understandable given how well insulated they are, I'm almost looking forward to the real cold so I can enjoy my cycling.
Only problem now is that I have nowhere to wipe my nose!